The state Friday made good on its threat to take Highmark to court over the Pittsburgh health insurer’s marketing of its new UPMC-free policies for senior citizens.

Highmark’s new Medicare Advantage “Community Blue” product line, introduced last week, both contradicts the insurer’s own advertising and fails to protect seniors as required by a summer consent agreement between the two Pittsburgh health giants, state regulators said Friday in seeking a court injunction.

The state Attorney General and the departments of health and insurance are asking the Commonwealth Court to find Highmark in contempt of the consent decree; they want the court to stop Highmark from marketing any limited network Medicare Advantage products that don’t include UPMC doctors, and are warning brokers that those selling the plans risk violating the state’s Unfair Insurance Practices Act.

The dispute, brewing since the end of September, flared last week, when Highmark introduced the narrow-network Community Blue HMO plan — with a “Signature” level and a “Prestige” level — in advance of the annual open enrollment period for senior citizens, during which they can shop for new plans.

Advertise with us

Medicare Advantage policies are health plans for senior citizens, sold and operated by private insurers.

Monthly premiums for the new Community Blue plan targeted by the state agencies start at $0, but the physician network excludes UPMC hospitals, as well as those of Excela Health, Butler Health System, St. Clair Hospital and Washington Health System.

Highmark says it offered all of the excluded hospitals the chance to participate in February, but that UPMC and others refused because the reimbursement levels were too low.

State regulators threatened legal action against Highmark via letter last week, saying they believe that the new Medicare Advantage plan violates the consent decree mediated by the state, and necessitated by years of tension over UPMC’s plan to sever its commercial contract with Highmark and lock under-65 Highmark customers out of many of UPMC’s hospitals and clinics.

Despite the warning shot from the state, Highmark attorneys and its CEO said this week that the company intends to go forward with the sale of the product, and now expects to win its case against the state.

Advertise with us

“We do not anticipate that this plan [will] not be an option for our members,” Highmark spokesman Aaron Billger said. “However, in the unlikely event that happens, [Medicare] procedures provide for a special election period if an individual’s plan is no longer available.”

While individuals can’t purchase the product until the open enrollment period begins Wednesday, a number of employer groups offering retiree benefits have already selected the plan, Mr. Billger said.

Highmark says the U.S. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services has vetted and approved the product for sale, and also says that both the state and UPMC knew about it and raised no objections until the end of September.

In the Friday afternoon filing, the state agencies also asked the court to force Highmark to “expand its provider network for any Medicare Advantage Plan it offers in Western Pennsylvania to include UPMC,” and to reimburse customers who may purchase the Community Blue product.

“The Commonwealth believes that there is the likelihood of confusion for consumers caused by Highmark’s conflicting information,” the attorney general’s office said in a press release.

Advertise with us

At issue is the interpretation of the provision of the June consent decrees that refers to Medicare plans, which reads:

“With respect to Highmark-covered vulnerable [Medicare and related] populations, UPMC shall continue to contract with Highmark at in-network rates for all of its hospital, physician and appropriate continuity of care services [as] long as Highmark does not make unilateral material changes to these programs. UPMC shall treat all Medicare participating consumers as in-network ... Highmark acknowledges that UPMC reserves the right to withdraw from these arrangements if Highmark should take the position that it has the authority to revise the rates and fees payable under those arrangements unilaterally and materially.”

State regulators, as well as UPMC, interpret that clause to mean that if UPMC is required to treat Highmark’s Medicare customers at in-network rates, then Highmark, by turn, must also be required to keep UPMC providers in its network for all of its Medicare policies.

Highmark disagrees, and says that other insurers — including UPMC Health Plan — operate narrow-network Medicare Advantage plans and low or no monthly premiums.

The state’s stance is misguided, according to the insurer. “This is the wrong action, and at the wrong time as seniors could reap the benefit of a lower cost product that may better suit their needs,” Highmark said in a statement. “The state is advocating a double standard when there are others in the marketplace offering plans that do not include broad network access.”

Advertise with us

In a Friday meeting of the House Democratic Policy Committee, lawmakers quizzed representatives of both Pittsburgh health companies about the controversial plan. UPMC’s Thomas McGough Jr., the health system’s top legal officer, described it as “defective and illegal.”

“UPMC knows how this gambit, if allowed to proceed, will play out,” he said. Seniors will start showing up at UPMC clinics starting in January, not realizing that their new Medicare Advantage plan doesn’t include UPMC doctors.

Rep. Tony DeLuca, D-Penn Hills, said the new, zero-premium plans amounted to a “bait and switch,” because Highmark is raising premiums on its popular Freedom Blue PPO Select plan, as well as its Freedom Blue Value Rx, Freedom Blue Classic jumps, and its Security Blue HMO product line.

In other words, Highmark is raising prices on its other products as a way of steering seniors toward its new low-cost Community Blue product, and toward its own, in-house hospital system, the Allegheny Health Network.

“Some of these seniors are just going to be looking at prices,” Mr. DeLuca said, and might not pay attention to the physician network. Highmark said it will carefully explain the plan’s network to everyone who buys it.