It’s been just a few months since Joe Fishel completed his first feature film, “The Haunting of Prince Dom Pedro,” but he is already back on set.
Fishel is working on his next project “I Swiped the Wrong One,” a modern age rom-com in which the characters search for love on a dating app. The movie is set in Pittsburgh and utilizes familiar locations, including Carnegie Coffee Company, COhatch Shadyside and Mellon Institute in Oakland. Fishel is the writer, producer and also has a role as a congressman.
The feature joins a long list of productions currently filming in the area, including the Amazon MGM Production “How to Rob a Bank” and an unnamed Apple TV+ thriller series based on the “Killer Instinct” books by Lars Kepler. Filming recently wrapped on the Milton and Kitty Hershey biopic “Hershey” as well. But as a smaller and more local production, “I Swiped the Wrong One” proves that Pittsburgh’s independent film community is also thriving.
The feature — which follows the online dating experiences of two men and two women — was originally a short film that was shown in Fishel’s previous feature: “The Haunting of Prince Dom Pedro,” a modern-day fairy tale about a group of Latin American history students. Like that film, “I Swiped the Wrong One” features a cast and crew of nearly all Pittsburghers.
One of those members is 37-year-old Laura Irene Young of Carnegie, who both directs the film and plays a main character’s ex-wife.
In 2022, Young lost her “dream job,” and in the weeks that followed, she found herself asking what came next.
Read More
“What is the dream? What is the relationship I want? Where do I want to live? I don’t even know anymore because I lost this thing I was working so hard for,” she recalled thinking at the time.
Now she’s glad she lost the job because it gave her the opportunity to grow. As the director, she’s infusing her experiences into the the production to bring its characters and their online dating situations to life.
Young’s story is similar to that of main character Amanda. She loses a career in Washington D.C. after the congressman she worked for (played by Fishel) is involved in a politically self-destructive scandal. While recovering from the loss and collecting herself, Amanda’s parents convince her to try a dating app. Then, “hilarity ensues,” according to Rachel Pfennigwerth, who portrays Amanda.
Stepping into the role of Amanda marks Pfennigwerth’s first time performing in a feature film, she said. The Lawrenceville resident grew up attending Act ONE Theater School in Bellevue through secondary school. Then, she attended Point Park University, graduating in 2009.
Like Young, Pfennigwerth has “moved around quite a bit” in her career, she said, noting the experience of finding her path helps her perform as Amanda.
“Figuring out what I want a city to give me or what sort of path I want to take when I start in a new place is very much what Amanda’s going through right now as well,” Pfennigwerth said.
She was also involved in the short film-version of “I Swiped the Wrong One” shown in “The Haunting of Prince Dom Pedro.” Fishel found the actor on the auditioning database Backstage and asked her to be a part of the smaller film. Then he offered her a spot on the feature film version of the movie. Pfennigwerth suggested Young to direct the film, as the two are good friends.
The first time she read the film’s script, its dating theme immediately resonated with Young. She said there are people or jobs that may “work” in our own lives, but that doesn’t mean they’re meant to be a part of us.
“There’s a meme of a garlic clove and one of the cloves is missing and there’s an orange slice put into it,” Young said. “And in the little meme, it says, ‘Just because it fits doesn’t mean it’s right.’”
That’s the difference between average romantic comedies and “I Swiped the Wrong One,” Young said — two characters could work together romantically, but the film never stops asking if they truly do.
Young is also enjoys the movie’s setting because of her own roots. While the production crew was scouting filming locations, Young got to bring her favorite places from her “little neck of the woods of Pittsburgh.”
With her work on “I Swiped the Wrong One,” Young has had the opportunity to see more of Pittsburgh’s vibrant movie industry that she always knew existed.
“Truly, the indie film community is phenomenal here. Every time I go to set, I am just in awe of what we can bring back. Any time we play back anything, I’m always smiling ear to ear.”
Pfennigwerth said this film and crew are not to be taken lightly.
“I hope [viewers] take away the quality and the talent and the drive that this community has and then goes out and supports the independent showings as well as — if they want to — the big major Blockbuster movies.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.