Jaws dropped, eyes bulged and hands covered mouths during Loren Allred’s first appearance on the “America’s Got Talent: Fantasy League” stage.
The 34-year-old North Side native and “Britain’s Got Talent” alumna brought the house down using nothing but her powerful voice during Jan. 15’s episode of NBC’s new twist on the long-running talent competition series featuring past contestants from across the “Got Talent” franchise.
Allred’s soaring rendition of “Never Enough” — the song she originated in the 2017 movie musical “The Greatest Showman” — wowed the show’s four judges and earned her a spot in Monday night’s first round of semifinal performances.
Judge Simon Cowell, who enlisted Allred for “Fantasy League” after falling for her vocal prowess on “Britain’s Got Talent,” called her “an extraordinarily good artist” and said he hopes America “gives you the break that I genuinely believe that you deserve.” A vote of confidence from Cowell goes a long way for Allred, who’s ready to show everyone what she can do after years of shying away from the spotlight.
“It’s been really amazing,” Allred told the Post-Gazette last week. “I grew up watching ‘American Idol’ and almost being scared of his criticism. Him being so nice to me has been very validating.”
Allred spent the first 15 years of her life in Pittsburgh before moving to Utah for high school and eventually settling down in New York City. She still identifies as a Pittsburgher and fondly recalled playing on the City Steps, visiting the (newly renamed) science center, receiving tennis lessons at Schenley Park and even getting attacked by a swan in North Park.
Read More
Singing was always an escape for Allred, who dreamed of making an album and landing on Broadway. She refused to perform publicly, though, until some high school friends pushed her to sing Mariah Carey’s “Someday” at a talent show. Allred went on to attend Boston’s Berklee College of Music and got her first record deal thanks to the singing videos she had been posting on her YouTube channel.
That label put her on season three of fellow NBC competition show “The Voice,” which Allred said wasn’t a particularly pleasant experience. Her awkward introduction to the world of televised singing combined with the disappointment of “just watching the years pass” without a completed album led Allred to quit the music industry and become “more interested in singing behind the scenes.”
A wedding band gig helped her find more work as a demo singer and, eventually, the voice that came out of Rebecca Ferguson’s mouth as her character, opera savant Jenny Lind, belted out “Never Enough” in “The Greatest Showman.” Allred praised the way Ferguson “really sold ‘Never Enough’” and said that for a while, she was perfectly content if most “Greatest Showman” fans had no idea who actually performed that song.
“My voice is out in the world, and that has always been one of my goals, to create something that will live beyond me,” she continued. “I love the fact that she was the one in the movie and I could be more safe behind the scenes.”
It began to irritate her, though, when she would sing “Never Enough” at private events and folks would compliment her on a great cover. It still took her a year after being contacted by “Britain’s Got Talent” producers during the height of COVID-induced lockdowns to decide it was now or never if she wanted to step out of the shadows and shout, “This is me!”
Cowell was “surprised and shocked” to learn that the woman standing in front of him on the “Britain’s Got Talent” stage was the real voice behind one of his favorite songs. Allred ended up making the finals before ultimately finishing in ninth place. She was proud of sticking around for so long despite the many viewers and British media members who thought she was too experienced for “Britain’s Got Talent.”
“As the show progressed, I felt more empowered and comfortable because I had faced my biggest fear, which was people in the press not liking me,” Allred said. “I feel like I’ve broken the ice on my fear and can do anything now.”

There was no part of Allred that hesitated after getting the call to appear on “America’s Got Talent: Fantasy League.” Cowell selected her as one of the 10 acts he would mentor in hopes that one of them would eventually be crowned the inaugural “Fantasy League” champion.
Though she was skeptical when Cowell suggested she break out her signature song right away, Allred heeded his advice and dazzled everyone in attendance with the highest “Never Enough” notes she has ever performed live. She was relieved and thrilled when the “Fantasy League” audience responded to her gambit with rapturous enthusiasm.
“That’s the strange phenomenon of the feeling of, this could be the greatest or most embarrassing moment of my life,” Allred said. “You don’t know what’s going to happen, and all you can do is stay focused in the moment and do your best.”
She and Cowell collaborated once again on the song she’ll be performing during Monday night’s episode that she couldn’t reveal in advance. In her mind, it’s the “perfect song to follow ‘Never Enough’ in my career.”
Speaking of which, Allred made sure to mention that her other new spin on that song dubbed “Never Enough (Loren’s Version)” is currently available to stream via Spotify and Apple Music. She’s aiming to release a full music video for “Never Enough (Loren’s Version)” sometime in February and also said that “America’s Got Talent” fans can expect more original music from her in the near future.
For now, Allred just wants everyone in her hometown to check out what she would like to believe is the greatest show on “America’s Got Talent: Fantasy League.”
“Pittsburgh raised me, and I’m proud to be a Pittsburgher,” she said. “I hope I make everyone back home proud.”
Joshua Axelrod: jaxelrod@post-gazette.com and Twitter @jaxelburgh.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.