The Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership, the City of Pittsburgh and WYEP announced on Tuesday that it was looking to Austin, Texas, for a few music tips.

Through a Heinz Endowments grant, WYEP, working in collaboration with the City and PDP, contracted Don Pitts, of Sound Music Cities and the former head of the City of Austin's Economic Development Department’s Music & Entertainment Division, to visit Pittsburgh Nov. 3-9, hold town meetings and offer his assessment on how the city’s nightlife and music scene can be enhanced.

The catalyst for the Music Ecosystem Project was a VisitPittsburgh survey in which music and nightlife did not rate as highly for Pittsburgh visitors as other aspects of their experience here. The Austin connection stems in part from a Responsible Hospitality Institute conference, attended earlier this year by a group of Pittsburghers representing city government, community development organizations, media, cultural and tourism organizations.

Since news of the consultant broke on Tuesday, there have been a lot of questions on social media about why we need a consultant and what he might be looking for. On Wednesday, we talked to Russell Howard, the PDP’s vice president of special events and development, who has a long history in the Pittsburgh music scene, having worked in the ’80s nightclubs Graffiti and the Pyramid.

Advertise with us

In March, you announced that PDP was launching a New Music initiative to offer more music in the city. What happened between then and now that we need a consultant?

Well, they’re two different things. The PDP is in Downtown music, and there is the consultancy, which is the collaboration. They're intertwined but they’re distinct. The Downtown Music Initiative, we’re trying to cultivate additional music venues Downtown. After our annual meeting with the panel there were a few venues that started to do music, like Revel + Roost. We have programmed, between now and then, probably a hundred acts Downtown. We’re talking to developers, talking to different groups coming into Downtown about developing music venues. We’ve been working on publicizing what’s happening. As we talk to restaurants and developers about adding music Downtown, we came up against some of the same hurdles that the music industry faces in Pittsburgh. The VisitPittsburgh survey just helped underline the fact that there was a gap here. The music scene in Pittsburgh, it thrives, but it thrives despite the lack of support and systems that other cities have in place to support them.

So, what can we learn from Austin?

One of the things we saw when we went there for the conference is that Austin succeeds because there is an entire system of support. Clearly, music there is more of a central aspect of the local economy, but what was clear is that the musicians have support, in terms of wages, of business, of marketing -- all the professional skills that some artists have better than others. Also, they support the venues. One of the examples is that when someone is putting up a residential building in close proximity to an existing music venue, the developer is responsible for sound-proofing their development and the people moving in have to acknowledge that they’re moving in next to a music venue.

How widespread a problem is that in Pittsburgh? Obviously, it was an issue for James Street [Gastropub and Speakeasy], which just announced it was closing.

Advertise with us

That’s just one thin slice. When you talk to folks who have liquor licenses who know that if they have amplified sound, their license is at risk if their sound can be heard from the curb, that’s a consideration. There are taxes that come into play when it comes to entertainment. There are all kinds of costs attached to that. And right now, there’s no system, there’s no permitting process for entertainment, no systems for reconciling issues, so it became apparent there was a need here. You talk to people like the FairPlay Music folks and musicians always say “We don’t get paid enough,” or “They want us to promote the venue -- we have a pay to play situation.” What it boils down to is that music is a business and it needs to be economically viable for the artist to make a living. The venues have to thrive in order for the artists to thrive. Then the neighborhoods can thrive off of that. Right now, there’s just not the infrastructure or systems in place.

So, what can this guy from Austin do?

He has a huge track record dealing with reconciling various constituencies. Under his watch, I know, complaints in Austin dropped over 70 percent. He also was in artist relations at Gibson Guitars. He understands what musicians want and need, what venues want and need, he understands city process and technology. He’s familiar with other cities aside from Austin. He can look and say, “Here are some options, here are ways to deal with it.”

How did WYEP get into the picture?

PDP, obviously, is focused on Downtown. What we needed was a musical entity that was, one, willing to step up, but was also not geographically focused. When we looked at who went to this music conference, most had a regional, neighborhood focus. It wouldn’t make sense for any one neighborhood group to be the central conduit, whereas YEP, with a focus on independent music, whether or not you agree with their aesthetic filter, they have that larger, umbrella role.

Advertise with us

Do you have any kind of personal vision of what you’d like to see?

Now, I’m talking personally, not on behalf of PDP or the collaboration. One thing I love about places like Nashville or Austin or New Orleans is you can sort of walk around and there is a music wafting from here and there. Pittsburgh, Downtown, because of its walkability, I would love it to be a place where people could come and explore music. One of the other sort of challenges is that Pittsburgh does not necessarily have a culture of people of consuming music just to explore it. There’s not a culture where people just go check out music. It’s usually something they’ve heard about, that they are familiar with, something that’s comfortable and not necessarily easily accessible in a collective area. I would love to see Downtown have a range of music and venues. Sometimes, when I talk to restaurants and they say, “Oh, we really don't have the space for that,” I hold up the Park House [on the North Side] as an example. There couldn't be a place less suited for music than Park House, but what they do, it works. There’s no reason that can’t be happening Downtown. Not everything has to be a built-out venue, though we are talking to developers about doing that.

Is there any funding possible for that?

There's the potential for funding, certainly. It’s something I would like to see happening. Right now, that’s not in the stream. That’s why we’re bringing Don in to assess everything. We’re looking for participation. We’re going to have those town hall meetings. We’re really looking for input. The four categories we’re looking to are artists, community, venues and the local music industry.

Do you have any sense of what these convention/tourist people want? Was there any specific feedback?

Advertise with us

No. I’m sorry so much attention is being paid to that. Nightlife did not get a bad score. Everything else was just glowingly positive. Music was noticeably less so. And it’s not surprising, because there is a need for it. As we’re looking at music as an economic business, the fact that we’ve got visitors coming in here is another reason why Downtown has a different type of potential than some of the other neighborhoods. We can supply music for tourists. Pittsburgh has always been a place where the action has been off in the neighborhoods, and that that is near and dear to my heart, but I remember when Downtown used to have three or four jazz bars. Obviously, that’s changed.

Do have any sense of the demographic of these visitors?

No, I’m, sure it’s not a one-size fits all. What do the Furries want to see versus the petroleum engineers. Probably, what would be here would have to be accessible to be successful. Music is a marketplace business. What do people show up for and show up to see? Some of that happens over time. There’s a Darwinistic aspect to any commercial activity like that.