It wasn’t just a certain sound that Tom Petty shared with his idol, Bob Dylan.

The iconic rocker from Gainesville, Fla., who died Monday at 66 of cardiac arrest, had a similarly elusive side to his personality.

“Tom was a really quiet guy,” says Rich Engler, who promoted many of the Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers shows in Pittsburgh. “Did you ever interview him?”

Nope.

Advertise with us

“That’s why.”

Like Dylan, Mr. Petty preferred to let the songs do the talking, and did he ever have songs. Not many artists could come to town and play a two-hour-plus set that left off about half of his radio classics, but that was the joy and frustration of a Tom Petty concert. Thousands of Pittsburghers now revel in the memory of those shows, where he delivered hit upon hit, forming a soundtrack of their teen years when they blasted songs like “Refugee,” “Here Comes My Girl” and “Breakdown” out of their car windows.

He had just wrapped up the Heartbreakers’ 40th anniversary tour, which played the PPG Paints Arena on June 9. As usual, he didn’t talk a whole lot, but he was in a gregarious mood, telling the fans, “We've certainly made a lot of trips here over those 40 years…Thanks for coming back, it means a lot to us.” He opened that show with “Rockin' Around (With You),” the first song on the band’s 1976 self-titled debut album.

Pittsburgh rocker Joe Grushecky recalls first seeing him at the Agora Theater in Cleveland, opening for Meat Loaf, just after that debut came out.

“We were struck by the overall vibe of the band — very British Invasion-like, with the Vox amps and the way they played. There was an economy to it. They were a song band. There were definitely periods of my life when I listened to him more than anybody.”

Advertise with us

In the ’80s, Mr. Grushecky’s band, the Iron City Houserockers, were on the same label as the Heartbreakers, MCA, but they only met once, backstage at the Civic Arena. Mr. Grushecky mentioned that they were label mates, and he remembers Mr. Petty just saying, “Aw yeah, Nick Lowe spoke highly of you guys.”

Former WDVE morning man Steve Hansen was working in San Francisco when Mr. Petty and the Heartbreakers broke, bringing an honest heartland rock sound back to the airwaves.

“Tom Petty arrived like a cool breeze on a muggy day,” he says. “It was a time when Player and the Little River Band were ascendant. Because of Fleetwood Mac, everyone was trying to write sappy love ballads. Tom Petty was the pre-wave of the New Wave. He wrote stripped-down, guitar-driven, three-minute gems with big, tasty hooks. He sang about sex, not love. His instincts were so right and someone said of Mike Campbell, ‘He plays only the notes you want to hear.’ You almost couldn't pick a bad Tom Petty song on those first couple of albums.”

“I Won’t Back Down” came a little later in the Petty canon, but the uncompromising attitude was there from the start.

“He was told ‘Listen To Her Heart’ would be a smash if he changed the line about ‘cocaine’ to ‘champagne,’ ” Mr. Hansen says. “He wouldn't. He was one of the few people who was making cool American rock before punk blew it all up.”

Advertise with us

Unlike Bruce Springsteen, who has shared stages with local musicians and played all variety of venues here, or John Mellencamp, who has made news here with Farm Aid and that surprise gig in Market Square, Mr. Petty’s trips through Pittsburgh were pretty routine. From his early stop at the Stanley Theater through the Arena, Palumbo and Burgettstown shows, Mr. Petty pulled in with this band, played a great show and left. He was much more prolific as a songwriter than a newsmaker.

“He never did a meet and greet,” Mr. Engler says. “I was only with him one time, of all the shows I did with him. Soft-spoken would be an understatement. He was standoff-ish, but in a shy kind of way, not in an egotistical kind of way.”

It was “Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers,” not “The Heartbreakers,” but it was very much a collective. They played their first arena headlining show here on Aug. 4, 1981, about six years into the band’s run.

Heartbreakers keyboardist Benmont Tench told the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette that month that he formed the Heartbreakers with Mike Campbell, Stan Lynch and Ron Blair, and that Mr. Petty, whom they had played with in Mudcrutch, was the last member to join.

“He was the best singer and the best songwriter, so it was a natural. Plus, he’s the only blond in the band, so … hey.”

Advertise with us

Tom Rooney, who used to manage the Civic Arena, says, “I knew the hiding places you could watch soundcheck unnoticed. Sometime in the early or mid-’80s Tom Petty was playing the Civic Arena, I think with George Thorogood, in the old half house setup. I was curious about Petty because he had radio hits, but what I remember about the soundcheck was how hard he worked the band, stopping them in mid-song and rehearsing over and over again. To become Mr. Coolness, he had to have a hard side.”

Even though Tom Petty didn’t make a lot of tight personal connections in Pittsburgh, his influence on artists here began with that first in the mid ’70s and never stopped, touching multiple generations.

Here’s what Pittsburgh musicians are saying:

Byron Nash, Byron Nash and Plan B: “Clearly he is, one of the top 10 songwriters of the past 30 years. Period. Also people forget that Petty was a huge part of the music video revolution that brought the visual identity of artists to the forefront of the music. Just go through his video catalogue. A true pioneer.”

Philip Harris, Hector in Paris: We used to cover American Girl in one of my first Pittsburgh bands, The Redphones. Just a great songwriter who had an amazing career. He died with his boots on. "There ain't no easy way out."

Advertise with us

Katie Simone, singer-songwriter: “I was 12 or 13 when I started taking voice lessons. I wanted to sing like Ann Wilson and Linda Ronstadt, really impeccable vocalists. But I also started really listening to Tom Petty at that time, and to me, he had the most authentic soulful sound out of any rocker I had ever heard. He may not have had the greatest voice but he sounded ‘real,’ and that's what did it for me. He never compromised who he was, and that was so apparent in his voice and his writing.”

Andre Costello, Andre Costello and the Cool Minors: “As a kid I remember people asking me what music I liked. I would reply, ‘Tom Petty.’ His music was honest, so it hit you right in the heart, and that connected with so many people. The perfect companion to a summertime drive or a broken heart. I used to write his lyrics in my notebook, sitting in the back of class in the boonies.”

Ben Valasek, singer-songwriter: “My first concert...1989...Tom Petty and the Replacements at the Palumbo Center. He made great songs out of simple lyrics and simple chords.”

Mark Dignam, singer-songwriter: “Feels like he's always been around and always would be... if anyone's work served as a musical backdrop to America itself, it was Tom Petty's.”

Josh Verbanets, Meeting of Important People: “The perfect intersection of garage rock, pop, punk, folk. Fun music with words that were hooky and still smart-ish, memorable, emotive, honest. Really thought he would be the guy to keep the classic rock thing going for another decade. Mostly timeless rock ’n’ roll stuff except for some grouchy songs about radio payola or whatever. I'll always remember that clip from 'Behind The Music' where one of the Heartbreakers said matter-of-factly that Tom was the leader, and they all followed him because he was an excellent leader. Which you could tell.”

Advertise with us

Paul Luc, singer-songwriter: “Somehow, time and time again, he was able to come up with simple universal sentiments in his songs. He found ‘obvious’ lines that are only apparent when someone as talented as Tom Petty shows them to you: ‘You don’t know how it feels to be me,’ ‘I won’t back down,’ ‘waiting is the hardest part”, ‘I keep crawling back to you.’ Every human on the planet can relate and retrofit personal stories into his songs. That's what makes him one of the greats. Try and do that just one time and you'll appreciate how difficult it must've been to do that consistently over multiple decades.”

Shari Richards, singer-songwriter: “He was my first concert ever. Peanut heaven at the Civic Arena. Joe Ely was the opening act. When he did "Breakdown" I knew music would be my path in life. This is just too sad :-( RIP Tom Petty”

Steve Acri, concert-goer: “After 50+ years of going to concerts, my personal opinion is that Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers were the best American band for the past 20 years. I'm so said to see that end.”

William J Ainsworth III, singer-songwriter: “I remember falling in love with ‘Mary Jane’s Last Dance’ while riding in a car on my way to be an extra in ‘Diabolique’ and with ‘Refugee’ when it crackled through my alarm lock on The Eagle in my bedroom on Hillsdale Avenue. Great road trip music every time. I think what I love about Petty is his ability to make rock and roll timeless and rootsy without making it sound like he was trying. Such a sincere voice. And kids will buy his records for the next fifty or hundred years.”

Tom Breiding, singer-songwriter: “Tom Petty was the King in my rock-n-roll world. I learned his songs on my first guitar; I performed his songs in my first bands, I wore his T-shirts at my earliest club dates. Among the hundreds of shows I have seen, including six or seven Petty concerts dating back to 1977, my favorite rock-n-roll show was the Pittsburgh stop on the Heartbreakers' Caravan Tour with the Del Fuegos and Georgia Satellites in '87. Two specific things I'll remember him by: He fought to keep ‘Hard Promises’ affordable for his fans and he and the Heartbreakers were Bob Dylan's best back-up band since ‘The Band.’ ”

Advertise with us

John Young, The Optimists: “Tom Petty's music has always just been in the water, so it's easy to take him for granted. If you're in a rock cover band, you play his songs--they're standards. ‘Listen To Her Heart.’ ‘The Waiting.’ ‘I Won't Back Down.’ Classics. But there are so many great deep cuts, too. And the album Wildflowers is an absolute masterpiece. He's a master songwriter working with a deep, sympathetic and talented band -- Mudcrutch, too. What a loss.”

Bill Toms, Bill Toms and Hard Rain: “ ‘Damn The Torpedoes.’ One of three albums that gave me a reason. The other two were ‘London Calling’ and ‘Darkness on the Edge of Town.’ What a two-year period for a young teenage guitar-slammin, want-to-be songwriter. Joe Strummer was tough. This one seems more personal.”

Steve Seel, A.T.S.: “Tom Petty's music hit me at the right time a couple of times. I loved the Heartbreakers as a kid, and I loved his solo records. He showed me you can keep doing his, and you can keep evolving meaningfully. He wrote concise songs, big hooks, and made records that sounded tremendous. He is an important influence on every aspect of my musical life.”

Brad Yoder, singer-songwriter: “His songs are so uncluttered, so emotionally direct, ‘simple’ in a way that seems effortless (though I’m sure he often worked hard to get them there). I’m trying to find the ‘tuning in to God’s Radio’ quote I’ve heard attributed to him. He wrote great songs as if channeling them from a bigger source, with a wry combination of humility and swagger which is uniquely American.”

Shawn McGregor, The Commonheart: “One of the best songwriters ever. Made everything simple, universal, and relatable. Most efficient songwriter that comes to mind. He had an incredible knack for turning a simple line into a sledgehammer.. ‘You don't know how it feels to be me,’ ‘the waiting is the hardest part.’ No one has done more with less. What a loss.”

Advertise with us

Greg Joseph, The Clarks: “Sad day. When your band bio mentions Tom Petty as a major influence for the past 30 years, it hits pretty hard. Stuck finishing a song? What would TP do?”

Jay Wiley, The Hawkeyes: “Tom Petty made it cool to write 3 chord rock n roll songs. He made it cool to be simple, to the point and just be who you are.”

Jon Bindley, Bindley Hardware Co.: “Tom Petty never compromised his authenticity. A brilliant collaborator and a student of songwriting who was constantly evolving. He thumbed his nose at the music business and stayed true to himself and those close to him. The fact that Mudcrutch got back together after all those years and toured says a lot about the kind of guy he was. I've always found comfort in knowing that Tom Petty was out there somewhere doing his thing. There will never be another like him. This hurts.”

Chris Callen, Through These Walls: “As a songwriter, the one thing that stuck with me about Tom Petty was ability to grab a listener with his storytelling ability, melodies, harmonies, and chord structures were secondary pieces to his writing style. He took a listener through an audible story where you can't help but picture the lyrics playing out as a video. He was a master at that. And a career with that much longevity is a proving point that people connect with strong storytelling lyrics instead of hooks.”

Billy Evanochko, Billy the Kid and the Regulators: “Tom Petty and the heartbreakers are a big part of the soundtrack of my life from the time of my childhood. Mike Campbell’s sexy guitar tone and stinging licks paired with Petty’s lyrical storytelling is what rock n roll is all about.”

Advertise with us

Dave Gasbarro, Fungus: “Like all great rockers he was baptized in fire and molded into greatness. He is an American icon that will be forever remembered.”

Jenn Wertz, former Rusted Root: “After I learned my first basic guitar chords, I wanted to learn ‘The Waiting’ learned it and I thought it was a perfect song. Tom Petty was masterful at that songcraft. So many hooks in every song that ride that line perfectly between rock-n-roll-catchy and emotionally moving. ‘The Waiting’ is still one of my favorite songs. To hear him play it alone, acoustically- that song craft is so evident.”

Terrence Michael, Dirty Faces: “Dirty Faces played ‘Refugee’ I believe twice, and I've been bummed we didn't record it for the decade-plus since. Now I'm bummed because I'll never see TP play live. The other night we were talking about Traveling Wilburys and I made the statement (something like) ‘When the LEAST LEGENDARY member of your band is Tom Petty, then your band is filled with legends."

Chuck Olson, singer-songwriter: “Matter of Fact songs based on the everyday American Experience. Never afraid of life but always rolling through the challenges, like a surfer. Beautiful, Authentic songs on how we live here.”

Mandy L Kivowitz-Delfaver, jazz cabaret singer: “Once when I was still doing shows at the Lava Lounge on Southside, so sometime between 1998 and 2002, he was in town for a performance at Star Lake Amphitheater. No I did not meet him, he did not come to my show. However somebody told his crew to come, so some of his side men, and many of his support staff like his personal chef and helpers and roadies did come to my show! And I have to say I have met a lot of people who have worked for a lot of rock stars in my career, and I have never met a group of people who loved their boss so much. I cannot remember what I said to offend one of them, but I was still drinking during my shows back then and I could've said something without meaning to, also I was much younger, and whatever I said, those people made it clear to me very quickly that nobody was going to slag Tom Petty, at least not in front of them! And it was at that moment that I vowed to myself that I would be the kind of musician who worked to deserve the love of the people who worked for me. I wanted to be the kind of person his employees knew him to be. Also his music kicked ass!”

Advertise with us

Scott Mervis: smervis@post-gazette.com

CORRECTION: A previous version of this article identified Phil Harris as a member of Hector in Pittsburgh. The band’s name is actually Hector in Paris.