Last week, just as we were paying final respects to the Bloomfield Bridge Tavern, the owners of James Street Speakeasy and Gastropub dropped the bombshell that the bustling North Side venue only had a few weeks left.
The BBT, a fixture on Liberty Avenue since 1985, closed its doors with a final show on Saturday, due to rising insurance costs. James Street is falling victim to persistent noise complaints from anonymous neighbors. The owner believes the complaints threaten its liquor license.
To veterans of the music scene, it might feel a bit like 1999-2000, when the Electric Banana and Graffiti closed within a few months. Or perhaps the period between 1995 and ’97 when the Decade and The Balcony closed. Or, more recently when the Shadow Lounge, Garfield Artworks and Modern Formations closed within a year or two, followed by the 31st Street Pub.
Like The Balcony, James Street was an upscale venue catering to the jazz scene, while also bringing other roots music like rock, blues and funk. The BBT, a neighborhood spot with deep roots in the indie-rock scene, was always up for just about anything, from “punk to polka,” as they liked to say.
The Pittsburgh club scene has a way of regenerating quickly, though, and it’s never all just bad news. The Funhouse at Mr. Smalls in Millvale, upstairs from the main room, opened last year as an intimate new room for local and national music. Spirit Hall and Cattivo in Lawrenceville are solidly booking two floors of music, and the Thunderbird Cafe also in Lawrenceville, is expected to open bigger and better after renovations in the spring.
The rock scene also has Gooski’s in Polish Hill; Howler’s and the Brillobox in Bloomfield; the Rex, Smiling Moose and Club Cafe on the South Side; the Hard Rock Cafe at Station Square and Jergel’s in Marshall, among other venues. The blues scene, mostly centered at Moondog’s and Excuses, has gotten thinner over the years, and in a city once teeming with jazz clubs, James Street is a big loss. There isn’t much for jazz lovers in the city limits outside of the Fairmont and NOLA on the Square, Downtown, and the North Side’s Alphabet City.
Read More
What is the impact for musicians trying to find places to play?
“I had six gigs at James Street this year. I doubt that I’ll find another venue to replace them,” said R&B legend Billy Price. “It’s true that great places always have come and gone — Decade, Graffiti, Mancini’s, Fat City, Evergreen — and something always emerges to take their place. But for some reason James Street really hurts. After the renovations, the performance space in the ballroom had become my favorite place to play.”
“I think it really affects certain scenes for sure,” said Justin Pitkavish, aka Lazy JP of jazzy hip-hop duo BBGuns (formerly LAZYBLACKMAN). “James Street was like the headquarters for blues, funk, jazz, etc., around here.”
“It feels like booking for a local band regressed a few steps in a short amount of time ... back to the pre-2010 days,” said Andrew Belsick, of LoFi Delphi. “And both of these venues were easy to work with from an artist’s perspective. This will leave more people flocking to Howlers and the Smalls Funhouse. Until the T-bird complex opens back up, it’s going to be tough.”
“It’s bad for the entire industry,” said jazz cabaret singer Phat Man Dee, who played both venues. “It’s not just about a place to play.... it’s about an entire socio-economic blow to the creative class and the people who work in the nighttime arts industry.
“It’s going be a lot harder to find a place to play and it’s going to be harder for anyone to want to risk their entire life savings and life’s work knowing a lawsuit or anonymous complaint can shut you down. It’s sad that these places with history and legacy are just going. ... and it’s not going to be easy to replace them.”
Most musicians agree that the quality issue is a big one, as both owners — Steve Frankowski at the BBT and Kevin Saftner at James Street — were very musician-friendly. Furthermore, James Street, which was temporarily shut down during the Deutschtown Music Festival in July 2016 because of the noise complaints, had just invested in soundproofing along with the beautiful renovations to the ballroom.
Jazz pianist Max Leake says James Street was first-rate in terms of sound, lighting and size. “It is not the usual, move a few tables for the band to squeeze into. It was a great venue for doing special theme shows. We did a Chick Corea tribute night about a month ago. I am not so sure that would have worked without a venue like James Street.”
“James Street was a welcome addition to venues that are jam band-friendly, and theCAUSE was looking forward to doing shows there in 2018,” said the band’s bassist-singer, David Tauberg. “We try to only do shows at places that have a stage, charge a cover, and that are nonsmoking and have good craft beer at a reasonable price. They also had a great staff, sound and management.”
Music isn’t dead in Bloomfield, as it still has Howler’s and Brillobox, and the North Side has Park House. Oakland, the core of student life and once the hub of the rock scene, is practically a musical wasteland these days. Same goes for Shadyside.
“I think the loss of venues in Oakland is, long term, the worst part for the rock scene,” said bassist Jesse Prentiss, who books local bands at the Funhouse. “College kids forming their first bands and getting into WRCT and WPTS as bands and DJs was, to me, a critical factor in the next generation of Pittsburgh bands hitting the other clubs and eventually becoming touring acts. But it’s also significant because those college kids’ nonmusical friends get into the scene that way.”
“I definitely think the lack of an Oakland venue has contributed to a relatively lower amount of new-generation show attendees across a variety of genres,” said David Bernabo of indie band Host Skull.
Steve Sciulli, who was part of the closing of the BBT with his band Ploughman’s Lunch, has always been of that DIY, never-say-die spirit where you find places to play, whether it’s an art gallery or a warehouse.
“I’ve been playing shows long enough that when we started there were no bars that would take a chance on our music. We had to create events and venues where none existed before. This helped to create a musical community.”
On the positive side, the Thunderbird Cafe, which closed for renovations in August 2016, will be back next year. The Bridge Music Hall Project, which is run by Rich Dieter and presents music at Wallace’s Whiskey Room at East Liberty’s Hotel Indigo, has been looking for a 150-capacity cabaret-style space where the concept will be more music, less chatter.
The Winery in the Strip, a cozy basement venue that was forced to cease its music bookings last December because it was not zoned for general assembly, is working out that problem.
“We have partnered with a developer, and we are taking our plans to do what is necessary to meet the zoning requirements to the city at a zoning board hearing scheduled next month,” said owner Tim Gaber. “If all goes well we hope to have something positive to report by the end of the year. In light of the terrible news about James Street, no more BBT, and with the Thunderbird under construction, the city sure could use another good music venue right now.”
Said Phat Man Dee: “This is the time when the city of Pittsburgh needs to decide if we’re a music city ... or not.”
Scott Mervis: smervis@post-gazette.com; 412-263-2576.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.