Each year, Pennsylvania businesses are required to shop for insurance packages that cover wages and medical benefits for employees injured in workplace accidents. And for the last two decades, insurers have seen the cost of those benefits — a major component in the calculation of insurance premiums — decline by 62 percent.
After a surprise Pennsylvania Supreme Court decision in June, that tranquility could be shattered.
The ruling threw out a key part of the workers’ compensation system that governed how the state has assessed workplace injuries for the past 20 years, alarming businesses and causing state lawmakers to rush to clarify the law.
If nothing is done, the cost of benefits could rise 6.06 percent effective Nov. 1. That would be the highest annual hike in at least 20 years and could translate to double-digit increases in insurance premiums that employers pay.
Created with Highstock 5.0.14Employers face hike after years of cheaper policies Since the 1996 reforms to workers' compensation law, insurers' cost of providing benefits to injured workers declined 62 percent. But after the Pennsylvania Supreme Court struck down part of those reforms in June, insurers and businesses are bracing for the largest annual increase in benefits costs. *The second 2017 figure represents the proposed loss cost increase, effective Nov. 1, 2017, pending approval by the Pennsylvania Insurance Department.Since the 1996 reforms to workers' compensation law, insurers' cost of providing benefits to injured workers declined 62 percent. But after the Pennsylvania Supreme Court struck down part of those reforms in June, insurers and businesses are bracing for the largest annual increase in benefits costs. *The second 2017 figure represents the proposed loss cost increase, effective Nov. 1, 2017, pending approval by the Pennsylvania Insurance Department.-25%-25%-6.94%-6.94%-5.26%-5.26%4.5%4.5%-1.55%-1.55%2.12%2.12%-2.41%-2.41%3.32%3.32%-2.89%-2.89%-8.58%-8.58%2.95%2.95%-10.22%-10.22%-3%-3%0.68%0.68%0.87%0.87%-5.66%-5.66%-4.01%-4.01%-5.15%-5.15%-5.99%-5.99%-0.9%-0.9%-6.21%-6.21%6.06%6.06%Percent change in workers' comp benefits costs1997199819992000200120022003200420052006200720082009201020112012201320142015201620172017*-40%-20%0%20%Source: Pennsylvania Compensation Rating Bureau | graphic: James Hilston/Post-Gazette
The cost projections are coming from the Pennsylvania Compensation Rating Bureau, a private group that influences workers’ compensation insurance rates by collecting information from the more than 400 insurance companies that offer such policies statewide.
That bureau submitted the proposed cost hike on Aug. 15 with the Pennsylvania Insurance Department. If approved, that hike would be factored into the premiums charged by insurers after Nov. 1.
The court struck down a key part of the workers’ compensation law passed in 1996 to limit benefits for the most severe workplace injuries. Under that provision, an employer’s insurance provider could request that injured workers undergo a medical assessment after two years out of the workplace.
If the physician — using guidelines set by the American Medical Association — found that a worker was less than 50 percent injured at that point, the insurer could cap partial benefits at 10 years.
If the physician rated a worker’s injury at more than 50 percent, the worker received full, lifetime benefits.
The state Supreme Court found that the physicians’ reliance on the medical association for the so-called impairment rating evaluations amounted to an illegal “delegation” of state power to a private entity.
Currently, more than 30 states use the AMA disability guidelines in their workers’ compensation laws.
“The Supreme Court ruling was a pretty abrupt change in Pennsylvania law,” said John R. Pedrick, vice president for actuarial services at the bureau. “Companies are not quite sure what the impact of this decision will be in the long term, and we found something we could quantify.”
While severely injured workers make up a small portion of total claims, those cases are among the most expensive and risky for the insurer and most devastating for the employee, Mr. Pedrick said. The court also left open the possibility that any worker injured over the past 20 years whose benefits have been capped — or has settled a workers’ compensation case before hitting that cap — could be eligible to re-file.
Without the evaluations, which are the easiest way for an insurer to cap benefits, the bureau estimated more workers would wind up receiving permanent lifetime benefits.
Department officials will begin reviewing the proposed hike as soon as next month. The bureau’s timing is as unprecedented as the suggested increase -— coming in the middle of a policy year that began April 1.
“We looked at what have today and looked at what we had in 1996,” Mr. Pedrick said. “If the evaluations not in place anymore, what do we revert to?”
In its filing, the bureau told insurance regulators that the evaluations had a positive effect on the system. They “significantly reduced uncertainty for the injured worker, the employer and the employer’s insurer regarding the length of time and the costs of workplace injuries.”
Business groups seized upon the bureau’s proposed hike to criticize the ruling and push state lawmakers to take immediate action.
Kevin Shivers, executive state director of the National Federation of Independent Business, which represents 14,000 employers in Pennsylvania, said the years before the evaluations were defined by “runaway litigation,” soaring medical claims and insurers threatening to leave the state.
“It’s disappointing that an activist state court would strike a 20-year-old law that has stabilized workers compensation insurance rates in Pennsylvania,” Mr. Shivers said.
Lawmakers are scrambling to find a solution before higher rates would be put into place.
Last week, Rep. Rob Kauffman, R-Franklin, and Rep. Garth Everett, R-Lycoming, sent a memo to colleagues about the proposed cost increase and their plans to introduce a bill in September. The legislation, according to the memo, would repeal the part of the law invalidated by the court ruling and pass language that legally authorizes physicians to use the AMA guidelines.
“These worker compensation reforms have been in place for more than 20 years and have worked as intended,” the representatives wrote. “The Supreme Court’s ruling will put workers’ compensation premiums on track to reverse course and increase dramatically.”
Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2743 and Twitter @PGdanielmoore.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.