Three months into his tenure as CEO for wellness and supplement retailer GNC, Mike Archbold could hardly sound more optimistic about the company and the business.

“There are so many great things about this brand,” said Mr. Archbold, 54, citing GNC’s position as market leader and its strong cash flow, as well as customers whom he declared “the most loyal in the industry.”

Yet, when Mr. Archbold’s appointment was announced in early August, the company’s recent history prompted one website to blare: “Michael Archbold takes the hot seat,” an assessment that brought a smile from the CEO during an interview last week at GNC’s global headquarters on Sixth Avenue, Downtown.

Despite executing 2011’s most successful public offering, this is a company that has struggled the past year on Wall Street.

Advertise with us

The day that Mr. Archbold took over for longtime President and CEO Joe Fortunato, GNC shares were selling for just over $30 after losing half their value in the previous nine months. It wasn’t just GNC having trouble; the vitamin and supplement business overall was hurting, and the harsh winter that hit all retailers did not help.

Mr. Archbold’s optimism comes from taking the long view, where he sees “a strong tail wind” of health awareness in coming years that will drive growth in the health and supplements business. A large part of that is demographics: “As we age, we need to take more and more supplements.”

His task now is to make sure those consumers looking for supplements think first of GNC.

He already has initiated subtle, but significant, changes in stores, most notably a somewhat-counter intuitive move to take a step back on product promotions. Instead of offering discounts throughout the store, GNC has moved to offer discounts on fewer products but make those discounts bigger.

“These days, customers tend not to respond to 10 percent off anything. They need to discount deeper,” Mr. Archbold said. His motto: “Fewer, bigger, bolder.”

Advertise with us

Early results show an increase in gross profits, he said, adding that “we haven’t had a lot of pushback from customers.”

GNC’s most recent “Beat Average” marketing campaign is also on the way out, he said, for the simple reason that it wasn’t driving sales. As for the next marketing campaign, “We’re still a couple of quarters away from that.”

One person who will be part of that discussion is Jeff Hennion, a former GNC executive who in September was named the company’s chief marketing officer and eCommerce officer, a position similar to one he held in 2011-2012 before becoming president and CFO for Branding Brand on South Side.

Also joining the executive team is Daisy Vanderlinde, chief human resource officer, who previously was executive vice president of human resources for Office Depot.

Much has been made of Mr. Archbold’s tenure at GNC competitor Vitamin Shoppe — he declined to address rumors that the two companies may join forces — but he said he also will be drawing from his experiences as CEO and CFO at fashion retailer Talbots for two years before coming to GNC.

Advertise with us

It’s all about the customer experience, he said.

He plans to step up customer-engagement training of store associates. The ideal, he said, would be greeting every customer by name but “even if you don’t know the customer by name, you’ve got to have that warm welcome.”

In coming months, GNC customers can expect to see new and different products, such as plant-based and nature-based proteins, while continuing to find the performance products the retailer is known for.

“We’ve done a lot of consumer research to make sure we can go there,” said Mr. Archbold. Rather than alienating the long-held customer base, “what we found is that they are very open to that.”

Whether Wall Street responds, of course, is an open question. Recently announced third quarter results showed year-over-year revenue was $656.3 million, down from $674.5 million in 2013, and same-store sales dropped 6.9 percent, compared with an 8.2 percent increase a year ago.

Advertise with us

GNC shares are now trading above $40. Mr. Archbold said it’s “a fool’s errand” to try to predict what a share price will be months down the road.

“But if you focus on growing the business, the stock will follow.”