The least secret thing about today’s pop music is that much of it uses the same simple four chords in a loop.

Probably the most popular demonstration of this is the song “4 Chords” by Axis of Awesome, with more than 100 million listens across streaming platforms, where a group of musicians sing Journey’s “Don’t Stop Believin’,” Train’s “Hey, Soul Sister,” “Can You Feel the Love Tonight” from “The Lion King,” Men At Work’s “Down Under,” a-ha’s “Take On Me” and literally dozens other famous tunes over a four-chord progression to demonstrate its furtive ubiquity.

Some listeners have a tendency to mistake simplicity for triteness. I’ve certainly rolled my eyes while looking down my nose and sniffing haughtily at artists that loop those four chords for yet another song about a breakup or hookup or slip-up or whatever.

Here’s looking at you, Ed Sheeran.

Advertise with us

Well. Our great and revered and bewigged classical masters used to use that exact same loop. Repeating a bass line while changing melody above it is called a “ground bass” — not to be conflated with the walking bass in jazz and blues! — and it’s been a popular kind of composition for hundreds of years, dating back to the Renaissance and Baroque periods of yore.

Classical composers just had fancier names for these compositions – rather than “songs,” they wrote “passacaglias” and “canons” and instead of a “looped bass” they called it a “basso ostinato.” Oy vey.

The difference between those lute-bearing bards of yesteryear and today’s crooners is technological in part.

Sheeran can loop himself playing his own layered bass and harmony, but the famous coffee-addicted Baroque composer Johann Sebastian Bach would have needed to hire additional musicians for each additional layer of complexity over even the simplest of basses.

(Maybe that’s why he had 20 kids — free backup players.)

Advertise with us

And here’s the rub: Composers back then were using a similar four-chord progression.

Why that particular harmonic progression is so predominant in Western music is another topic, but digging through music history for the evolutionary bones of today’s popular music confirms a direct link.

To demonstrate, meet musical archaeologist Andrew Fouts. A resident of Pittsburgh’s Manchester neighborhood, Fouts is one of the city’s leading early music violinists, meaning he specializes in performing music from the Renaissance and Baroque periods, or the 1400-1700s, with arcane instrumental equipment.

Fouts is also the co-artistic director of the early music organization Chatham Baroque and the proud owner of a Boss RC-600 loop pedal, which will feature in an upcoming Chatham Baroque performance featuring violin and theorbo (a kind of lute, which in turn is kind of an ancestor of the guitar) playing pop music from the 1600s to today.

In an office in the bowels of a grand old episcopal church that also serves as Chatham’s headquarters, Fouts plucks a simple bass line on his violin, poking at a pedal on the looper with his foot to record and start. He layers a simple harmony on top of the bass, and then another, and then a rhythm line with some lazy beatboxing, before diving into a complex melody filled with scales and flourishes — a one-man Baroque band.

Advertise with us

The song sounded like it could have been written hundreds of years ago.

It was Billie Eilish’s “Birds of a Feather.”

“Most modern songs are kind of all ground basses in a way due to their simplicity, though the bass changes for verse and chorus and bridge,” he said.

 
 
 
View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Chatham Baroque (@chathambaroque)

He drew connections between the Baroque composer Jean-Paul-Egide Martini’s “Plaisir d’amour” (“Pleasure of love”) and the song “Can’t Help Falling in Love With You,” Heinrich Biber’s 1676 “Passacaglia” and the Ray Charles hit “Hit the Road Jack” and more.

“Make that same progression major, go down the scale further, and you've got the opening part of Nina Simone's ‘My Baby Just Cares for Me’ and the chorus in Janet Jackson's ‘Together Again,’” he said.

Advertise with us

These basses and progressions are about as cliche as the adage about nothing being new under the sun, but they’re also an unsubtle reminder that complexity and quality aren’t the same thing.

Chatham Baroque performs “Popular Music Across the Centuries” on Saturday at 7:30 p.m. at St. Andrews Episcopal Church and Sunday at 2:30 p.m. in the Hicks Memorial Chapel at the Pittsburgh Theological Seminary. Tickets are $45 with discounts for students and seniors at chathambaroque.org.

Jeremy Reynolds: jreynolds@post-gazette.com. His work at the Post-Gazette is supported in part by a grant from the San Francisco Conservatory of Music, Getty Foundation and Rubin Institute.