How much does health care really cost?

We may be familiar with our own monthly premiums, yearly deductibles, copayments and even coinsurance. Hospitals are now required to post their list prices, too, although almost no one pays that amount.

Ultimately we, the public, don’t really have a good answer. All we know is that the cost keeps going up — health costs now represent nearly one-fifth of America’s gross domestic product — while other developed nations spend less and have better outcomes.

National health care out-of-pocket expenses On average, the out-of-pocket cost* per person for health care in 1970 was $119 or $601 in 2017 dollars. It increased gradually to an average of $1,124 per capita in 2017. PER CAPITA OUT-OF-POCKET EXPENDITURES, 1970-2017

Advertise with us

*Out-of-pocket medical costs are in addition to the amount paid in health insurance premiums.

Chance Brinkman-Sull/Post-Gazette

Locally, UPMC has touted some of the lowest-cost Medicare Advantage and individual marketplace plans in the country, each providing access to its world-class care network. The numbers seem to validate that claim, too.

Last year, a UPMC Health Plan-backed report looked at health care costs in the Pittsburgh market, including services supplied by competing Allegheny Health Network. The paper from Berkeley Research Group consultants in California showed that Medicare fee-for-service health care costs here are among the lowest in the country, although utilization was higher than the national average.

“These lower costs are the result of lower payment rates and not lower hospital utilization,” the paper concluded, “which means that Pittsburgh’s hospitals provide care more efficiently.”

Advertise with us

Others say the numbers alone don’t tell the whole story.

“Medicare payments in Pittsburgh are some of the lowest in the country because the cost of living and wage rates for health care workers here are some of the lowest in the country,” said Harold Miller, president and CEO of the Pittsburgh-based Center for Healthcare Quality and Payment Reform.

“When the workforce is paid less, services can be provided at lower cost.”

Gerard Anderson, a professor of health policy and management at Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore, also said Medicare is not the place to judge costs because rates are set nationally based on factors such as the region’s average hourly wage.

Instead, you should look at private commercial insurance, he said, which comprises the largest share of insured and involves negotiated rates.

Advertise with us

Both experts take issue as well with the Berkeley paper’s conclusion that higher utilization paired with lower premiums means hospitals here are more efficient.

“That’s a failing system,” countered Mr. Anderson. “You don’t want people in the hospital.”

Piles of claims data

What, then, is the answer on costs?

Two academic-based initiatives, one with roots in Pittsburgh, have been trying to find that answer by analyzing actual claims data.

Advertise with us

The Washington, D.C.-based Health Care Cost Institute has collected more than 6 billion commercial insurance claims for 50 million patients since 2011 from four major health insurers -– United Healthcare, Aetna, Humana and Kaiser Permanente, although United Healthcare recently announced it was ending its participation.

HCCI data show Pittsburgh had health care prices below the national median in 2016 — but it may be closing in on the national benchmark after a statewide 22 percent growth in spending from 2013-2017.

Pittsburgh’s utilization of health care services, meanwhile, was 21 percent above the national median in 2016, on a par with Washington, D.C., and Houston, the institute’s data showed.

Even if you have good insurance coverage yourself, the rising cost of health care “affects the generosity of your benefits package and it affects your take-home pay,” said Niall Brennan, president and CEO of HCCI.

“It is the 800-pound gorilla that is slowly strangling the economy.”

Advertise with us

A second site analyzing health care costs is the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, which purchases access to claims data collected by IBM Watson’s MarketScan Research databases.

Those have private and government program insurance claims data for more than 250 million patients, minus any patient identifying information. The data are used to look for patterns in health care costs and provide pricing estimates, which they can personalize based on someone’s benefit coverage.

At the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette’s request, the Hopkins researchers compared 2016 health care costs among Pittsburgh, Philadelphia and Erie.

The Hopkins researchers’ preliminary analysis shows a knee replacement costs a little over $20,850 in Pittsburgh and $30,979 in Philadelphia.

IBM Watson Health’s Bobbi Coluni points out, though, that the price for a knee replacement here can range from $16,000 to $34,000 and from $18,000 to $45,000 in Philadelphia. The final cost to a consumer will depend on a number of factors, such as the patient’s insurance plan coverage and whether the procedure was done in a hospital or an outpatient setting.

Advertise with us

‘People don’t really care’

All the moving parts can easily confuse consumers. Even with a 25-year career in health care analytics, Ms. Coluni said she, too, was recently caught by surprise.

After having a cancerous spot on her forehead removed last fall at an outpatient clinic, she was scheduled for a follow-up reconstruction procedure at a hospital.

“The total charge was over $19,000, with most of it related to the high cost of using the local hospital OR instead of an outpatient clinic,” she wrote in a blog afterward. “Because of my high deductible health plan, I ended up paying over $6,000 while my health plan paid $3,500.”

When she showed the bill to her physician, “He said, ‘People don’t really care what the price is,’” Ms. Coluni said in a recent phone interview.

Advertise with us

“There’s this perception that insurance will take care of it, but that’s really not accurate. We’re all paying for it.”

Diminishing competition

And that’s the key question: How much is health care really costing all of us, not just as individuals? What are we getting for the $3.5 trillion we spend each year? And where does the Pittsburgh market fit in that equation?

Martin Gaynor, a professor of economics and health policy at Carnegie Mellon University’s Heinz College, was a Health Care Cost Institute founding member.

He and four colleagues published research in February based on the institute’s data that showed private health spending per enrollee increased 16.9 percent from 2007-2014 while traditional Medicare spending per beneficiary decreased 1.2 percent.

Advertise with us

In testimony last month in Washington, D.C., before the House subcommittee on antitrust, commercial and administrative law, Mr. Gaynor explained that the U.S. health care system is based on markets. “These markets do not function as well as they could or should.”

The reason is diminishing competition, he said, as evidenced by some 1,600 hospital mergers nationwide in the last 20 years — more than 450 of them since 2012.

“The result is that the majority of local areas are now dominated by one large, powerful health system,” said Mr. Gaynor, who then cited three examples of dominated markets: Boston, San Francisco … and Pittsburgh, despite Allegheny Health’s current neighborhood hospital construction boom.

He went on to say markets dominated by one health system tend to share similar characteristics — substantial price increases for care and insurance without offsetting gains in quality or efficiency.

As for the low-cost insurance plans cited by UPMC, “I wouldn’t simply accept their claims as true,” Mr. Gaynor said in a recent interview. “I’d want to see what their premiums are and how they compare to others to verify the claim that they’re lower.”

Advertise with us

He told the committee that he recommends stronger antitrust enforcement and greater transparency “so employers, policymakers, and consumers have access to information about health care costs and quality.” The committee is working on a bill to lower prescription drug prices by expanding access to generics.

Data, he suggested, will play a key role in achieving the necessary transparency.

“In my view, we’re still not there as a country in terms of having the data infrastructure that we need.”

Without that data, he continued, “You won’t know how much things are costing. You won’t know whether costs are high, or whether costs are low.

“How do you formulate policy when you don’t know what’s going on?”

Steve Twedt: stwedt@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1963.