AK Steel had one of its best years in the last decade in 2018, as sales rose with the price of steel and demand for a range of new products.

Yet the Ohio-based owner of the Butler Works — the hulking facility just outside Butler that melts, casts, rolls and finishes steel — does not expect this year to be quite as sweet.

The culprit: a drop in steel prices that would hit a chunk of its sales not currently under contract.

During a call with analysts Tuesday, company executives said they are basing their estimates on  the average price of steel sitting at $720 a ton this year, down from $830 a ton in 2018. The 2019 estimate is based on the assumption that prices seen in January will continue.

Advertise with us

The company has moved in recent years to manage such big drops. It now ships about 70 percent of its steel to buyers who’ve agreed to a fixed price that does not shift with the market.

Still, the sinking prices — along with higher costs for materials used in steel-making like coal and iron ore — affects the remaining shipments that track the market swings.

The prices were enough to weigh on overall expectations for 2019: AK Steel estimated its 2019 profits will fall between $160 million and $180 million, compared with $186 million in profits the company reported in 2018.

“We did an excellent job in getting what we thought we would get on automotive contracts without a doubt,” said Jaime Vasquez, AK Steel’s chief financial officer, referring to the contracted shipments.

“But offsetting that ... you’re talking about a $110 decline” in price per ton of steel, Mr. Vasquez said.

Advertise with us

That’s about $200 million in lost revenue over 1.8 million tons of steel that are not under contract and shipped according to spot prices, he said. Another 4 million tons of steel are contracted.

AK Steel’s mixed outlook spurred a chorus of wary comments from financial analysts.

David Lipschitz of Macquarie Group downgraded the stock, explaining that the positive earnings could “face downside risks on falling steel prices.”

The company’s guidance “leaves a bit to be desired,” from the perspective of Philip Gibbs, a KeyBanc analyst.

AK Steel’s solid financial performance in 2018 could be offset by disappointing expectations for the coming years, wrote Chris Olin of Longbow Research.

Advertise with us

Investors did not seem worried — at least Tuesday — as AK Steel stock traded up 5 percent to close at $2.83.

The possibility of softening steel prices will be an issue for the broader U.S. steel industry in 2019.

There’s been a slight cooling in the Trump administration’s trade war with China that erected 25 percent tariffs on imported steel and boosted demand for steel made by U.S. steel companies like AK Steel. As talks between the world’s two largest economies continue, those tariffs might be reduced or eliminated.

U.S. steel-making capacity is also on the rise, boosting supplies and steadily lowering prices from peak prices last summer. Pittsburgh-based U.S. Steel restarted operations in Granite City, Ill., last year, adding significant production capacity that brought down prices.

U.S. Steel is set to report its own earnings and guidance on Wednesday.

Advertise with us

Also on Tuesday, AK Steel announced the closure of a plant in Ashland, Ky., which had been largely idled more than three years ago. The closure will cost $80 million but save the company $40 million annually, executives said.

AK Steel has seven other production facilities in Ohio, Indiana, Michigan and Pennsylvania, including the Butler Works.

A steel price roller coaster for AK Steel AK Steel, the Ohio-based company that owns Butler Works, expects a drop in steel prices in 2019. Last year, the company's average sales price climbed back to 2012 levels.

Source: AK Steel | graphic: Ed Yozwick/Post-Gazette

Daniel Moore: dmoore@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2743 and Twitter @PGdanielmoore