Pretty much everyone’s heard of Yo-Yo Ma, right?
The amazing cellist who pops up on TV shows like “Mr. Rogers’ Neighborhood” and movies every now and then, a player so excellent he’s — a bit like Kermit the Frog — pretty much universally admired and adored?
OK, what would happen if Yo-Yo joined a Grammy Award-nominated beatboxer, Christylez Bacon, onstage in Wheeling West Virginia and laid down some fresh(ish) Johann Sebastian Bach?
The result was an energetic, zippy musical fusion, delightful in its novelty, a little like overlaying braille on top of a piece of liquid-smooth glass. Or maybe more like a bit of chili powder thrown on fois gras to inventive effect.
At any rate, the concert in question was the Wheeling Symphony Orchestra’s first ever gala on Thursday evening. The program was all-American and all by living, breathing composers: famous film scorer John Williams’ Concerto for Cello and Orchestra with Mr. Ma flanked by Caroline Shaw’s “Entr’acte” and a new piece for the orchestra, “Migrations in Rhythm: A Concerto for Beatbox and Rhyme” by composer Evan Meier. Music director John Devlin conducted the concert for a crowd of about 1,800 in the landmark Capitol Theatre in Wheeling, the orchestra’s home.
The concerto for beatbox was the evening’s biggest swing. It wasn’t a miss, but maybe a foul. Here’s why: the work was a survey of American music, sampling rhythms and harmonies from different eras with the voice woven in between. The piece transitioned rapidly without much to connect its different threads except for Bacon rapping verses explaining the history behind each selection before beatboxing his way through a few minutes of ‘50s nostalgia or the like.
Read More

The main problem was the balance. The orchestra was simply too loud for Bacon, and it was difficult to hear his verses, at least from my position on the balcony of the theatre. This robbed the concerto of its coherence and emotional impact.
This isn’t to say that orchestras shouldn’t attempt to commission music that bridges historical and contemporary traditions, only that it’s incredibly difficult to do it well.
There was a well-intentioned attempt, though, with solid playing from the orchestra. Now, the Wheeling Symphony Orchestra is not like the Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra. It has a budget of about $1.8 million compared to Pittsburgh’s $30 million. Its players mostly perform in many smaller orchestras and teach or have side jobs. It plays a handful of concerts a year as opposed to nearly every weekend, like in Pittsburgh, and draws around 700-1,000 per show.
This isn’t a knock at all — these orchestras are invaluable to the cultural backbone of the country. And the Wheeling Symphony played well, Thursday. If anything, I wanted more contrast between loud and soft passages, particularly in the strings, and maybe a bit more rhythmic precision at times.
In the first half of the concert, string players stood among listeners in the auditorium for the “Entr’acte,” a nice bit of symbolism for bringing the music to listeners. And Ma’s playing in the Williams concerto was, as always, arresting, evocative and emotionally gripping. At the end of his performance, Bacon popped out on stage for the pair’s duet, the Gigue from Bach’s Suite No. 3 for Solo Cello.
The pair complemented each other well; the fusion made for a zest that gave this historic piece a certain friskiness.
Yo-Yo Ma will visit the Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra in February. The Wheeling Symphony Orchestra will continue to program creative offerings, including a series that pairs local chefs with instrumental music, called SoundBites.
Jeremy Reynolds: jreynolds@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1634; twitter: @Reynolds_PG. Mr. Reynolds' work at the Post-Gazette is supported in part by a grant from the San Francisco Conservatory of Music, Getty Foundation and Rubin Institute.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.