With crude-oil prices soaring, refiners are taking advantage of tight supplies to fatten the margins that they earn from turning oil into jet fuel. And cash-strapped airlines are picking up the mounting tab.

The widening gaps between the price of crude oil and various types of fuel -- known in the industry as crack spreads -- are dealing a one-two punch to an industry that can ill afford it, where fuel is the second-biggest expense after labor. The average crack spread for jet fuel topped $11 per barrel in the first half of this year. That is up from an average $2.59 per barrel in 2002, with the biggest jump occurring in the past six months, said Mike Lovett, chief executive of Muse, Stancil, a Dallas global-energy consulting firm.

Gasoline-hungry motorists are feeling the pain of a widening crack spread, too, but the effect has been less pronounced. From 2002 through June of this year, the gasoline crack spread nearly doubled to $7.75 a barrel from $4.14 -- but the average jet-fuel crack spread more than quadrupled.

Oil prices are continuing to rise. U.S. light, sweet crude for September delivery rose to a record of $64 a barrel before closing up $1.63, or 2.6 percent, at $63.94 on the New York Mercantile Exchange Monday.

Advertise with us

Adjusted for inflation, this is the highest crude has traded at since November 1982. However, it remains well below its inflation-adjusted peak price of $94.77 set in April 1980.

Tight refining capacity has played a role in the price run-up. The industry has a shortage of capacity to refine heavy oils, which has pushed up the price of lighter oils, like the benchmark West Texas Intermediate.

To a reeling airline industry, the widening crack spread couldn't come at a worse time. For nine of the nation's largest airlines, the second-quarter fuel bill totaled a combined $4.34 billion, said Bear Stearns analyst David Strine. Had the crack spread held at year-earlier levels, the fuel would have cost $3.92 billion, a difference of more than $420 million. That is more than enough to erase the $227.4 million those airlines collectively lost in the period.

"Those of us in the airline industry are being doubly hurt," said Gerard Arpey, chief executive of American Airlines, whose annual fuel costs rise by $29 million for each one-cent rise in the cost of jet fuel per gallon.

Through June of this year, the price of West Texas Intermediate crude oil rose an average 39.7 percent per barrel from a year earlier to $51, while jet fuel rose at a much faster 49.1 percent a barrel to more than $62, said Mr. Strine of Bear Stearns. Continental Airlines says it now spends $12,202 for fuel to fly a Boeing Co. 757 cross-country from Los Angeles to Newark, N.J..

Advertise with us

The bottom line: About one-fifth of the increase in jet fuel prices is coming from a widening crack spread, while the other four-fifths reflect higher oil prices.

The widening crack spread is another factor weighing on the stock prices of airlines. Since December 2003, the Standard & Poor's Airline Index has fallen 20.35 percent while the broader S&P 500 stock index has risen 11.15 percent.

Blame diesel cars in part for the widening crack spread. Jet fuel and diesel fuel have similar components, and soaring demand for diesel-powered vehicles, particularly in Europe, is pushing up prices for both fuels. Greater industrial demand for diesel in China also has played a role. Airline executives complain that refiners, which in the past decade came off a long period of weak profit margins, have been slow to add new refining capacity, which is contributing to the high prices.

Gene Edwards, senior vice president of supply, trading and wholesale marketing for refiner Valero Energy, said the higher profit margins are simply being dictated by the laws of supply and demand in a "feast or famine" refining market. He estimates his industry's return on capital has risen to the 20 percent range from 5 percent during weaker times in the 1990s, and he expects it to stay there.

While Mr. Edwards expects refiners to add more capacity -- Valero will spend $4 billion to do so over the next five years -- "it takes time" and won't produce enough overall supply to equal growing demand, he said. He added that higher oil prices, not refining margins, are the primary factor driving up jet-fuel costs.

Advertise with us

Fereidun Fesharaki, a senior fellow and downstream-petroleum expert at the U.S. government-funded EastWest center in Honolulu, sees the crack spread continuing to widen because of tight supplies.

But Bob Sturtz, head of fuel purchasing at UAL's United Airlines, disagrees. He thinks that today's spread will be viewed in the future as an historic high. He expects refiners will add jet-fuel capacity nearer-term because of the thick margins, though he acknowledges it could take time for the spread to narrow.

"These prices will only fall if demand subsides or supply increases," he said. UAL's fuel bill hit $955 million in the second quarter, up 38 percent from a year earlier, as the carrier, still mired in bankruptcy proceedings, posted a $1.43 billion loss.

At AMR, parent of American Airlines, the world's largest airline by traffic, the second-quarter fuel bill totaled $1.35 billion, up 47 percent from $917 million a year earlier. The company, which made a meager $58 million profit in the quarter, paid $1.63 a gallon for jet fuel in the period, up from $1.11 a gallon a year earlier. American expects third-quarter fuel prices to creep even higher, to an average of $1.85 a gallon.

A few carriers, including Southwest Airlines and America West Holdings' America West, have partially insulated themselves from higher prices with fuel hedges. The hedges, executed before prices surged, effectively locked in lower prices. But most airlines have little or no hedges in place, and now it is too late and costly to find attractive prices.

Advertise with us

Airlines that fly more heavily in the Western U.S. get hit even harder by the crack spread because prices for jet fuel run higher there. One day recently, for example, West Coast jet fuel was $1.70 a gallon while Gulf Coast fuel was $1.61.

For now, carriers are taking whatever small steps they can to trim their fuel consumption, including cutting off engines while taxiing.

"We're always hopeful that our price is coming back down to earth, so to speak. But it's not good," said Rick Pressly, managing director of fuel management for Continental Airlines, where a penny increase in the price of jet fuel per gallon boosts operating costs by $17 million a year. "You can't shop around for different crack spreads like driving to different gas stations."