Jill Sobule did most of her touring as a solo artist, but when she came to Pittsburgh, the folk-pop artist magically had a band — affectionately named Jill’s Jagoffs.

That story of that band, which will play tribute to the late artist on Friday, began with a pool game with English musician and songwriter Lloyd Cole in a Chicago bar in 1998.

Rod Schwartz, the bassist for 11th Hour and the various tributes to The Clash, The Police, etc., had missed his chance to see the British rocker in Pittsburgh because he was rehearsing to fill in on a Clarks gig. He liked Cole enough to go see him in Chicago at the Double Door.

“I went down to use the bathroom and the downstairs of the Double Door was a big room with a pool table, and only Lloyd Cole, nobody else in the room,” Schwartz says. “He asked me if I wanted to play a game of pool. And I was like, giddy, because it's like, ‘Wow, it's your guy. You're playing pool with him.’ And, literally, I racked it, he broke and before I could even pick up a stick, he's like, ‘Oh, Jill just came on. You gotta go check her out.’ She was in his band, The Negatives, but she was also the opening act.”

Advertise with us

Schwartz was much more interested in playing pool with Lloyd Cole but he went back up, a little resentful of Sobule for interrupting the moment.

“And then she played a song,” Schwartz says. “She played another song, and I'm like, ‘All right, that one was pretty good. Yeah, that one's catchy.’ And about halfway through, I was like, ‘Well, I hope she has merch. She just completely won me over.’ ”

By that point, the singer-songwriter was eight years into a career that began in 1990 with her debut album, “Things Here Are Different,” produced by Todd Rundgren. Her biggest splash came with her second, self-titled album in 1995, which included the striking “I Kissed a Girl” (not to be confused with the later Katy Perry song) and “Supermodel,” which made it onto the “Clueless” soundtrack.

Schwartz got a chance to meet her that night in Chicago, and then he saw her the next year when she came to Rosebud and just about every time after that.

“She was always so personable,” he says. “And then she was always by herself. She always played acoustic. And one time I just said to her, like, ‘You ever gonna come with a band? The arrangements of your songs for a band are so great. It'd be great to hear them with a band.’ And she said, ‘Well, put one together and we'll do it.’”

Advertise with us

And so he did, way back in 2004, and they were ready to go. But Sobule had so much going on, they didn’t make contact before she returned to play The Mattress Factory later that year.

“Me and my friend went, and I'm like, ‘Well, I'm not going to approach her about this. Obviously, it didn't happen. She was probably just nice, didn't know what to say, no big deal.’ And the show ended, I was walking out of the men's room and I hear this voice behind me go, ‘Hey, weren't we going to be in a band?’ And I turned around, and it's her. And it started all over.”

It still didn’t happen, however, because she would blow into town and never have time to rehearse. After driving her to a guitar store for a repair on the day of a show, they became closer friends and she would stay at the Schwartz house when she came to town.

“She loved staying with people,” he says. “I later saw an interview with a guy who was a friend of hers way back in the day, and he said that she didn't like being alone. She had the thrill of being on stage and being with so many people, and as a traveling person playing by herself, she wouldn’t want to go be alone in a hotel room.”

Jump forward in time to April 2023, and she was faced with a weeknight Club Cafe show that didn’t appear to be selling well. Schwartz texted her, saying, “We’ll sell it out for you. Let’s play.”

Advertise with us

“And she's like, ‘Let's do it,’” he says. “And we waited for weeks and weeks for a set list, and she was like, ‘I'll send you one, I'll send you one.’ And it never came. So we just learned songs on our own, like, ‘This is what we think she'll play.’ And a week before the show, she called and said, ‘Alright, let's do the set list.’ I'm like, ‘Well, I hope it's stuff we learned,’ and it pretty much was.”

They played a sold-out Club Cafe that night and had a great time doing it.

“It was funny because it was a lot of work for her,” Schwartz says. “Because she always played by herself, so she changed arrangements on songs, changed keys on songs, did them however she wanted to do them. And to go back and do something with a band, she actually had to listen to her songs and work in that kind of format. It was kind of an honor that she was willing to put in that kind of work.”

They played together two more times, at City Winery in November 2023 and May 2024. They had been set to do it again this June when news came that Sobule, at 66, had died in a house fire at someone else’s home in Minneapolis.

Since then, there has been a series of tribute shows across the country titled “Jillith Fair - Loving Jill Sobule” honoring the dates she was set to play those cities. Among the artists taking part are Tom Morello, Margaret Cho, Lisa Loeb and Amanda Palmer.

Advertise with us

“There was just no way we could play a show like, do a whole concert of her stuff, a month later. I mean, honestly, I couldn't listen to the songs. It was just too heartbreaking. It really took a while to be able to listen to the stuff again.”

City Winery told them to reach out when they were ready, and so they set the date for this week. The core band will include Schwartz, singer-violist Sarah Siplak, guitarists Steve Seel and Scott Canavan, drummer Kip Ruefle, keyboardists/horn players Tim Pollock and Terry Divelbliss, singer Holly Scott, singer-percussionist Tracey Whorton, trombonist Perry Pinto and cellist Clare Drobot. They will be joined by guest singers Liz Berlin (Rusted Root), Melissa Knauer (Fuzzy Comets) as well as Jen Fisher and Pete Bush (Salena Catalina).

Proceeds will go to the It Was A Good Life Foundation with the hope that some of her 70 unreleased songs will be completed.

“Variety did a nice piece about these tribute shows,” Schwartz says, “about how people feel a real attachment to her. But it ended with something that just kind of hit me. And it said a lot of her dear fans, close fans, are probably going to want to travel to a lot of cities to see a lot of different shows. Because when these shows end, it's probably going to be your last chance for quite a while to hear any of these songs live.

“And it just really struck me that I can't imagine these songs won't be played live. And the band talked about it amongst ourselves, and we're, like, ‘Even if we're the last city doing this, we gotta do this once a year.’ You know, hopefully other cities will still continue to do this. But you know, for us, we got to make sure these songs don't go away.”

The show is at City Winery Pittsburgh, Strip, at 7:30 p.m. Friday. Tickets are $20; citywinery.com.