Which is the best orchestra in the U.S.? And how do you even measure such a thing?

Organizations such as the Grammy Awards and the International Classical Music Awards recognize exceptional orchestral performances and recordings, but aside from these how do you stack one ensemble against another?

A New York Times headline in January suggested that Cleveland may have that honor, nodding to the orchestra’s world-renowned sound, work ethic and collaborative spirit.

(Last year, a Cleveland sweet shop created a chocolate bar honoring the Cleveland Orchestra’s centennial, a serious mark in its favor.  Where’s the chocolate, Pittsburgh?)

Advertise with us

Cleveland was one of the so-called Big Five orchestras of the 20th century alongside the orchestras in New York, Boston, Chicago and Philadelphia. That outdated assignation was based on metrics like budget size or base salary, or how often and where an ensemble tours and its recording output. Those numbers are often still used today to assess quality, as it does follow to a degree that higher paying orchestra jobs will attract the best players.

But the numbers don’t always add up, and a larger budget doesn’t guarantee quality. When it comes down to it, the best way to evaluate an orchestra is simply to listen.

Read More

Orchestras compared

In February, the Post-Gazette visited the Cleveland and Philadelphia orchestras to get an idea of how the sounds of these renowned ensembles compare to our hometown band, and to see what these institutions have to offer that Pittsburgh should take note of for future seasons.

The Cleveland Orchestra

A recent concert in Cleveland featured the ensemble performing music by Beethoven and Elgar’s Symphony No. 2 in Severance Hall. Guest conductor Nikolaj Znaider led the concert, with pianist Yefim Bronfman open the evening with Beethoven’s Piano Concerto No. 5 (“Emperor”).

Advertise with us
How Cleveland is drawing younger audiences

The Cleveland Orchestra is seeing record numbers of young people at their concert. In 2010 the orchestra received a $20 million endowment gift to start the Center for Future Audiences, a program intended to cultivate a younger audience.

According to the orchestra, more than 220,000 young people have participated in the program’s activities to date, and more young people than ever are attending Cleveland Orchestra concerts at Severance Hall. An incredible 20 percent of the orchestra’s classical concert audience is under age 25. Before the program began, that number was about 8 percent.

“One of the great debates in the orchestra world is whether to program specifically for younger people,” said Ross Binnie, chief brand offer of The Cleveland Orchestra. “Our experience is no, you need to keep plowing ahead with what you do best. I believe that you want to give the students the best seats available. The integration and the energy is incredible, and that has a profound impact on the energy of the room.”

The Center comprises various ticket programs to offer admission to young people at a reduced rate for classical and summer programs. There also is a Student Ambassadors Program and The Circle, a monthly membership model for young professionals that includes subsidized ticket prices, behind-the-scenes access and more. There are 285 members signed up.

The Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra is set to launch its own young professionals club next season, which will likely be most comparable to The Circle in Cleveland.

Coincidentally (or not, as it makes rather good sense for a soloist to hit both Pittsburgh and Cleveland on tour given their geographic proximity), Mr. Bronfman had performed Beethoven’s Piano Concerto No. 3 with the PSO the previous week.

Where soloist and orchestra gave a staidly polished performance in Cleveland, the pianist’s Pittsburgh appearance featured a more aggressive approach.

Mr. Bronfman and the Cleveland Orchestra suffused Severance with grace and a lithe, pale sound, at once elastic and absolutely precise. Cleveland’s Beethoven felt just a touch stuffy, while Pittsburgh’s Beethoven might have been a bit forceful at times.

Pitch for pitch, The Cleveland Orchestra might be unmatched for its refinement of technique, and that’s no slight on the orchestra’s tonal variety energy. Elgar’s Symphony No. 2 is complex, layered to the nth degree, but Cleveland’s players delivered such a smooth-edged performance, the work came off more as an intrepid adventure than the heavy slog that some recordings depict.

The Philadelphia Orchestra

Advertise with us

Violin superstar Joshua Bell joined the Philadelphia Orchestra and conductor Yannick Nezet-Seguin in mid-February to play Wieniawki’s Violin Concerto No. 2 in D minor. The first two movements were mesmerizing, with florid, lyrical lines throughout, but in the third Mr. Bell took such a breakneck tempo that the orchestra struggled to keep up. Mr. Bell will next join the Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra in June 2019.

The meat and potatoes of the program came after intermission: Shostakovich’s Symphony No. 7 in C Major, (“Leningrad”). Here the orchestra displayed an incredible range of dynamics, flexing the acoustics of Verizon Hall in the Kimmel Center with the extreme louds and softs inherent to Shostakovich’s music.

The LiveNote experience in Philly

There’s a wave of tech set to enter the concert hall next season including, among other innovations, real-time program note apps.

At a recent Philadelphia Orchestra concert, listeners downloaded an app called LiveNote to their smartphones and watched as curated content played across their screens during the performance. The content includes text and images, blurbs about the history or formal structure of the music, and is intended to help listeners connect with the music on an emotional level by understanding its historical context and theoretical underpinnings.

The app’s developers were highly conscious of the app’s potential to be disruptive or distracting; the software uses negative text (light text on a dark background) to minimize brightness, and the content only changes a few times per movement so as not to detract from the music onstage.

A new version of the software, LiveNote2.0, will roll out later this spring and will be available for any orchestra to use starting next season. Stay tuned — you could see LiveNote in a Heinz Hall concert. Other entities developing real-time concert apps are the Boston Symphony Orchestra and Octava LLC.

From my vantage on the orchestra floor, Verizon Hall didn’t have much ring to it — the orchestra’s sound was quite dry, and winds, brass and strings didn’t quite achieve the same svelte blend of their Cleveland counterparts. This made for a brawnier sound and allowed for a greater range of color than more reverb might have. Brass attacks were a bit softer than you’d hear in Heinz Hall, and the lushness of the strings was dark and inviting.

Philadelphia’s concert began with an announcement about new technology in the concert hall, another in a string of attempts to use apps or video projections to help connect listeners to the music at hand.

Regional accents

Advertise with us

At the level that these orchestras — or any of America’s top ensembles — perform, comparison isn’t about “better” or “worse” so much as “consistency” and a subjective assessment of an orchestra’s sound.

Whether or not an orchestra should have these sorts of distinctive, regional accents to their timbres is a bit of a moot question. They exist. These subtle shadings make listening all the more exciting. There’s a distinctive pleasure that comes from noticing and acknowledging particulars and peculiarities of style that are intrinsic to each orchestra.

Pittsburgh is an underdog in terms of numbers, with a smaller budget, fewer classical concerts, a smaller recording output and smaller base salaries. But it’s the oldest orchestra of the three, and in terms of sound, holds its own quite capably, as evidenced by last year’s European tour, this year’s Grammy win for best orchestral performance and music director Manfred Honeck’s Artist of the Year award from the International Classical Music Awards.

Cleveland’s Beethoven isn’t the same as Pittsburgh’s Beethoven. Obviously. Thank goodness. The PSO has a bit more unbridled a sound than either of the other two orchestras in question; it’s a touch rougher, and while that sometimes causes small ensemble issues (the brass have been a touch loud lately, and string articulation isn’t always crystal clear), the extra “oomph” often breeds an extra dynamism that electrifies performances.

Which is the best orchestra in the country? You can consider institutional issues like creativity in programming, community collaborations, innovations in tech, recordings and awards, but ultimately, when it comes down to an orchestra’s playing, its sound, that’s up to the individual listener.

Advertise with us

After all, they’re all pretty good.

To hear the difference between The Philadelphia Orchestra and the Pittsburgh Symphony Orchestra, listen to their recent recordings of Strauss’s Suite from Der Rosenkavalier below. (The Cleveland Orchestra does not have a recent recording of this particular piece available.)

Jeremy Reynolds: jreynolds@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1634; twitter: @Reynolds_PG. Mr. Reynolds' work at the Post-Gazette is supported in part by a grant from the San Francisco Conservatory of Music, the Getty Foundation, and the Rubin Institute.