The next time you start complaining about the high cost of car insurance, consider this: A new survey found motorists in the Pittsburgh region are shelling out some of the lowest premiums in the country.
The average annual premium locally was just over $600, or 24 percent lower than the national average of $797. That was the third cheapest among the 25 regions studied, according to Denver-based InsuranceQuotes.com, which commissioned Quadrant Information Services to do the analysis.
Only drivers in Cleveland and Charlotte enjoyed lower rates, at $550 and $454 respectively.
The most expensive region by far was Detroit, where premiums averaged $2,112, or 165 percent above the national average. The survey attributed the high rates to Michigan insurance law that mandates unlimited lifetime coverage for medical expenses in an accident.
After Detroit, the most expensive regions were New York, Miami and Los Angeles, where premiums ranged from 36 percent to 25 percent higher than the national average.
Regions near the top of the list tended to have higher populations with more traffic density, resulting in more potential for accidents and insurance claims, said Laura Adams, senior analyst at InsuranceQuotes.com. They also tended to have higher crime rates, leading to more claims for auto break-ins and theft, she said.
In Pittsburgh, “There’s probably something going on there in terms of traffic density not being as high,” Ms. Adams said.
The analysis used a combination of metropolitan statistical areas and the broader combined statistical areas. That likely helped bring down the average premium in the Pittsburgh region, which encompassed Weirton, W.Va., to the south and Steubenville, Ohio, to the west.
Picking up rural areas, “absolutely can make the number look less expensive,” Ms. Adams said.
Quadrant used “millions of pieces of data,” including insurance quotes covering at least 70 percent of the market in every ZIP code in the regions analyzed, she said. Rates were based on a representative motorist with a bachelor’s degree who drives 15,000 miles a year with no breaks in coverage, a $500 collision and comprehensive deductible, state mandated minimum liability coverage and full personal injury coverage.
Rates were sampled in August but the figure for the national average was from 2011, the most recent available data from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners.
“The major point of the study was to highlight that where you live plays a really big role in what you pay for car insurance,” Ms. Adams said. Moving even one ZIP code can make a difference, she said.
“We are trying to raise awareness that there are a lot of factors that go into [setting] rates, and you have to be proactive about ways to save money.”
No matter where people live, one often overlooked way to cut premiums is to ask about qualifying for special discounts that insurers don’t automatically mention, she said.
For example, many insurers offer a “good student” discount for high school and college students who maintain a “B” average.
“Insurers have found a correlation between good grades and good driving behavior,” Ms. Adams said. “You would have to self-report to take advantage of that discount.”
Another type of discount people often miss out on is for certain types of occupations, such as for teachers and people in the medical field, she said.
Last month, the Consumer Federation of America issued an advisory urging consumers to routinely shop around for the best price on auto insurance, especially if they have been with the same carrier for a number of years.
The organization said some insurers are unfairly raising rates on loyal customers based on pricing models that predict that certain types of policyholders are unlikely to look for a better deal.
The association of insurance commissioners has said it is investigating the practice.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.