Let’s put aside snobbery — of course you don’t need to understand a work of art’s form to appreciate it.
However.
In my experience, it can certainly help, much in the same way that a good light source can elevate a spelunking expedition by revealing more of the depth and beauty of a cave system.
The Pittsburgh Symphony is launching its subscription series on Friday at 7:30 p.m. — a half hour earlier start time than in previous years! — with what happens to be one of the works that convinced me to dive headlong into classical music: German composer Felix Mendelssohn’s Violin Concerto in E minor. Star soloist Augustin Hadelich is the violinist, while PSO music director Manfred Honeck conducts. Tickets begin at $25 at pittsburghsymphony.org.
As a wee 12 year old, I didn’t know or care that the first movement was in “sonata form,” that the second was in ternary form or that the finale was a rondo. I just knew that I liked the shape of the melodies and that I could hear the main themes return in each movement and the feelings they evoked as they evolved and flexed in performances.
Now, however, 20 years and thousands of hours of listening and studying later, I’m comfortable saying that a general knowledge of formal structures can indeed enhance the joy I find in listening to such music. Having a rough idea of how a piece is going to go allows for surprise and delight when it conforms or deviates. It also allows listeners to track the work’s progress in a more concrete manner than simply letting the sensation wash over them.
Read More
Again, not that there’s anything wrong with this style of listening — I’m simply sharing my preference.
So to kick off this season, let’s have a quick and dirty recap on a couple of the most common forms. Formalists, put the pitchforks down — this is meant for the curious, not the aficionado. If this proves helpful, I may continue recapping forms throughout the season.
Sonata form
The violin concerto opens in sonata form, which has three main sections: an exposition, development and recapitulation.
A what, a what and a what?
Lately, I’ve been explaining musical sonata form by comparing it to sitcom structure. There’s often an introduction (like a cold open) before the movement’s main theme appears, like the principal character or A plot. Then, there is a transition and a contrasting theme, sort of like a B plot.
This is the exposition.
Then, those two themes are deconstructed and pass through a variety of musical keys and textures and treatments. They blend together and split apart again, much like A and B plots intwining and untwining as a show’s characters work to solve an episode’s obstacles and reach a resolution.
This is the development.
To close, the main theme and often second theme return, somewhat transformed by their journey. In a sitcom, this is when the conflict is resolved and everything returns to status quo. Sometimes, there is a brief “coda” or epilogue of new material to provide symmetry with the introduction.
This is the recapitulation.
Rondo form
The final movement of the Mendelssohn is a kind of “rondo.”
This is even simpler than sonata form; there is a principal “rondo theme” that reoccurs often, with each repetition separated off by contrasting “episodes.” In the case of the Mendelssohn, after a brief introduction, the music speeds up and flits off in a first statement of the main theme in the solo violin.
(Part of my fascination with this piece is that it bears an uncanny resemblance to a theme from Disney’s “101 Dalmatians.” Probably a coincidence, but I’ll link below.)
This theme appears in the solo violin and various other sections of the orchestra as it alternates with other material, some of it transitory some of it more like additional themes.
Often, classical pieces in this form will speed up to end with a great fanfare or flourish.
Technically, this movement is in sonata-rondo form — the jargon can seem impenetrable at first. But this isn’t a necessary distinction right now.
Over the years, I’ve found that knowing how to zero in on what music will repeat and then focusing on the differences in the way it is written and performed when that music recurs to be one of the great artistic delights available to us today.
But I’m biased. It’s all in the ear of the beholder.
Now, here are the Dalmatians.
And here is the Mendelssohn at the start of the rondo theme.
Jeremy Reynolds: jreynolds@post-gazette.com. His work at the Post-Gazette is supported in part by a grant from the San Francisco Conservatory of Music, Getty Foundation and Rubin Institute.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.