Watching Ken Burns and Lynn Novick’s epic documentary undertaking, “The Vietnam War,” one is reminded of the story of the blind men encountering an elephant.
This old Indian parable has six men touching the elephant in different places. One, finding the tail, says an elephant is like a rope. Another, with the ear, says the elephant is like a fan. In the end, they agree all of the viewpoints are possibly valid.
And so it is with “The Vietnam War,” a 10-episode, 18-hour interpretation told from various sides and through sociological as well as historical lenses. One part might be a somewhat dry political lesson, but the next segment, a painful, graphic account of incidents such as the My Lai massacre.
Although critically acclaimed, “The Vietnam War” has, for some veterans, been too difficult to watch. Whether or not these men and women have been diagnosed with Post Traumatic Stress Disorder, or have even put a name to their anxiety, it’s been viewed by some as a trigger.
“I think our veterans’ opinions of the series are, like of the war, all over the map,” said Todd DePastino, executive director of Pittsburgh-based Veterans Breakfast Club. “It’s a Rorschach test of how you view the country.”
The series recently concluded its first broadcast run, but now repeats locally on WQED Tuesdays through the end of November at 9 p.m. It also can be viewed with narration in English, Spanish and Vietnamese at PBS.org.
Read More
“My wife wanted me to watch with her, and I said ‘no,’ ” said Donny Keller, a Purple Heart veteran from Waynesburg, Greene County. “And then she said ‘What if I tape it?’ Again, I said ‘no.’ ”
Mr. Keller was a radio telephone operator, or RTO, from 1968-69 in the Mekong Delta. He was wounded twice, including an incident where seven men were killed as they walked into a booby trap. He took shrapnel in the face and right arm, and was hospitalized in Saigon.
When he heard PBS was presenting “The Vietnam War,” “I started having nightmares right off… I flailed in bed, I woke up soaked.”
Although early screenings for veterans elicited general praise, Mr. Keller is not alone in his concerns about re-visiting a traumatic time in his life. Having watched “two or three” episodes, Ken Swaney of Uniontown said it wasn’t cathartic: “I don’t know what could make you feel better. That war lasted a long time, people got tired of seeing this.”
He said he considered himself fortunate for having registered with the Navy after his draft number came up. A boilerman on a guided missile ship, Mr. Swaney said of his Army compatriots: “They saw much more, You know, walk over the bodies. We couldn’t see it, we were three miles out in the Tonkin Gulf.
“We didn’t see where those missiles were going or what they were doing. But they [Army] did, and that had to be horrible.”
“It’s certainly been a topic of conversation in my clinical sessions,” said psychologist Kathleen DeNardi, who heads the Pittsburgh Veterans Health Administration Combat Stress Recovery Clinic. For privacy reasons, Ms. DeNardi could not speak to specifics. “One of the things we work really hard to do in our clinic is to educate our patients about mental health in general, but PTSD in particular, especially those who might be experiencing it.
“I known there is a lot of misinformation [about PTSD] among the general population.”
Forty-six percent of the more than 70,000 patients in the VA Pittsburgh Healthcare System are Vietnam War-era veterans who are treated for myriad of issues both mental and physical. In the fiscal years 2016 and 2017, there were 11,130 visits/appointments in the Combat Stress Recovery Clinic. It also provides video appointments through its Telehealth program.
There are four clusters of symptoms used to diagnose PTSD: avoidance; occurring or re-experiencing thoughts about traumatic images or experiences; negative alteration in cognition and mood, or, how the person views or sees the world after experiencing trauma; and finally, hyper-arousal, what are considered classic anxiety symptoms.
“What I cannot reiterate enough is that PTSD is a disorder that people can recover from,” Ms. DeNardi said.
The vast VA Pittsburgh Healthcare System also provides walk-in assessments from 8 a.m.-4:30 p.m. weekdays in Oakland and provides one-on-one videoconferencing therapy sessions for those who live in areas not convenient to its other physical locations.
On a recent weekend, the Vietnam Traveling Memorial Wall program arrived for four days at the Greene County Fairgrounds in Waynesburg. The scaled-down version of the original in Washington, D.C. drew hundreds of vets for the formal programs and dozens during the more quiet hours.
Vietnam veteran Don Martin of Dunns Station, Washington County, spoke at the opening ceremony. He said he has not watched “The Vietnam War” or other accounts because he prefers to remember the war through his experiences as a reconnaissance expert.
“I’m afraid to watch these documentaries because if some kid asks me a question, I’m going to give him somebody else’s answer other than my own honest opinion. I don’t know if that makes any sense,” he said, raising his hands with a shrug.
“ ‘Platoon’ was based on a battle that I was in, and it had nothing to do with anything. I didn’t know this Oliver Stone guy but he keyed on things I did not see. I didn’t see people shooting people in the back. It’s [just entertainment], unless you’re getting blamed for it.”
Many veterans pointed out that, unlike the heros of previous wars, Vietnam-era soldiers were not celebrated on their return to the States. Burying memories of war, and the hesitation to talk about it later, were a pattern for many.
“We were called ‘baby-killers,’ ‘rapists,’ ” Mr. Keller said. “I never killed a baby, I never raped anybody but that’s what we were called.”
He said conversations with other vets have been theraputic, and that educating others through programs such as the Vietnam Traveling Wall has made it easier to talk about what was previously suppressed: “You’ve got to remember one thing: we didn’t know we had PTSD. I didn’t know until 10 years ago, didn’t know what it was. So how can you fight something you didn’t know you had?”
“I think, another problem was, when we came back, everybody said ‘that’s the only war America lost.’ We don’t feel like we lost. Had we been allowed to win, we would have,” Mr. Martin said.
“You got that right,” added Mr. Keller who, like Mr. Martin, was awarded the Purple Heart.
It has taken decades, but it seems many veterans are finally ready to open up. Mr. Martin said that his staying in the Army, in the Reserve stateside and then as a commander of the National Guard in Waynesburg, gave him a purpose.
“I wanted to help them [young soldiers] be prepared so they would not have to go through what we did.”
In Uniontown, Mr. Swaney said, about 60-80 veterans meet each Thursday night through the local AMVETS program there.
The Veterans Breakfast Club is a 501(c)3 nonprofit for vets of all eras. It has an ongoing “Veterans Voices” oral history project, and plans a spring tour to Vietnam next year. Mr. DePastino said that when the organization held its annual gala in late September, “The Vietnam War” documentary series was a topic of discussion.
“One veteran in particular put into words so wonderfully how he felt, Jim Puhala, a helicopter pilot.
“He said ‘I watched that and just felt so angry.’ He’s a very mild-mannered guy and his wife looked at him, astonished. She said ‘I didn’t know that; why do you watch [‘The Vietnam War’] every night?’
“Jim said ‘I’m angry at everything: I’m angry at Nixon, Johnson, Kennedy. I’m mad at the protesters, I’m mad at the men in the My Lai massacre, I’m angry at the enemy — everything about it.’
“I think he was grieving. The cost of the war was terrible, and these are people who know this war first-hand.”
Maria Sciullo: msciullo@post-gazette.com or @MariaSciulloPG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.