John Putzier

Greater Pittsburgh Automobile Dealers Association

CEO

John Putzier: Lessons from the Great Recession

After owning his own consulting business for 25 years, John Putzier was burning out. In 2010, just as the Great Recession was engulfing auto dealers by the hundreds, he switched gears to represent them.

Advertise with us

He dissolved his practice — Brighton Heights-based FirStep Inc., a firm that consulted with many industries but focused on the auto trade because “a lot of dealers weren’t strong on the human resources side of things,” Mr. Putzier said.

The company helped auto dealers recruit top talent and establish a positive culture. His first client was Saturn before the manufacturer became popular for its famously un-dentable vehicles. He sub-contracted work for J.D. Power, the Costa Mesa, Calif.-based marketing information firm, working with dealerships all over the country.

But it was time to quit living out of a suitcase.

“I was not a happy camper the last few years,” he said. “When you don’t like your job, you don’t like your life.”

In late 2010, Mr. Putzier joined the board of the Greater Pittsburgh Automobile Dealers Association, an O’Hara-based nonprofit supporting more than 200 franchised automobile and truck dealers in Western Pennsylvania, where he now serves as CEO.

Advertise with us
Q: Most vivid memory of great recession?

A: “Surviving instead of thriving, trying to be resourceful, and trying to figure it all out. I couldn’t retire at that age and it caused me to have to dig down and reinvent myself … I think the silver lining of the recession was that it forced me to reinvent myself when I probably should have sooner … how are you going to adapt to this new economy and how do you make yourself have value again?”

Q:What would you do differently?

A: “I would have switched jobs sooner. I wouldn’t have done anything differently, because it worked out for me. I don’t know if it was brilliance or serendipity. Sometimes it’s a combination of hard work and luck.”

He immediately requested an economic impact study be conducted after realizing there was a gap in reports from 2004 to 2011. Still, parsing the old data and comparing it to more recent metrics, Mr. Putzier deduced that the local auto dealer industry hasn’t changed much in the last 10 years or so.

“We didn’t lose sales or customers or market,” he said. “And ironically, we didn’t lose any jobs.”

In 2003, the Pittsburgh region employed 21,600 in the auto dealer industry.

In 2015, he said, there were 22,080 workers.

While data between 2007 and 2009 is missing from the association’s archives, he notes that there has been an overall trend of stability in employment. That’s due to a shrink in shops, he said, with no repercussion in sales.

Advertise with us

“What happened was, during the recession and the consolidation and the bankruptcies, we lost stores but we didn't lose customers,” Mr. Putzier said. “The customers ended up going to different stores.”

John Putzier: Memories of the Great Recession

In 2003, the region had 302 rooftops, or shops, Mr. Putzier explained. In 2015, there were only 200 auto stores left, he said.

Closings came amid sweeping changes at the Big Three auto manufacturers. In 2009, General Motors and Chrysler filed for bankruptcy for 40 and 42 days, respectively. Ford narrowly avoided the same fate by securing a line of credit to protect itself. 

“I saw desperation and frustration around me,” Mr. Putzier said. “I hate to use the Darwinian perspective, but some organizations are destined and ready to fail.

“For the dealerships that survived, they thrived,” he said.

Advertise with us

An average of 490 new cars and 430 pre-owned cars were sold at each auto shop in 2003. According to the association’s most recent data, by 2017, dealers sold an average of 785 new cars and 615 used ones at each location.

“We are selling way more vehicles in 2017 than we did in 2003,” Mr. Putzier said. He noted that the early 2000s might not be the best benchmark year for the impact of the Great Recession, but said the auto industry has “not only recovered but overcome” the hardships it endured from 2007 to 2009.

The average auto dealer in Pittsburgh now sells about $50.4 million in merchandise compared to $28.5 million per shop in 2003.

Like the remaining auto dealers in the region, Mr. Putzier is glad he learned to pivot — and quickly.

“I think the silver lining of the recession was that it forced me to reinvent myself when I probably should have sooner,” he said. “How are you going to adapt to this new economy, and how do you make yourself have value again?”

Advertise with us

Courtney Linder: clinder@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1707. Twitter: @LinderPG.

Join the Tech.pgh Community!

Sign up for Courtney Linder's free newsletter.