The picture of a man crouched down and lining up a shot on the golf course -- unaware of the alligator crawling up behind -- is among the more frightening images collected as part of new research on the psychological effects that the recent economic downturn has had on everyday Americans. The barbed wire fence photograph is pretty striking, too.

A Pittsburgh market research firm wanted to get beyond the grind of economic numbers that roll in daily, numbers that offer an analytical view on the sometimes messy business of jobs, homes, pay and spending that help determine how Americans really live.

"I find a lot of those statistics kind of bloodless," said Gerald Zaltman, co-founder of Olson Zaltman Associates, in a phone interview on Friday.

Images that the firm's research subjects -- a diverse collection of 28 Americans, ages 25 to 65 with household incomes between $25,000 and $150,000, from places such as Boston, Kansas City, Dallas and Pittsburgh -- brought in to illustrate how they felt about the economy showed a lot of stress.

Advertise with us

Basically, the researchers found, many citizens in the land of the free aren't feeling easy. They're feeling trapped, discouraged, resentful and fearful -- at least when they think too much about their personal financial situations and that of the country.

"It's not that they dwell on it all day long," Mr. Zaltman said. It would be difficult to survive or function well obsessing about paying for college or the nation's economic difficulties or having to shop at dollar stores and skip vacations.

But the struggle is wearing on them.

Olson Zaltman uses its own patented method to get at unconscious feelings and emotions. It involves studying images chosen by participants and asking them about those choices. Documentary filmmaker Morgan Spurlock came to the firm not long ago to use the method to figure out his own personal brand.

The firm did a similar economic study in 2009. The latest interviews were conducted between late October and January, a period when the Conference Board's Consumer Confidence Index showed improved sentiment nationally, then a dip in January followed by an increase again in February.

Advertise with us

Mr. Zaltman said this study found more hopeful signs than the one done in the depths of the Great Recession. People have learned to be resourceful and are starting to hope things will get better -- chancing the risk they'll be disappointed.

The findings, he said, could be useful for human resources departments in understanding employees' frustrations with job opportunities and pay, as well as for teachers whose students may be in households stressed by economic uncertainty. Even higher income households have been feeling penned in.

Marketers may want to avoid focusing too heavily on low prices, the researchers said. Sometimes those messages make consumers feel like failures, struggling even though they've worked hard and tried to follow the rules. As one subject said, "I went from Ann Taylor girl to Old Navy girl."

Messages that might resonate better include stories of underdogs succeeding against all odds and the idea of small luxuries that make life enjoyable. Also, partnering a product or store with a charity -- perhaps by sharing part of the profit -- could give consumers a feeling of being good providers and re-establishing a sense of control.

The research did find a complicated blend of feelings about fellow citizens. Anger at places like Wall Street that seem to be thriving at the expense of others mixed with appreciation and envy of those who have the financial resources to live more freely.

The Olson Zaltman firm's work isn't political, although Mr. Zaltman is a little concerned with the impact that a hard-fought election year could have on Americans' sense of well-being. Still, he's hoping people start to choose happier images. "There are signs of optimism," he said.