HARRISBURG -- State Rep. Daryl Metcalfe is taking aim at cities such as Pittsburgh, Philadelphia and others that have approved their own laws to regulate the sale and possession of handguns, rifles, shotguns or other firearms.

As hundreds of gun owners filled the Capitol rotunda and hallways for a pro-Second Amendment rally today, the Cranberry Republican said he's introducing legislation to deter municipalities from enacting local laws regulating guns.

He thinks such laws are unenforceable. He maintains that such power is reserved just for the state Legislature, adding the state's criminal code "specifically prohibits local firearm laws."

His bill would require "any offending jurisdiction" to reimburse any person or organization that successfully challenges "an illegal local firearm ordinance for actual (financial) damages, reasonable attorney fees and other legal costs."

Advertise with us

He said the U.S. Constitution's Second Amendment, as well as Section 21 of the state constitution, "affirms in no uncertain terms that 'the rights of citizens to bear arms in defense of themselves and the state shall not be questioned.'"

He said his bill is meant to "financially deter and/or punish" any local governments that "blatantly violate" the criminal code and the state and federal constitutions.

Mr. Metcalfe organized the fourth annual "Right to Keep and Bear Arms" rally at the Capitol. People held placards reading "Criminals Will Always Have Guns -- Will We?'' and "Guns Only Have Two Enemies -- Rust and Politicians."

Mr. Metcalfe said gun owners in the state "will never tolerate the enactment of any gun control measure that leaves law-abiding citizens disarmed and defenseless against violent intruders, who in most cases obtain their weapons illegally."

Besides Mr. Metcalfe, a high-profile list of gun rights officials spoke at the rally, including author/lawyer Stephen Halbrook, who successfully argued that the U.S. Supreme Court should overturn Washington, D.C.'s gun ban; Gun Owners of America President Larry Pratt and National Rifle Association President John Sigler.

Advertise with us

"Today, Second Amendment freedoms stand in a precarious position," said Mr. Sigler. He and others urged the large crowd to oppose Gov. Ed Rendell's efforts to limit handgun buyers to one weapon a month.

Mr. Sigler called such a limit "intellectually bankrupt" and ineffective. Only four states have enacted such laws, he said, and "they were miserable failures."

He said limiting guns sales didn't lower crime in South Carolina, which later repealed the law. He said robbery rates in Maryland increased after such a law was passed.

"Criminals don't obey the one-gun-a-month law any more than they obey other laws," he said.

Speakers also opposed efforts by Mr. Rendell and some mayors and police chiefs to give cities and towns the clear right to enact their own gun ordinances. Even though some have done so, such as Pittsburgh and Philadelphia, legal questions are delaying strict enforcement.

Advertise with us

If different towns across the state have different gun laws, there will be "a patchwork of contradictory laws," Mr. Sigler said. "You could end up in jail because of a city ordinance you knew nothing about."

Speakers also strongly opposed any efforts by the state to create a statewide "gun registry," where owners would have to register all the guns they own.

"Gun registration leads to gun confiscation, as surely as thunder follows lightning," said Mr. Sigler.

Gun advocates also oppose a proposal by some Pennsylvania mayors and police chiefs to require gun owners to report any "lost or stolen" guns to police within 72 hours. The idea is to stop "straw purchasers'' from buying guns from an owner and later having them used in a crime.