The state Senate this afternoon ignored pleas from Pittsburgh Mayor Luke Ravenstahl and included the city in a bill for the state to take over struggling municipal pension systems.

Senators approved the measure by a 38-9 margin with almost all local senators voting in favor. The bill now goes to the House for consideration.

Sen. Jay Costa, D-Forest Hills, said the bill would give the city a "fresh start" on efforts to fully fund its pension. It would give the city lower payemnts until 2017, when payments would jump as the city's other debt service goes down, he said.

Before the vote, Mr. Ravenstahl pleaded with legislators to give the city two years to fix its own problems, rather than seizing its troubled retirement fund and requiring what he considers budget-busting payments in future years.

Advertise with us

"Just give us a chance to solve this locally," the mayor said in an interview between calls to Harrisburg. "We can do it ... Give us a two-year window to explore leasing [public] garages" and putting the proceeds into the city's pension pool.

Mr. Ravenstahl said he's organizing a public meeting on the pension bill, at 6 p.m. tomorrow in City Council Chamber, to explain its ramifications to the public.

With legislation moving quickly to allow Philadelphia to raise its sales tax to shore up its pension fund, and to seize a handful of other troubled funds dominated by Pittsburgh's, Mr. Ravenstahl complained about a process that didn't give his administration a chance to analyze the ever-changing legislation's impact.

"We got it on Sunday," he said of the legislation. "It was read Monday. It's going to be voted on tonight ... How are we supposed to react to something that wasn't on the table until Sunday?"

He said local legislators have gone along with a fast-track approach because Philadelphia needs the help. He said he's asking them, "Don't you represent us?"

Advertise with us

He said constant amendments make it hard to calculate the legislation's effects on the city, but held to earlier estimates that it would force Pittsburgh to put $70 million a year into a state-run pension pool -- up from the $45 million it is putting into its own fund this year. The city was already struggling to figure out how to increase its annual pension investment to $60 million, he said, and going higher would force as-yet-undetermined tax hikes or service cuts.

The legislation would give the city the option of ramping up to higher payments into the pension pool, but that would just postpone and worsen a crushing problem, he said. "Eight years from now, disaster," he predicted. "Total disaster ... Year eight, the city would crumble" under the weight of $100 million-plus in payments into the pension pool.

The legislation would not affect the pensions due to existing employees, but would tilt benefits due to workers hired next year and beyond. A typical police officer who retires now might get a $2,500-a-month pension, he said. Under the benefit calculations mandated by the legislation, the typical officer of the future would get around $3,375 or $3,938, depending on whether overtime is included in the formula.

City police don't get Social Security.

Meanwhile, the typical refuse worker of tomorrow would get a pension payment that was around half of that collected by refuse workers retiring today.

Advertise with us

"It's not fair. It's not equitable," Mr. Ravenstahl said.

He said two years would be enough time for the city to complete the process of deciding whether to lease its parking garages and possible on-street meters to a private operator, and putting the proceeds into the pension pot. At last count, it contained $251 million, which is 28 percent of the $899 million it should contain to meet its long-term obligations.

"If our plan doesn't work, then we have no choice but to work within the confines of the state," he said.

More details in tomorrow's Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.