Before “America’s Got Talent,” Loren Allred felt like a chameleon. Now, she never wants to blend in with the crowd again.

The 34-year-old North Side native and “Britain’s Got Talent” alumna recently appeared on “America’s Got Talent: Fantasy League” alongside other former participants from across various iterations of the “Got Talent” franchise. Allred’s powerful voice dazzled everyone within earshot before her “Fantasy League” run was cut agonizingly short during Monday’s semifinals episode.

Allred told the Post-Gazette Thursday afternoon that while she was disappointed about not reaching the “Fantasy League” finals, she appreciates all the exposure and self-confidence she gained courtesy of her time on this inaugural edition of the long-running NBC talent competition show.

“I’ve never experienced the overwhelming support and the word getting out in the U.S. about me before this,” she said. “I think it was the right decision, for sure.”

Advertise with us

Judge Simon Cowell convinced Allred to join his “Fantasy League” team after being blown away by her vocal prowess on “Britain’s Got Talent.” She burst onto the “Fantasy League” scene during the show’s Jan. 15 episode by belting out a booming rendition of “Never Enough,” the song she performed for the 2017 movie musical “The Greatest Showman” that no one is ever allowed to mistake for a cover again.

For her second performance, Allred gave Cowell a list of songs she thought would pair well with her giant voice. Cowell considered Allred’s ideas, but instead suggested that she do her own spin on “Over the Rainbow” from “The Wizard of Oz.”

“I think it’s one of the most emotional songs of all time,” Allred said. “It’s hopeful, but the person singing it is in an in-between place and feeling like there’s this place I’m dreaming of. It’s empowering, but also conflicted. It’s all the emotions in one song.”

One can see why “Over the Rainbow” may have resonated thematically with Allred, whose natural shyness tends to clash with her burning desire for musical superstardom.

Still, it’s probably not a song many music or film lovers ever associated with soaring vocals — that is, until Allred sang it.

Advertise with us

She was proud of being “really able to make this version [of ‘Over the Rainbow’] my own” despite the 20 seconds where she literally forgot to breathe. Allred received universal praise from all four “Fantasy League” judges, though Mel B did question her song choice. Cowell took a shot at the former Spice Girl by asking if she would’ve preferred if Allred had sung something like “Wannabe.”

“I almost feel like she was using that moment to have that competitive nature with Simon,” Allred said. “I don’t think a lot of the audience agreed with her, and I thought Simon’s comeback was pretty funny.”

Mel B’s negativity did make Allred wonder if her comments would influence the voting decisions of the in-studio audience that had been tasked with determining who would make the finals. She couldn’t rely on the judges’ golden buzzers, which had all been used up by the time Allred took the stage as that semifinal round’s last act. (Her “Over the Rainbow” performance ended up airing quite early in Monday’s episode.)

If nothing else, Allred felt like she had done her best and was secure in the knowledge that “no matter what happened, I’d be OK.” It still stung, of course, when she ultimately finished in second place to the Pack Drumline. She had at least become friends with enough Pack members that she was more happy for them and less upset about missing out on the “Fantasy League” finals.

“I knew how much they wanted this and how much they practiced,” Allred said. “I knew they came from humble beginnings, and I was really excited for them.”

Advertise with us

Watching Monday’s episode reminded Allred that she had once allowed herself to believe that after so many missed opportunities, “Wow, maybe this is the one I could take home!” A pre-”Fantasy League” Allred may have “taken my elimination more personally,” but the confidence she gained throughout that experience helped leave her at peace with how everything unfolded.

Since her television fate was revealed, Allred has been inundated with “thousands of comments and texts” expressing their incredulity over the semifinals results. She thanked all the Pittsburghers who cheered her on and said they may be able to catch her later this year at the Steel City’s annual Pride celebration.

These days, Allred is readying the release of her “Over the Rainbow” cover and completing the music video for “Never Enough (Loren’s Version).” She’s in the process of writing some original music and has also fielded a few calls about potential auditions for Broadway shows.

Whatever happens next, Allred will always be grateful to everyone at “America’s Got Talent: Fantasy League” for helping her find “my own voice and artistry” while also thickening her skin to the point that she now feels ready to perform on even bigger stages.

’For me, it’s more about singing my heart out and getting my story to the world,” she said. “I feel like I did that and ended on a high note.”

Joshua Axelrod: jaxelrod@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jaxelburgh.