Someday down the road there might be a “lost” album coming from The Cheats, so long as they can remember where it is.

It was to be the proper followup to the Pittsburgh punk band’s fifth album, “Cussin’, Crying ‘n’ Carrying On,” released in the dreaded summer of 2020.

“We did 14 songs,” says frontman Todd Porter, aka Todd Cheat. “But, ahhh, it was weird. It didn’t have hooks or anything. None of us liked it.”

Soon after the album was recorded with producer Johnny Razorblade of the local band Johnny and the Razorblades, in 2023, the Cheats’ young guitarist Rob Senomar exited the band that’s been through almost 40 members since forming in 2001.

Advertise with us

“He lived in Cleveland, so it was getting kinda…stressful,” Porter says. “When he first came in, he didn’t have a girlfriend. All at once, he got a girlfriend. He was trying to move, changed jobs, he said, ‘Awww, I can’t do it.’”

When Porter put out the word that they were looking for a new guitarist, Razorblade, who would occasionally fill in for Senomar, reached out to him.

“I was hesitant mainly because I’m the type of person who likes to put everything into whatever I’m doing and my band, Johnny and the Razorblades, was still going at the time,” Razorblade says. “I just didn’t feel like I’d be able to give them everything that I would expect from me. After talking with them though, they said that none of that mattered and they’ll work around my band and recording schedule with me and they did. I definitely wasn’t expecting to join The Cheats as an actual member, but it’s been the best fit for me for what I do.”

The five of them got back to work on what is now the fifth Cheats album, "Old Rats On A New Ship.”

It was a quick process, Porter says, “because Johnny’s a writing machine, and I guess he had a lot of stuff bottled up inside.”

Advertise with us

Porter — along with guitarist Devon Holiday, bassist Philthy Phil and drummer Kyle Cheat —  threw him assorted riffs and lyrical ideas and said, ‘Write em,’ and Razorblade shot back quickly with demos. In less than a year, they had the 11 songs and a title courtesy of “The Sopranos.”

“I started re-watching ‘The Sopranos’ recently,” Porter says, “and there was an episode where all the old guys come out of prison and they start jacking stuff up for the rest of the guys. Ad the one dude goes to Junior, ‘These guys are coming out, [messing] everything up.’ And he goes, ‘Whattaya gonna do. It’s old rats on a new ship.”

Given that Porter, also a famed tattoo artist and 61-year-old grandfather, is used to comments like “these old guys still rock,” he could relate.

The old rats rip through 11 songs, most clocking in just over two minutes, with youthful punk fury and the grizzled howl of Porter, whose legacy in Pittsburgh dates back to 1986 with hardcore band Eviction. Of his vocal style, which he carried into Silver Tongued Devil, Porter said in a previous interview, “I just stole everything from Lemmy.”

The Cheats set a thrashy pace with opening track “Blood from a Stone” and never let it up, whether they’re riding the more hard rock edge or the pop-punk one.

Advertise with us

“The tune’s are a little more catchy, faster [than the last album],” Porter says. “We got some power-pop influences going.”

“Todd originally told me he wanted to do a power-pop record and that’s what I started with, like power-pop songs with a punk influence,” Razorblade says. “ ‘I Wanna’… was the first one. Then he mentioned that it was really poppy, so I went the other direction and found some balance.”

Two of the standouts, easily gleaned from the titles, are the full-throttle “Everything You Love Will Die” (as fast as punk gets) and the slyly funny “The Only Thing I'm [expletive that rhymes with ‘ducking’] Is Up.”

“We were playing one night in West Virginia,” Porter says, “and I said to Johnny, ‘I got this title for a song.’ I think some old Black comedian said it somewhere. I sang him the chorus, and he was like, ‘Let me see what I can do with it.’ Johnny doesn’t drink, so he’s always working on stuff.”

Porter had a rough demo back the next afternoon and the song was recorded within the week.

Advertise with us

“Being in The Cheats has been a great experience because we all have a lot of the same influences on where we pull things from,” Razorblade says. “We all like Springsteen and the Backyard Babies and other things, but at the same time, I might pull more from power-pop like Sorrows or The Exploding Hearts. Devin is pulling from things you wouldn’t expect, same with Phil and Kyle. It all works so well to me. I can honestly say that this record is probably my favorite album that I’ve been a part of.”

The band’s album release show will take place at The Crafthouse Stage and Grill, Whitehall, on Saturday with Electric Frankenstein and The Ravagers.