It was long ago and not so far away …
It was right in Polish Hill, actually, which isn’t far from Mazeroski Field in Oakland, where a weekly Sunday afternoon co-ed pickup softball game took place among musicians from punk bands like A.T.S., The Feral Family, The Crow Flies and The Working Poor.
Some of them were really good. Others were better off sticking to the Electric Banana. But no one cared — it was just for fun.
In May 1994, I got a call from a local promoter asking if I could rustle up a team to play against a band and crew coming into town.
It was Meat Loaf, who, after a 15-year drought on the singles charts, had risen from the ashes to go to No. 1 with “I'd Do Anything for Love (But I Won't Do That)” and was headlining the Civic Arena May 29 on the Everything Louder Tour.
The afternoons, before soundcheck, were spent on visiting fields where the Meat Loaf softball team took on a hometown contender. Meat Loaf was, in fact, a lifelong jock. According to legend, during a clumsy moment in practice with his high school football team in Dallas, the coach hollered at Marvin Lee Aday, “Get off my foot, Meatloaf!”
Read More
Rock legend was born.
While making “Bat Out of Hell II” in 1991, Meat Loaf was lying low coaching a girls’ softball team in Redding, Conn., so he knew his way around the diamond as well.
We were clearly not the stiffest competition to be found in Pittsburgh. We did not have one big, beefy guy. We were just quick and wiry.
So, there we were warming up at West Penn Field when a tour bus pulled up and out stepped Meat Loaf in surprising game shape with a bunch of giants decked out in pristine uniforms — white jerseys, black pants, gothic red Meat Loaf hats, cleats. They were about to play a team wearing jeans and Converse shoes and, in one or two cases, boots.
Time warp to 2021, last week. I get on the phone with Meat Loaf, who is coming in for Steel City Con this weekend, and start with some small talk.
“Hey” — I don’t even say his name, ’cause I’m not gonna call someone “Meat,” even though his friends do — “do you remember playing a softball game here in ... ?”
Before I even get the words out of my mouth, he goes, “I’m sorry you lost.”
Stop right there!
I thought to myself.
I didn’t go Ellen Foley on him, because this was one minute into an interview and there was no good reason to derail it by squabbling about a game 30 years ago that he clearly doesn't even remember.
“I'm not sure that's how it went,” I said mildly. “I don't know. It was a good game ... ”
“Well, I can tell you you lost,” he said firmly. “We only lost one game in two years: It was against the Arizona indoor football team.”
Like I said, it was long ago (and not so far away), but as I recall, we creamed that Meat Loaf team.
He pitched, laying up literal and figurative softballs, and we knocked so many balls off his legs I was afraid he wasn’t going to be able to play the show that night. I’m not gonna say the Pittsburgh punks had any resentment toward a guy who sold 65 million albums, but...
We slapped singles and doubles and stretched them into extra bases, played out of our mind in the field and basically made them look big and soft.
I reached out via Facebook to a few musicians who played with him on that tour but haven’t heard back. I have no idea if they played softball. Maybe someone from his side will read this silly thing and help settle this.
I did reach left-handed hitter Ed Masley, who in ’93 was playing in The Frampton Brothers and writing music stories for the Post-Gazette. He remembers us winning, too.
I’ve got no proof of what happened on West Penn Field — there were no cellphones, no social media, no scorebook (in our dugout) and no crowd (as it wasn’t to be publicized). But I’m damn sure we remember it better than he did.
How often do you get to bat against Meat Loaf?
“I got a double,” Masley recalls, “and when I got to second base, I told him, ‘I got your bat out of hell!’ ”
And that, I believe, was the inspiration, many years later, for “Bat Out of Hell III: The Monster Is Loose.”
If you have any information on the events of May 29, 1994, please email smervis@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.