In early 2021, employees nationwide began quitting jobs en masse in a move now called the “Great Resignation” or the “Big Quit.” Studies suggested that wage stagnation and dissatisfaction were the primary drivers.

The nonprofit arts sector, which was already experiencing the highest level of employee turnover of any industry due to low wages and a lack of opportunities for advancement, is still feeling the effects of the Big Quit and churning fiercely. Take the Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra, which in 2022 saw 50% of its staff depart for other jobs. (There are currently five positions posted to the symphony’s website.)

This has also made filling some positions difficult. For example, the Wheeling Symphony Orchestra in West Virginia struggled for more than a year to fill its executive director position.

Recently, however, the symphony announced it had found its new leader in Pittsburgh native Sonja Thoms, a trained oboist and experienced orchestra staffer who has worked for the Pittsburgh and Nashville symphonies.

Advertise with us

“There’s just been so much churn. I think everyone is being more selective about which jobs they’re willing to take,” Thoms said, adding that Wheeling has a little more staffing up to do now that she has taken on the executive role.

The orchestra in Wheeling, about an hour’s drive south and west from Pittsburgh, operates with a roughly $1.3 million budget and hires its musicians on a per-service basis, meaning that they are not full-time players. These musicians often teach and play in other smaller orchestras on the side to build a career. Some have “day jobs” as well.

Nevertheless, the organization has been creative over the years, pairing music and food and attempting new concert formats like “Symphony on Ice” (which is pretty much what it sounds like) to better embed itself in the fabric of its city.

In 2022, the orchestra won the Governor’s Arts Award for Resiliency in 2022 for its continued performances during the pandemic.

“It truly feels like an important part of the community,” Thoms said. “I want to honor and lean into that.”

Advertise with us

She added that having worked at larger orchestras like Pittsburgh’s, which operates with a roughly $30 million budget, she has an appreciation for an orchestra’s capabilities.

“I think the work of an orchestra doesn’t change by size, but it does scale based on what resources are available.”

The Wheeling Symphony, which operates with only a few full-time staff members, also announced that it has extended music director John Devlin’s contract for an additional four years. Devlin is the creative impetus behind many of the symphony’s creative concert formats.

The orchestra’s next performances are a “Farm to Fork” fundraiser on Aug. 26 and a James Bond-themed performance on Sept. 3. The 2023-24 season schedule is not yet posted but will be in coming weeks at wheelingsymphony.com.

Jeremy Reynolds: jreynolds@post-gazette.com. His work at the Post-Gazette is supported in part by a grant from the San Francisco Conservatory of Music, Getty Foundation and Rubin Institute.