It took Marty Ashby more than 10 years to collect content and footage that would become the 2018 documentary aptly titled “We Knew What We Had: The Greatest Jazz Story Never Told.”
Along with Jeff Sewald, his cohort at MCG Jazz, his goal was to preserve and chronicle the unique jazz history of Pittsburgh.
The hourlong documentary, which aired on WQED and other public television stations, features Ahmad Jamal, Stanley Turrentine, Mary Lou Williams, Billy Eckstine, Kenny Clarke, Art Blakey, Ray Brown, Earl “Fatha” Hines, Erroll Garner, Billy Strayhorn and George Benson (mcgjazz.org, $19.99).
Manchester Craftsmen’s Guild founder Bill Strickland supported efforts to produce a film that would tell the authentic story of Pittsburgh’s jazz heritage while at least some of these luminaries were still alive.
“When Stanley Turrentine [2000] and Ray Brown [2002] passed away, I told our board, ‘I’m not going to lose another great Pittsburgh jazz figure before they can tell their own story,” Ashby said.
“The Pittsburgh jazz story is about the music and the people who created the music. It’s not Black, not white. It’s all about the music.
“There’s no narrator or host, just the cats telling the story,” said Ashby, a jazz guitarist from Baldwinsville, N.Y. “It’s not my opinion of them telling the story of how the music became so fertile or how the music developed.”
The documentary also discusses the demolition of the Lower Hill District and Crawford Grill No. 1, which was torn down in 1959 to make way for construction of the Civic Arena.
“Unfortunately, that side had to be told, too, with the destruction of the Lower Hill and the many lounges that were destroyed,” Ashby said.
In the film, Benson talks about the Hill’s downfall from personal experience.
“His input made the film profound, because he became a superstar even though his Hill District neighborhood was destroyed by so-called urban renewal,” Ashby said.
Musicians left out
“We Knew What We Had” won several awards and praise from many in the jazz world. But it also left out many musicians, club owners, disc jockeys and others that contributed to Pittsburgh’s place in jazz history.
Cecil Brooks Jr., a drummer in the city’s golden jazz era, and his son, drummer and club owner Cecil Brooks III, were among those disappointed.
“My dad was a contemporary of all those Pittsburgh greats, from Earl “Fatha” Hines, to Erroll Garner, Mary Lou Williams and more,” said the younger Brooks, who now lives in Los Angeles. “He knew them personally and performed with them all.”
His father, who turned 96 in June, continues to play. He believes he and his son should have been mentioned in the documentary along with others.
“Not only me, but probably my son, too. Not only was he a successful working musician here in the city, he had the nerve and fortitude to relocate to New York City, became a musician, record producer and a successful nightclub owner.”
Brooks Jr. also named guitarist Jim McClinton of Beaver Falls, and former band mates Bobby Jones and George Thompson.
His son listed keyboardist Brett Williams; drummers Phil Terrell, Jeff “Tain” Watts, Sylvester Goshay and Erik Hargrove of Washington, Pa.; bassists Mickey Bass and Chris Sullivan; trombonist Al Dowe; and vocalist Etta Cox.
“Drummer Jerry Betters deserves major mention for his musicianship and ability to own a successful jazz club in East Liberty, The Crescendo Lounge,” he said.
“That was the ultimate hang spot [in the 1980s] for local jazz lovers, musicians and patrons alike. And we can’t forget vibraphonist Steve Nelson and the great John “Squirrel” Mosley, the Roy Ayers trumpeter,” said Brooks III.
‘Cut in the editing suite’
Nelson Harrison, 83, a trombonist who performed with the Count Basie Orchestra, helped set up interviews with several famous musicians and acted as a historical consultant for the film.
“I told them to contact several older musicians who were still living at the time,” he said. “I gave them phone numbers and other ways to contact these people. They interviewed several of them, too, but when it came to the final product, many of these video interviews were cut in the editing suite.”
Among those he mentioned who didn’t make the cut were: Brooks Jr. and III; bandleader and club owner Joe Westray; trombonist Grover Mitchell; bassists Paul Thompson and Mike Taylor; drummer Gill Clark; trombonist Harold Betters, flautist Nicole Mitchell and saxophonist Art Nance.
Also worth noting is North Side drummer Charles “Poogie” Bell Jr., who has backed Marcus Miller, Luther Vandross and Chaka Khan.
Since graduating from Peabody High School in 1973, Kevin Amos’ name has been synonymous with Pittsburgh jazz radio. Amos, along with WDUQ’s Tony Mowod and New Pittsburgh Courier columnists Hazel Garland and Doug Drown, has helped promote Pittsburgh’s jazz heritage.
After high school, Amos went to the University of Pittsburgh, where he became a freshman classmate of football stars Tony Dorsett and Gary Burley. Amos’ love for traditional jazz deepened upon meeting DJs Thomas “Saxxie” Williams, Ahmir Rashid and Buck Bryce.
“These guys deserve to be mentioned in all Pittsburgh jazz documentaries,” he said. “Also Jimmy “Fats” Ponder, Kenny Blake, Leon Dorsey, James Johnson III, Nicole Mitchell and Geri Allen. And Erroll Garner’s older brother, Linton Garner, was another very talented pianist who very rarely gets mentioned.”
“I recall Dr. Nathan Davis wanting to spotlight some of the younger Pittsburgh cats like Greg Humphries, Larry “Butch” McGee, Tony Campbell, Rodney McCoy, Arnold Stagger and Larry Estes.”
After leaving Pitt, Amos briefly worked at Point Park College’s WPPJ radio before becoming station manager at WYEP-FM, a community-oriented station on Pitt’s campus that specialized in jazz and competed with Duquesne University’s WDUQ.
Amos still works in radio but is semi-retired.
Part 2?
Ashby acknowledged that many other Pittsburghers deserve to be honored for their role in jazz history.
“We’re hoping to have a second part where we can spotlight several more deserving musicians,” he said. “We should have an easier time raising money for Part 2 after completing this one.”
During production of “We Knew What We Had,” Ashby said American Public Television specified that the film would be no more than one hour.
“We did our best with the time we had. It wasn’t like we were afforded a 16-part series like the Ken Burns PBS specials,” he said, noting that part of his inspiration to spotlight Pittsburgh’s jazz history was that Burns’ 10-part “Jazz” documentary did not acknowledge the city’s role in the American art form.
“Believe me, there are several musicians we wanted to highlight in this first viewing. We’re very hopeful that in the future, we will present a second part that will capture and highlight the many Pittsburgh-area musicians who are also well-deserving.”
He named Marcello “Mars” Scarazzo, Roy Eldridge, Maxine Sullivan, Eddie Jefferson, Vinnie Colaiuta, Richie Cole, Delsey McKay, Sammy Nestico, Arnold “Spider” Rondinelli, Locksley “Slide” Hampton and Dakota Staton.
“There’s a ton of them,” Ashby concluded.
Timothy Cox (teacawks2@gmail.com) is a freelance journalist, Point Park University graduate and former entertainment editor of the New Pittsburgh Courier.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.