“Don’t say I showed you to the door/when all I did was hold it open.”
With those words, from the The Breakup Society song “Your Invitation to Quit,” Ed Masley described the demise of his previous band The Frampton Brothers.
The Pittsburgh power-pop group, which debuted in 1991 with “I Am Curious (George),” lasted a little less than a decade and went out with the brilliant “File Under F (For Failure),” a 1999 album produced by Conrad Uno (Young Fresh Fellows, Mudhoney, Presidents of the United States).
An entry in the Trouser Press praised Masley and the Framptons with terms like “good-natured roots pop,” “culture-maven commentary” and even “melodic genius.”
Then came the kind of big crash and burn you hear about on VH1’s “Behind the Music.”
Actually, it wasn’t really like that.
“It was just a slow, grueling descent into dysfunction,” Masley says.
The frontman had booked some admittedly ill-fated tours, they had been through nine drummers and the bass player had just quit, leaving core members Masley and guitarist Sean Lally at another crossroads.
“Lally and I were not just band members,” he says. “We were best friends for years, and The Frampton Brothers made us hate each other.”
It led to the invitation to quit, sent from Masley’s computer (pre-cellphone era) while at work one day as rock critic at the Post-Gazette.
“I emailed Lally and said, ‘I know you've been really unhappy. If you don't want to do this anymore, now is probably a good time for you to just quit,” Masley says. “He just said, ‘OK.’
‘I mean, the thing is, I wanted him to say, ‘no.’ I wanted him to suggest marriage counseling. I did not want him to take me up on the offer, right?
“And then he told me that I fired him by email! His take on that was firing him by email.”
Masley went on to form The Breakup Society, now based in Arizona, and Lally is in the Baltimore bands Zocko and The Starlings — Charm City.
On Saturday at The Government Center, they will reunite for the first time in 17 years, joined by the “File Under F” rhythm section of bassist Ray Vasko and drummer Bob Hoag (also of The Breakup Society), with guest appearances by the debut album lineup of Dave Vandervoort and Doug Blair.
The long gap between reunions is related to the last one, at the now-closed Bloomfield Bridge Tavern, not going as planned.
“We had lined up a friend of ours to drum who had to cancel at the last minute because of medical reasons,” Masley says “And so we had to find a substitute drummer on the fly who had never played our songs until the rehearsal the morning of the show.
“There's nothing wrong with that drummer — and he's a super nice guy, so I'm not saying anything against him — but we went in really poorly prepared and misrepresented what we were even about. It just ended up not being good. And so after that, I just didn't want to do it again.”
The unfortunate loss of both of Masley’s parents within the last few years led to reflection and a change of heart about the Framptons.
“I really appreciate the idea of reconnecting and staying connected with the people who are meaningful parts of your life while you have the chance," he says, “and The Frampton Brothers were a huge part of my life and the members of that band were huge parts of my life.”
Masley has been rehearsing in Arizona with Hoag, and the full band will reacquaint themselves with the songs here before the show.
And that won’t be the end.
“Then we’ll do the reunion album,” Masley says.
Really?
“Yeah, there's talk of it,” he says. “Lally and I are excited about working together again. Bob is excited about working with The Frampton Brothers again. That's an important chapter of his life.
“Finally, we get to be like Pavement, but it’s just that we’re all split apart.”
The show is part of the two-day Monongahela Pop Festival at Government Center with The Harry Von Zells, Benefits (release show) and Bat Radar. The Friday lineup is Greg Hoy & the Boys, The Garment District, Denalis and Pink Gin Marimbas. Tickets are $35; thegovernmentcenter.com.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.