At one point during the Tuesday evening session, Dave Wheeler, who has toured far and wide as the frontman for the acclaimed Pittsburgh bands Carousel Outside/Inside, put it out there bluntly.

“It’s not an amazing scene,” he said. “It’s just fine. It’s totally all right. Pittsburgh has a totally all right music scene.”

The platform for trying to make it better was a public Town Hall Meeting of the Pittsburgh Music Ecosystem Project at the Kelly Strayhorn Theater, presented by WYEP (91.3 FM), the City of Pittsburgh and the Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership. The meeting was another stage of this project, launched in the fall to develop ways to improve the Pittsburgh music scene, spurred by a Visit Pittsburgh survey that found it to be rated lower than other aspects of the Pittsburgh tourist experience.

When the study was released, WYEP, with a grant from the Heinz Endowments, commissioned Don Pitts, a consultant from the bustling Austin, Texas, scene to draw up a report on ways to enhance the Pittsburgh music infrastructure. That report is expected in June, according to WYEP general manager Abby Goldstein who moderated the Town Hall.

Advertise with us

It began pleasantly Tuesday with the panel on stage asked to about “the positives” of the Pittsburgh scene: They talked about the DIY spirit, the wealth and diversity of talent, the importance of building relationships and the successes of homegrown stars like Wiz Khalifa and Mac Miller.

And then we got to “the negatives,” and what commenced was a full-on gripe session, from the panel but more from the fully engaged crowd at the KST.

There were complaints about club-goers not wanting to pay covers, promoters not paying artists enough, a lack of “big wigs” here to make an impact, a lack of respect for hip-hop. The Steelers, Pirates and Penguins getting all the attention. The city not doing enough to recognize its talent, and a lack of local music coverage from the mainstream media including WDVE and the Post-Gazette. Even those beautiful bridges, that divide us, took some of the blame.

Mr. Pitts, who was observing in the crowd, became a target himself from a few angry crowd members demanding that, because he’s being paid “a gazillion dollars” — he’s actually getting a portion of the $30,000 grant — he should chime in right there with what he plans to do.

Clearly, he’s still a long way from those kinds of conclusions. When he tried to speak, saying this was part of the process, he was rudely shouted down. Rusted Root’s Liz Berlin, a member of the panel, jumped in, as she did a few times, to calm tempers.

Advertise with us

In the discussion of what can be done to improve the scene, panelist and drummer Charles “Poogie” Bell (Erykah Badu, David Bowie, Marcus Miller), put some of the burden on the fans.

“I think the psychology of the people here is spoiled,” he said. “They think they should be able to see great musicians and it should be free. There’s no sense of value behind what it is. … People don’t have a problem paying $17 or whatever it is to go see ‘Black Panther,’ but your band’s playing at a club and you ask them for five dollars and they go, ‘Five dollars!’ ”

As part of the discussion of why bands can’t get plum gigs with big money, Ben Penigar, of promoter Grey Area Productions, who was in the audience, offered a reality check

“As you grow your craft, you grow a fanbase, and as you grow a fanbase, you sell tickets,” he said. “That’s the measurable, quantitative analysis of how much can I pay a band. It’s how many tickets they can sell. I’m not trying to be mean. I’m just being honest. I can’t pay a band if no one’s going to come out. I have real bills to pay, so if you can sell tickets, I can pay you, if you can sell more tickets, I can pay you more.”

There was much debate of whether there needs to be a centralized site for people to find out what is happening in the music scene, but no consensus on whether that has value or who would do it. One attendee said the Post-Gazette is too busy telling people where The Clarks are playing and what bands eat on the road.

Advertise with us

It was noted that the scene lacks networking events for musicians, an idea Wheeler quickly dismissed: “There are networking events for musicians: They’re called shows,” he said, drawing one of the evening’s few rounds of laughter.

The abundance of local music festivals in Pittsburgh is generally regarded as a positive for the scene, but Wheeler tossed in some healthy skepticism. He praised the more curated festivals like Descendants of Crom, VIA, Pittonkatonk and Skullfest, but said of the neighborhood crawls, “You talk about Millvale Festival, Deutschtown, I don’t think those help the city. If you’re interested in creating the biggest business day of the year for business on the North Side, then that’s a success. .. In terms of stimulating creativity and creating truly great music? No! It’s 200 local bands. How many of them are going to be great? You draw people from the suburbs for one day a year and I don’t think that helps.”

The next phase of the process is a Pittsburgh Music Ecosystem survey asking for input on the scene. It can be filled out quietly, and peacefully, at home.

Scott Mervis: smervis@post-gazette.com