High gasoline and diesel prices, record exports and imports and growing concerns about the effects of highway traffic on the environment could represent a competitive advantage for southwestern Pennsylvania -- if we maintain a healthy waterway system.

While barging is the least expensive and most environmentally sensitive way to ship, its public and private benefits are not well understood. A 15-barge tow passing through the Port of Pittsburgh can carry 22,500 tons of cargo, the equivalent of 225 rail cars or 900 tractor-trailers that otherwise might be tearing up our already busy streets.

A recent report by the American Society of Civil Engineers noted that to move that same volume of cargo one mile requires 44 gallons of diesel fuel by barge, 111 by rail and 381 by truck. Moving cargo 100 miles along the waterways can cost less than a penny a ton-mile, a fraction of the costs for road or rail and just a little more than the cost of a first class stamp.

Martin Associates of Lancaster documented that this activity maintains more than 45,000 direct jobs in our 11-county port district and more than 217,000 total jobs. This is a much higher total than it has found in most other ports, including ocean ports, because most of the cargo that comes to Pittsburgh is in the form of raw materials that are processed or manufactured here, adding value to our local economy, rather than just transferring goods made overseas. The locks and dams that support those jobs also provide stable pools of water for industrial cooling, drinking water, fire-fighting, and river recreation and tourism.

Advertise with us

There is some good news. Shippers already are increasing use of the waterways. The Port of Pittsburgh Commission (PPC) recently released a report showing that traffic through its locks for the first quarter of 2006 was up 23 percent over the same period for 2005. In turn, the first quarter of 2005 was up 22 percent over the same period in 2004. Thanks to provisions of the Clean Air Act, increases are expected to continue well into the future as energy companies add scrubbers to power plants, making coal mined from the Pittsburgh Seam increasingly more valuable in the marketplace.

But not all the news is good. Pittsburgh has some of the oldest locks and dams in the system. In 1994 the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers broke ground for three new locks and dams on the Lower Monongahela River, a project that was expected to be completed in 10 years, or 2004. Due to federal funding delays, the project is anywhere from 12 to 15 additional years behind schedule and may not be completed until as late as 2020.

The news gets worse. There are three sets of locks and dams on the Ohio River at Emsworth, Dashields and Montgomery (EDM) in Pennsylvania. They are the oldest, smallest and in worst condition of any on the Ohio River and should have been replaced years ago. The facility at Emsworth was built in 1921, when Warren G. Harding was president.

At only 600 feet long, all three locks are just half the length of the rest of the Ohio River locks. Their small size gives towing companies the additional expense of double locking, placing our Pennsylvania businesses that must pay for this at a cost disadvantage to other Ohio River states. The Army Corps of Engineers has classified Emsworth as "in exigent condition" or needing emergency repairs. Industry groups wonder if Dashields and Montgomery, only a few years younger, are not far behind.

Fortunately, the federal government has begun to realize how critical this resource is, not only for our regional economy, but for the national economy as well. In his fiscal year 2007 budget message, President Bush included $62.8 million for construction on the Lower Monongahela River and $17 million for emergency repairs at Emsworth. Half of those fees are paid for by users and already have been collected.

Advertise with us

The PPC, the Waterways Association of Pittsburgh and Waterways Council Inc., a national trade group, have asked Congress to increase the amount for emergency repairs at Emsworth to $25 million and to add $3 million to fund part of a four-year study to determine the long-term future of the EDM locks and dams. They also are asking for additional funds to provide simple maintenance on the Monongahela and Allegheny rivers in order to avert the need for extraordinary emergency repairs in the future.

The U.S. House Appropriations Committee, to the credit of our local delegation, did provide $1.3 million to do the EDM study and allocated some additional funds for maintenance. The appropriations action now moves to the Senate.

While we all recognize that we must become less dependent on foreign oil, reduce our air emissions, reduce highway congestion and control inflation, few possibilities have such a strong public payback as simple investments in our waterway infrastructure.

As shippers become more familiar with the private benefits of moving cargo from highways to waterways, and if government invests wisely in its most effective infrastructure, we will be ready to position southwestern Pennsylvania to capture that growth.

It is the right thing to do, and in the long run we may have no choice if we want America to compete on the world market.