Can an orchestra’s playing embody the character of its home city?
There are regional differences and dialects between America’s great symphonies. The Chicago Symphony was long known for its powerful, blustering brass; Cleveland’s orchestra for its transparent, silvery strings; the New York Philharmonic for their unruly, temperamental excellence.
What does the Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra sound like?
On Thursday, the orchestra gave a farewell performance led by music director Manfred Honeck before departing its semiannual European tour, which this year consists of a dozen already sold-out appearances in nine cities including Vienna and Salzburg. That concert showcased the musicians in music by the Russian master Rachmaninoff and the Austrian composer Mahler, just a taste of the repertoire the Steel City’s orchestra is bringing on this pilgrimage to the birthplace of Western orchestral music.
“Fine-tuned” is an understatement for their current level of preparation. In Rachmaninoff’s third piano concerto with famous pianist Yefim Bronfman, the orchestra’s blend proved sumptuous, with melody and countermelody alike slithering through the textures like a single organism flexing different parts of its musculature. All was shimmering subtlety until the unshackled, unbridled finale, an exercise in recklessness that pulsed straight to the back of Heinz Hall.
There is an energy — an intensity, a sense of abandon — that defines Pittsburgh’s sound. When timing and intonation align, the Steel City’s is certainly one of America’s great orchestras.
Read More
Next, the musicians leapt into Mahler’s Symphony No. 5 with similar fervor, leaning into the chaos and complexity of the counterpoint here without inhibition. The first two movements of this symphony are a funeral march and a dark, storming affair. The third transforms the character to a more rural, pastoral character, simpler and gentler than what came before.
And then, quiet strings and harp introduce the soul of the symphony, a slow, tentative movement of utter serenity. Here was the evening’s highlight — after all the sound and fury, the orchestra slipped into its new role with such utter conviction, it could have been another orchestra altogether.
This intensity of character is also a part of the orchestra’s DNA. Its interpretations may not always be appropriate or universally appealing, but they always dive headlong into the character, nothing done by half. This adaptability is as key to their reputation as a great orchestra.
There are parallels to be drawn here with Pittsburgh’s intrepid reinvention from the U.S. industrial capital to a city of education and technology and healthcare. That designation isn’t just corny local pride: The orchestra is currently a contender for Gramophone magazine’s worldwide “orchestra of the year” award.
The orchestra’s most recent recording has drawn praise from publications including The New York Times, Bachtrack and more.
Honeck has been the orchestra’s primary conductor for 16 seasons now. It’s his rapport with the orchestra and his detail-conscious nature as well as the caliber of each individual player that continue to elevate the Steel City’s orchestra on the metaphorical world stage.
And on Sunday, they depart to actually perform on some of the world’s actual stages.
Wish them well.
Jeremy Reynolds: jreynolds@post-gazette.com. His work at the Post-Gazette is supported in part by a grant from the San Francisco Conservatory of Music, Getty Foundation and Rubin Institute.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.