On the first day of the annual open enrollment period, Highmark made public its offerings for the 2015 post-UPMC era, including a two-tiered Community Blue Flex plan and a new Medicare Advantage plan that comes at a reduced cost but doesn’t offer in-network access to several local health systems including UPMC.
All current Medicare and Medicare Advantage plans will continue to provide access to UPMC physicians and facilities.
Highmark officials on Wednesday emphasized that the new plans offered by the Pittsburgh insurer give employers and consumers more choices for access and cost by offering different coverage levels, or tiers, to their menu of plans.
“Tiering provides one more level of transparency to the customer, and transparency is really important in today’s world,” said Anthony Benevento, Highmark’s senior vice president of Pennsylvania markets.
Community Blue Flex will offer either standard or enhanced Flex plans, as well as a third option for those who seek out-of-network care. The enhanced plan closely resembles the current Community Blue plan while the standard plan shifts more costs to the consumer.
For both the Community Blue PPO and Community Blue Flex PPO, UPMC’s seven core hospitals in Allegheny County will be out of network: Presbyterian-Shadyside, Passavant, Magee-Womens, UPMC East, McKeesport, Mercy and St. Margaret. Only Children’s Hospital and Western Psychiatric Institute and Clinic remain in-network within the county for Community Blue and the enhanced Community Blue Flex.
Read More
Under the standard Community Blue Flex, UPMC Hamot in Erie and Horizon in Greenville, Mercer County, are also in-network but the subscriber will bear more of the costs. Community Blue Flex subscribers going to other, out-of-network UPMC facilities may be billed for up to 60 percent of UPMC’s charges, minus whatever their plan benefits cover.
Community Blue has been one of the flashpoints in the ongoing Highmark-UPMC contract dispute.
When the plan was introduced early last year, UPMC blocked Community Blue members’ access to its physicians and facilities, even those willing to pay cash at out-of-network costs. UPMC did that because the current Highmark contract, which expires Dec. 31, prohibited the health system from billing patients for the remaining balance of the bill beyond Highmark’s reimbursement.
Beginning in 2015, Community Blue members will have access to the UPMC network again but they may face that fee for 60 percent of charges. “It’s just a matter of what they pay to have that access, and it depends on what benefit design they choose,” said Mr. Benevento.
As an example, Highmark says someone with standard Community Blue Flex receiving care at an out-of-network UPMC facility could face an individual deductible of $1,500 ($3,000 for a family), plus 50 percent of the coinsurance (the insured individual’s percentage share of the cost for the covered service), $5,000 in out-of-pocket costs ($10,000 for a family) and 50 percent of the remaining cost of the hospital care or doctor’s office visit.
In-network, Community Blue Flex deductibles and out-of-pocket costs are cut in half but coinsurance goes up to 70 percent as do hospital services after the deductible is met.
For the enhanced plan, deductibles go to $250 ($500 for a family), an office visit is $15 and hospital stays are fully covered after the deductible is met. The subscriber would still be responsible for the coinsurance portion.
A Highmark press release on the plan can be found at www.highmark.com/hmk2/newsroom/2014/pr100114CommunityBlue.shtml.
Medicare recipients will continue to have access to UPMC, although Highmark intends to offer a new Medicare Advantage plan that has monthly premiums ranging from zero to $193, while trading its low cost for a narrower network. In that plan, those paying the lower premium will face more of the costs when they receive care.
Tim Lightner, Highmark’s vice president for senior markets product and marketing, said the plan will be offered in 23 Western Pennsylvania counties and the network will not include UPMC, Excela Health in Westmoreland County, Butler Health System or Washington Health System.
“We’ve put this out there as a choice,” Mr. Lightner said. “It’s frankly not going to be the right product for everyone.”
A fuller description of the plan can be viewed online at www.highmark.com/hmk2/newsroom/2014/pr100114CommunityBlueMedicare.shtml.
While announcing the new offerings, Highmark also said it is discontinuing its Medicare Advantage Freedom Blue PPO high deductible and Security Blue HMO high-deductible plans, which spokesman Aaron Billger says will affect about 13,000 people. Highmark has 339,000 Medicare Advantage members.
The Highmark announcement came as the yearly three-month open enrollment plan began Wednesday. Come January, many Highmark members will face limited access to UPMC facilities and physicians, particularly in Allegheny County.
UPMC, which chose not to renew the Highmark contract once the Pittsburgh insurer established the competing Allegheny Health Network, is betting that many Highmark members will opt for either UPMC Health Plan or one of the national insurers that have contracts with UPMC to insure access to its doctors and hospitals.
Highmark officials, however, are buoyed by what they said was a 95 percent retention rate for contracts renewed in July. That represents 35 to 40 percent of their total contracts, said Dana Collins, senior client manager, adding that they’re confident about retaining members in the current enrollment period as well.
Robin Bugni, vice president for product management and development, said part of that confidence stems from the “tremendously successful” launch of Community Blue, which now has 325,000 members in Western Pennsylvania.
“They have everything they need in the Community Blue network. They are getting the care that they need.”
Steve Twedt: stwedt@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1963.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.