The bottom line on ABC’s “The Conners” — aka “Roseanne” without Roseanne Barr — is that viewers who enjoyed the revival last spring are likely to be satisfied with this new iteration.
Just as “Valerie” continued on NBC for four seasons in the late 1980s after its namesake star, Valerie Harper, was fired following a salary dispute — producers killed off Ms. Harper’s Valerie Hogan and renamed the show “Valerie’s Family” (and later “The Hogan Family”) with Sandy Duncan joining the cast as a new maternal figure — “The Conners” doesn’t miss too many beats after Roseanne.
TV REVIEW: ‘The Conners’
When: 8 p.m. Tuesday, ABC.
Starring: John Goodman, Laurie Metcalf, Sara Gilbert.
ABC revived “Roseanne” earlier this year to blockbuster ratings and eagerly renewed the comedy for a second season (or an 11th season if you count the show’s original nine-season run). But then ABC canceled “Roseanne” after Ms. Barr let loose with a racist tweet. A few weeks later the network announced this spinoff, “The Conners” (8 p.m. Tuesday, WTAE-TV.)
Some of the problems that existed on “Roseanne” this past spring are still areas of concern in “The Conners,” most notably the acting by some of the show’s secondary cast members. And there are occasional groaner bits of dialogue. But reliably winning performances from stars John Goodman, Laurie Metcalf and Sara Gilbert continue to carry the series as it explores life after Roseanne along with the semi-topical storylines that “Roseanne” was built on.
The premiere, while it has its share of laughs, leans more heavily into drama as it deals with the absence of Ms. Barr’s character and the impact that has on her family. These scenes will play better among viewers who can separate Roseanne the fictional character from Ms. Barr, a feat that may be impossible for some. (ABC made the show available for review only if critics agree not to “discuss, imply or in any other way reveal what happens to the character of Roseanne Conner,” so no spoilers here.)
Based on two episodes screened, the show’s writers try to fill the Roseanne void with assorted combinations of characters and echoes from the show’s past. In the premiere, the writers write to the long-running conflict between Darlene (Ms. Gilbert) and her sister, Becky (Lecy Goranson), which was always a mirror of Roseanne’s squabbles with her sister, Jackie (Ms. Meltcalf).
A second episode that won’t air for a few weeks moves further away from the absence of Roseanne. This installment smartly relies on audience familiarity with existing characters, including Darlene’s ex-, David (guest star Johnny Galecki), who has a new girlfriend, Blue (Juliette Lewis, basically playing the same character she plays in HBO’s “Camping”). That said, Roseanne’s cackle is missed and the show’s humor quotient takes a bit of a dip without her sharp, nasally barbs. (The politics so prevalent in the spring run of episodes is missing from the two episodes previewed.)
Given its directive on not revealing Roseanne’s fate, it’s clear ABC aims to boost tune-in for the first episode. Surely network execs expect ratings to tumble in subsequent weeks.
The question becomes, will “The Conners” be able to sustain enough viewer interest to have as fruitful a run as “The Hogan Family” post “Valerie”? In this Peak TV era of unending TV choices that prospect seems questionable.
TV writer Rob Owen: rowen@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2582. Read the Tuned In Journal blog at post-gazette.com/tv. Follow RobOwenTV on Twitter or Facebook.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.