The internet can be such a swamp of negativity. Sometimes, it almost seems like that’s why it was invented.
What we don’t often see is the target of the negativity actually highlighting it on their social media page, but that’s what the Thrival Music Festival decided to do last month to address criticisms of the 2016 festival. Last year’s fest, the first at the Carrie Furnace in Swissvale, had a tough opening day with a shortage of water, an annoying token system, long lines for food and drinks, a variety of parking/transportation issues and, according to fans, “too many old people.”
Some of the issues were remedied the second day — not the old people — and more will be ironed out, according to Thrival director Dan Law, when Thrival opens the sixth annual festival back at the Carrie Furnace on Friday.
“What we’ve done this year are pretty substantial improvements,” he says, starting with “two large free water stations on the site from doors until close, so people aren’t required to wait in line or buy tokens or any other transactions just to get water.”
Parking there will always be a challenge, given its size, but it didn’t help last year, he says, that 3,000 people bought tickets the day of the show and did not read the social media posts and other correspondence about getting there. This year, parking passes were sold in advance and more free shuttles have been added for people parking at the Waterfront.
Thrival, presented by the East Liberty-based incubator/accelerator Ascender (formerly Thrill Mill), has been growing steadily since launching at Bakery Square five years ago with De La Soul and sitting tight for year two with Moby and Portugal.The Man. In 2015, it moved to the more expansive former LTV Coke Works site in Hazelwood with Panic! at the Disco, Manchester Orchestra and Wale, and last year, it migrated again to the Carrie Furnace, where it drew 16,000 over two days for Chainsmokers and Thievery Corporation.
This year, for the first time, Thrival has partnered with concert giant Live Nation, for a few reasons. For starters, Ascender is an innovation company with five full-time staffers, not a concert promoter, so it has a different focus throughout the year, and part of that is the two days of innovation programming that precede the concert. One of those programs has Saturday’s headliner Wiz Khalifa as part of a panel called “High Road” at Carnegie Museum of Art on Thursday.
Beyond that, he says, “As a small nonprofit, you have to ask yourself a stark question: Can you continue to put up so much financial risk and exposure with the hope that it will come back with a set number of tickets?”
In other words, a Thrival bust would be devastating to Ascender, while Live Nation absorbs that kind of risk every day.
Finally, there are the logistics of putting on a concert in an undeveloped site like the Carrie Furnace.
“It’s not unlike building a city for two days and making a city operate smoothly and efficiently. Live Nation knows how to do that,” Mr. Law says. “They know how to build cities and make them function properly. Their track record goes to Austin City Limits, Bonnaroo, Lollapalooza, Governor’s Ball — they bring a pretty substantial degree of core competencies to Thrival.”
This will be the first Thrival with two headliners from the hip-hop realm. Topping the Friday bill is LA-based rapper Logic, who hit No. 1 on the album charts in May with its third album, “Everybody,” complete with the singles “Everybody,” "Black Spiderman” and “1-800-273-8255.” He’s joined by rapper/DJ Carnage, indie-rockers Two Door Cinema and Circa Waves and producer/DJ Tokimonsta.
Pittsburgh’s own Wiz Khalifa headlines Saturday, playing his one hometown show of 2017, on a bill that also includes DJ/producer GRIZ, electropop singer-songwriter Kiiara and rapper Kyle.
On that shift toward rap and EDM, Mr. Law says, “If we’re talking about new ideas and pushing boundaries, why would we have the same type of music year in and year out? It just doesn’t mesh philosophically or logically. We’re always trying to change genres and dynamics and the types of music people are listening to.”
This summer, Mr. Law wrote a blog post about how the saturated market for festivals is causing some to fail, citing Pemberton, Mysteryland and Karoondinha (near State College) as recent examples. The latter was canceled for lack of ticket sales, despite offering a bill with Chance the Rapper, John Legend and the Roots.
“My theory is that it’s not about the lineup,” he says, “because every single year someone or a [group] of individuals is going to be so incensed that you booked a certain artist or type of music that they will immediately go to social media and vent their frustration with you. It’s not about the lineup — it’s about community and culture. It’s about, ‘Can Pittsburgh sustain a festival?’ Karoondinha was absolutely stacked, top to bottom. They spent millions on the music. The festival did not even open its doors. It canceled weeks before it was supposed to happen, and it has met a similar fate to a lot of festivals, most notably the hot dumpster fire that was Fyre Festival.
“There’s over 10,000 music festivals to choose from in America,” he says, “and dozens of the highest profile ones are shutting down because there is a bubble that is unmistakable and you can’t fight that bubble by booking better artists.”
How do you fight the bubble? With a sense of community and a sense of purpose, he says, like Thrival being a symbol of Pittsburgh in the midst of a tech revolution.
“We started off trying to effectively tell a good story about Pittsburgh. We wanted to first celebrate new ideas, creativity and innovation in the city, and we wanted people to have fun. We used music for the fun component, for the community-building component. Not only do we want to build a live event, we want to do it in a space that’s unorthodox, that gets people thinking differently about their environment, that gets people thinking about creative reuse or looking at abandoned steel mills or retired blast furnaces not as blight on the landscape but potential assets to the community.
“In 2017,” adds, “we’re talking about Pittsburgh being a hub for the artificial intelligence revolution and people are taking driverless cars to work and we’re being considered for the next headquarters for Amazon. And if we’re not effectively telling that story, there’s no way we can progress as a region. If we don’t share that narrative, we go back to the conservative, risk-averse mentality that doesn’t get anybody anywhere. Thrival makes a pretty strong declaration, which is: Pittsburgh isn’t on the comeback. Pittsburgh is back and it’s time for us to take a leadership position.”
Scott Mervis: smervis@post-gazette.com; Twitter: @scottmervis_pg




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.