Roger McGuinn and Chris Hillman, on stage together, would probably be great even with some random guys you picked up off the street.
With Marty Stuart and the Superlatives, well, the name says it all.
The show Tuesday night at Carnegie of Homestead Music Hall was one we’ll never forget, because, first of all, it’s rare to see one of these Byrds, let alone two of them together. The occasion for the McGuinn-Hillman reunion is the 50th anniversary of “Sweetheart of the Rodeo,” the seminal 1968 album that found the Los Angeles-based folk/psych-rock band flowing into country mode.
For that, they could not have done better than the Superlatives, a crack quartet with heavenly harmonies of their own and the jaw-dropping chops of frontman Stuart, playing some of the sweetest, most nimble guitar and mandolin solos you’ll ever hear.
They took the stage with a country-flavored Byrds sampler, beginning with Dylan’s “My Back Pages” and bouncing through favorites like “Mr. Spaceman,” which they said was inspired by the Beatles doing country, and lesser-known pieces like “Time Between,” Hillman’s first stab at writing.
You don’t expect “Drug Store Truck Drivin' Man” to turn up on a Byrds set list, but being in storyteller mode, it fit well. They explained that it was about a visit they had with a Nashville DJ who took their “Mr. Tambourine Man” single off the turntable in 10 seconds and said, “I’m not gonna play that! What’s it about?”
“I don’t know,” McGuinn told him. “It’s a Bob Dylan song!”
In telling the story, McGuinn left it open to interpretation as to whether Bob Dylan songs should have been played automatically in 1964 or whether they were just incomprehensible.
As for his Byrds bandmate at the time, when McGuinn first strummed it out on acoustic guitar, David Crosby said, “I don’t like it, man!” But, dipping into the Bach canon, he came up with that jangling riff on his Rickenbacker guitar that sounded amazing then, and now, to a folk-rock devotee, makes you feel like you’re seeing Van Gogh at his easel when you hear it live.
Just over a half-hour in, they took a 20-minute intermission, which was odd, after which we were rewarded with a mini-set from the Superlatives (Stuart, Kenny Vaughan, Chris Scruggs and Harry Stinson) starting with a gorgeous nearly a cappella treatment of the gospel song “Angels Rock Me to Sleep,” which Stuart said he was offering “to your beautiful city.”
They gave us reason to come back and see them alone next time, tearing up the stage with the roadhouse burner “Country Boy Rock & Roll” and the very Byrds-inspired “Time Don’t Wait.”
McGuinn and Hillman returned to take us to the Grand Ol Opry, L.A. Byrds-style, with “Sweetheart,” running a classic gamut from Dylan (“You Ain't Goin' Nowhere,” “Nothing Was Delivered”) to Woody Guthrie (“Pretty Boy Floyd”) to Merle Haggard (“Life in Prison”) to Gene Autry (“Blue Canadian Rockies”).
Going into the ‘68 Byrds record, McGuinn said they were looking for a piano player and found Gram Parsons. “I didn't know,” he added, “he was going to turn into George Jones in a sequined suit.” Parsons enriched the album, and thus the show, with the wistful ballad “Hickory Wind” and the midtempo country-rocker “One Hundred Years From Now.”
The unexpected “Sweetheart” standout was “You Don't Miss Your Water,” which swept us up in a beautiful wave of harmonies, bringing everyone to their feet.
Hillman told us in an interview last week that Haggard once told him it was “almost” a great album. Almost. If that’s the case, with the Superlatives on board, they inched quite a bit closer to greatness.
The five-song encore was, in part, their tribute to the late Tom Petty, the finest of the Byrds disciples. They sounded like the Heartbreakers rocking through “King of the Hill,” McGuinn’s ‘90s duet with Petty; Hillman took the lead on a sweet, bluegrassy version of “Wildflowers”; and Stuart led the way on “Runnin’ Down a Dream” with, simply, the best mandolin solo I’ve ever witnessed.
Opening and closing the encore were two pieces of classic Byrds: “So You Want to Be a Rock 'n' Roll Star” and “Turn! Turn! Turn! (To Everything There Is a Season).” It was almost hard to grasp that all these years later, we were hearing these songs played live, so perfectly.
So basically, it had been a half-century since “Sweetheart” and 30 years since McGuinn and Hillman toured together -- and somehow they turn up in vintage form. How is that even possible?
Scott Mervis: smervis@post-gazette.com.
SWEETHEART OF THE RODEO TOUR SETLIST
My Back Pages
(Bob Dylan cover)
A Satisfied Mind
(Joe Hayes cover)
Mr. Spaceman
(The Byrds cover)
Time Between
(The Byrds cover)
Old John Robertson
(The Byrds cover)
Wasn't Born to Follow
(Carole King cover)
Sing Me Back Home
(Merle Haggard cover)
Drug Store Truck Drivin' Man
(The Byrds cover)
Mr. Tambourine Man
(Bob Dylan cover)
Intermission:
Angels Rock Me To Sleep (traditional) (Marty Stuart and His Fabulous Superlatives only)
Country Boy Rock & Roll
(Marty Stuart cover) (Marty Stuart and His Fabulous Superlatives only)
Time Don't Wait
(Marty Stuart and His Fabulous Superlatives cover) (Marty Stuart and His Fabulous Superlatives only)
You Ain't Goin' Nowhere
(Bob Dylan & The Band cover)
Pretty Boy Floyd
(Woody Guthrie cover)
Hickory Wind
(The Byrds cover)
Life in Prison
(Merle Haggard and The Strangers cover)
One Hundred Years From Now
(The Byrds cover)
Nothing Was Delivered
(Bob Dylan & The Band cover)
Blue Canadian Rockies
(Gene Autry cover)
The Christian Life
(The Louvin Brothers cover)
You're Still on My Mind
(Luke McDaniel cover)
You Don't Miss Your Water
(William Bell cover)
I Am a Pilgrim
([traditional] cover)
You Ain't Goin' Nowhere
(Bob Dylan & The Band cover)
Encore:
So You Want to Be a Rock 'n' Roll Star
(The Byrds cover)
King of the Hill
(Roger McGuinn cover)
Wildflowers
(Tom Petty cover)
Runnin' Down a Dream
(Tom Petty cover)
Turn! Turn! Turn! (To Everything There Is a Season)
(Pete Seeger cover)




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.