NEW YORK -- General Motors returned to the stock market Thursday with a car show on Wall Street and a congratulatory message from President Barack Obama, but the shares did not deliver a big surge above the price of the initial public offering.

Shares in the nation's biggest automaker closed at $34.19 in heavy trading, a 3.6 percent increase over the $33-a-share price of its offering.

Investors had hoped for a larger bounce on the first day of trading for the company, which was rescued last year by a $50 billion government bailout and swift trip through bankruptcy reorganization.

Industry analysts said it appeared that the decision this week by GM and its underwriters to bump up the stock's target price from the original $26-to-$29 range had absorbed the usual first-day rise for an initial public offering. "That was where the bounce was," said David Cole, chairman emeritus of the Center for Automotive Research in Ann Arbor, Mich.

Advertise with us

The relatively small increase in the GM share price also meant that the U.S. taxpayers likely captured the best return possible in their first divestiture of what was a 61 percent stake in the company.

Too high of a jump could have left GM and the Obama administration open to the charge that they priced the stock too low, abandoning paper profits that could have gone to taxpayers instead.

GM executives celebrated the occasion by ringing the bell to open trading on the New York Stock Exchange -- and, they hoped, put an end to the "Government Motors" stigma. "It has held us back," said Mark Reuss, GM's head of North American operations. "We know that, and we know that our competitors have certainly taken advantage of all that."

While GM was anxious to move past the bailout, Mr. Obama took the opportunity to defend the government's rescue of the company. "We are finally beginning to see some of the tough decisions that we made in the midst of crisis pay off," he said.

The president said critics of the government's role in saving GM and Chrysler were ready to "read the American auto industry its last rites," but that at least 1 million jobs would have been lost if the Detroit automakers were allowed to fail. "That was not an acceptable option, to throw up our hands and to quit," he said.

Advertise with us

The GM offering, including preferred shares and the overallotment, set a record for the largest initial public offering in U.S. history. The entire offering is expected to reach $23.1 billion, including preferred shares and an overallotment option that will be exercised to take advantage of strong demand for GM's shares.

The Treasury Department sold about half of its stake and will reap about $13.6 billion once the overallotment is completed. The total government stake in the company will shrink to about 26 percent, including preferred shares and accounting for stock options given to former GM bondholders.

At certain points during trading Thursday, about 30 percent of all the shares changing hands on the New York exchange were GM's. By the end of the day, GM was one of the most highly traded stocks, with nearly 457 million shares changing hands.

Shares opened strong at $35 -- $2 higher than the initial public offering price -- and reached $35.99 in early trading, before sliding down to the closing price. Some company and government officials had suggested a possible first-day bounce of 10 percent to 20 percent.

In other high-profile initial offerings, Visa's shares rose 28.4 percent in their first day of trading in 2008, while the Blackstone Group's jumped 15.1 percent in 2007, according to data from Thomson Reuters.

Advertise with us

Privately, government officials and GM underwriters said Thursday that they were relieved by the stock's trading, indicating that the shares had been valued appropriately. The goal, they said, was to establish enough of a market for GM shares to guarantee they would trade well, while maximizing taxpayers' profits.

The offering came after GM executives held more than 80 meetings with potential investors during a two-week international road show. Daniel Akerson, GM's new CEO, worked to persuade skeptical investors that the company would not revert to its old bureaucratic, spendthrift ways.

"We know how we arrived here, and we know what went wrong," he said in a conference call Thursday. "I believe we learned a lot from that."

Other big sellers of stock into the offering were the United Auto Workers health care trust and the Canadian government.