Time wasn’t on their side, and neither was the temperature, when the Acousticafe crew did their stellar tribute to The Rolling Stones on Light Up Night.

Opening for Joan Jett & the Blackhearts, the ensemble of Pittsburgh luminaries had worked up a 20-song set that would run nearly 90 minutes.

Due to frigid temperatures and logistical issues that November evening, they got through 13 of them before their set ended at around the 65-minute mark with some confusion about whether they could keep going.

The crowd got soul man Kenny Stockard sounding like a dead ringer for Keith Richards on “Happy,” former Rusted Root singer Jenn Wertz killing it on “Midnight Rambler,” Gary Musisko letting loose on “Monkey Man,” Chet Vincent slashing through “Street Fighting Man,” a hot jam on “Can’t You Hear Me Knocking,” a full cast treatment of “You Can’t Always Get What You Want” and more.

Advertise with us

Somehow, the guitarists — Jon Reider, Pete Bush and Steve Hobaugh — were able to navigate those dirty Stones riffs with icy fingers.

Lost in the shuffle were second helpings from some of the marque singers as well as two selections from the next generation: “Paint It Black” led by 18-year-old Gibson Musisko, the son of Wertz and Musisko, and “The Last Time,” featuring Cassandra and Vanessa Prentiss, the daughters of bandleader/bassist Jesse Prentiss.

After the set, Jesse and Liz Berlin — Rusted Root singer and Mr. Smalls co-owner — sent a message asking if the musicians would want to encore the set at The Funhouse at Mr. Smalls with the full 20 tracks.

“Everyone was on board in an instant,” Wertz says.

That occasion will be Friday night at the Millvale venue, where additions to cast include Jon Bindley, of Bindley Hardware Co., and Mike Speranzo, Mr. Smalls co-owner and Drowning Clowns guitarist. Orange Music, which was limited to 15 minutes on the Light Up Night bill, will get a full set as opener.

Advertise with us

For Wertz, the truncated set was the only downside to a special night in which she got to duet with her son, Gibson, frontman of the indie-rock band PosterChild, on “Mother’s Little Helper.” She also got a kick out of the wild version of “Monkey Man” from Musisko, an Acousticafe regular and former member of The Regal Sweet.

“Gary is a hidden gem in Pittsburgh,” Wertz says. “He has such a range. He can sing on par with Jeff Buckley and then sort of at the level of Jim Morrison.”

The three of them, who were part of “You Can’t Always Get What You Want,” hadn’t sung together in public since Gibson was a preschooler at an Acousticafe night.

It was also a chance for Wertz to show off some fierce harmonica work doing Jagger’s part on “Midnight Rambler.”

Learning the song, she says, “I thought ‘That sounds like a pretty easy harmonica part and I got on a basic C harmonica to play it, and I was like, ‘WHAT is happening?! I feel like it's the wrong key or something.’ I ended up Youtube-ing it, and this harmonica master guy was like, ‘You might have just got yourself a C harmonica and started trying to play ‘Midnight Rambler’ and you might think that you're in the wrong key.’ I was like, ‘Yeah.’ And he said, ‘What you have here is a very underrated, world-class harmonica player in Mick Jagger, who's doing some pretty tricky stuff.”

Advertise with us

By Light Up Night, she had Jagger’s breathing technique down pat.

For how cold it was, and with everything else happening at Light Up Night, she was pleased with the turnout for a Stones tribute that followed the Beatles tribute the year prior.

“We were stunned and so grateful at the number of people who showed up for our set,” she says. “It was a total joy. I had a super good time playing with these folks.”

The show is at 7:30 p.m. Friday. Tickets are $15 at mrsmalls.com.