“Anthony Bourdain’s Parts Unknown” wasn’t the only thing that stirred emotions in Pittsburgh last month.
The last week of October was an eventful one for the Pittsburgh music scene, sparked by the closing of the beloved Bloomfield Bridge Tavern, the announced closure of James Street Gastropub and Speakeasy on the North Side, and news of Music Ecosystem Project designed to build a more vibrant scene here.
The latter is an initiative launched by WYEP-FM, the city of Pittsburgh and the Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership that includes a $30,000 Heinz Endowments grant to WYEP to, in part, commission Don Pitts, a consultant from Austin, Texas, to explore ways to enhance the city’s music scene. Part of that emphasis will be on how to better showcase Pittsburgh’s talent to people visiting the city from out of town.
If nothing else, it’s gotten people talking (a Facebook thread on the original PG story is up to 600 comments) in advance of Mr. Pitts arriving in Pittsburgh Friday for a week-long stay to meet with representatives of city government and the entertainment industry.
Some of the reactions and developments of the past two weeks:
-- Radio support has become a big topic of the debate. And, already, things are happening. Longtime indie/experimental presenter Manny Theiner (Garfield Artworks, Sonic Temple, Millvale Industrial Theater, etc.), an outspoken critic of WYEP, had a two-hour meeting this week with the station’s general manager, Abby Goldstein, to propose programming additions to the independent station that would include two-hour blocks for such genres as Ambient/Space Music, Goth/Industrial, Reggae/Ska, Avant-Garde Jazz/Free-Improv, Punk/Hardcore or Metal, along with shows for ethnic music such as Brazilian, African and Jewish. There’s no telling where it will lead, but Ms. Goldstein is receptive to the feedback.
-- Kevin Saftner, owner of James Street Gastropub and Speakeasy (which is closing over his frustration with noise complaints), has stated that he is compiling a directory of Pittsburgh music industry professionals that he plans to release soon.
-- WYEP’s Goldstein and Russell Howard, of the Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership, have been active on Facebook, clarifying what Mr. Pitts’ mission will be here. A lot of it has to do with reviewing zoning for live music and local ordinances that address sound complaint issues. Goldstein posted, “Don is coming in to access the regulatory environment in the city and offer some recommendation on systemic change that might make things easier for musicians, venues and businesses. That's all. Second, this is not about the music scene itself, this is about the processes and mechanisms that allow the scene to thrive or not.”
-- Fair Play Pittsburgh, a “musician-led initiative to bring all aspects of the community together has promoted,” has received more attention for a previously scheduled meeting set for 6 p.m. Monday at Belvedere’s in Lawrenceville. Among the speakers will be Cody Walters, co-founder of Deutschtown Music Festival. It will be followed by what is sure to be a lively panel discussion.
-- Sean Styles, who plays in the local cover band Walk of Shame, has provoked lots of discussion -- and quite a lot of heat -- for an Oct. 23rd blog provocatively titled “WHY MUSIC IN PITTSBURGH IS DEAD.” In it, he declares, “The music scene as you know it is gone, and it is not coming back.” He goes on to say that musicians have to cater more to audiences: “To me, music is first and foremost, a business. It’s a business to the venues that book me because they know that I will play popular songs that caters to their demographic to drive bar sales and make them more money. I’m not there to perform good music – I am there to sell booze. I am there to help their business make money.”
— Cleveland has been a big topic, with a lot of discussion not only of bands there getting more support but fans here of edgier music having to travel to Cleveland for shows.
-- On Thursday, I received a Facebook message from a music industry insider who wrote, “The difference between Pittsburgh and other cities is very rarely do any of the bands treat their band as a business. It's the music business. They don't want to do anything but post on Facebook or Twitter and think that’s all the promotion they need to promote their band. Take a band like Rusted Root, to make it, they got their music out there, they got people to shows. Then it expanded to other cities. It was a groundswell. All before the internet was huge. I don't see that anymore. That's the difference. I find very few bands actually treating their bands like a business. Back in the ‘90s when 18,000 people came to a local band festival at Star Lake, it's because it was actually a scene. I don't see a music scene here at all anymore. Very few local bands can consistently sell out 300 cap clubs, let alone 600 or 1,000 cap clubs. These are just my thoughts. Maybe I'm wrong. But I read some of the things people say. Blame WYEP. Blame commercial radio. Blame this person, blame that person. Like everything in life, you gotta do it yourself because no one owes your band anything. If you have a good product that is sellable, you gotta be able to want radio and record companies to come to you. Right now. Most record companies aren't looking at you if you don't have the numbers. The Facebook likes. The people at your shows, etc.”
Was it something Rusted Root did, business wise? Or did it just have the right sound, look and vibe at the right time? Same for Wiz Khalifa and Mac Miller. That’s certainly a topic for further discussion.
Mr. Pitt’s recommendations will arrive in the spring. Until then, the conversation is sure to continue.
Scott Mervis: smervis@post-gazette.com.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.