The Kelly Critics is a joint program of the Post-Gazette and Pittsburgh CLO's Gene Kelly Awards for Excellence in High School Musicals, in which students at Kelly schools review musicals at other Kelly schools. Reviews are edited by senior theater critic Christopher Rawson. Click here for more reviews and coverage of high school musicals. Click here for the full Western Pennsylvania schedule of spring high school musicals.
What are follies girls from New York City doing in Nevada, and why are they teaching some hapless cowboys how to tap dance? Why, to save the local theater, of course!
This odd-sounding situation appeared on the stage of the Kelly Strayhorn Theater in East Liberty, where Westinghouse Arts Academy’s spirited production of “Crazy For You” showed just how crazy things can get when love is involved, and delivered on the truly madcap nature of the show.
The days of old theatre productions make a glorious and whimsically classical comeback in the form of “Crazy For You.” The show is loosely based on the 1930 musical “Girl Crazy,” which features George Gershwin’s music and his brother Ira’s lyrics. “Crazy For You” has all the makings of a classic musical with famous songs from other Gershwin musicals added to an actual Gershwin skeleton
The show is a tale of a boy, a girl, and a theater in need of saving. Bobby Child, the son of a New York banking family, who just loves dancing, is sent to foreclose the Gaiety Theater in the little town of Deadrock, Nevada. He falls in love with Polly Baker upon arrival. While Child has been engaged for five years, that’s not the real issue at hand. The real problem is that Polly is the very woman who is trying to keep her town’s theater open. A twisting and turning love story ensues, and while some points may seem predictable, “Crazy For You” delivers on all the comedy needed for a night well spent at the theater.
The show got off to a humorous start, with Bobby Child, played by Matthew Hommel, begging for an audition in front of illustrious producer Bela Zangler, played by Peter Kelley Stamerra. Hommel’s performance, with impressive comedic timing and a powerful voice, brightened every scene he was in, fueling the energy and pace.
While Hommel was running, singing, and tapping his way into the hearts of the audience, the momentum was supplied by Zangler’s Follies, a ten-girl troupe of dancers who seemed to arrive by clown car, livening up the old ghost town and keeping the production moving. The girls provided a nice balance to the cowboy-heavy town, and even though some of the male roles were supplemented by actual girls, it was all done with believable gusto and charm.
In their first scene together, Bobby and Polly kiss, run around, tap dance and waltz in “Shall We Dance?” The chemistry between Hommel and Aliya Pimental was smile-inducing and downright fun, with the pair matching one another’s energy levels while also complementing each other’s voices.
As Polly dodges advances from Deadrock’s saloon owner Lank Hawkins, played by Noah Kies, she falls in love with Bobby right back, the same heartless banker she’d denounced mere scenes before. But when she discovers Bobby’s identity, Polly too becomes torn. Pimental powerfully captures the melancholy felt in “Someone to Watch Over Me,” as Polly longs for one decent man.
Fun could easily be lost in the whirlwind of the story, but Westinghouse Arts snuck it into every nook and cranny they could. For example, Stamerra and Kies slid down metal siding before tumbling into a tap routine, and the cowboys played the Follies Girls like stand up basses in “I Got Rhythm.” As Bobby pretends to be Zangler, Hommel must alternate between his normal character and his impersonation. Hommel successfully distinguishes the two, especially as he shares his witty thoughts as Bobby to the audience while disguised as Zangler. And when two British tourists stroll into town, Lank struggles to comprehend what a croissant is, with Kies’ delivery leaving the whole theater laughing.
The epitome of Westinghouse Arts’ success came in “What Causes That,” as Hommel and Stamerra, both acting as Zangler, humorously drowned their sorrows together over their lady troubles in Lank’s saloon, smoothly harmonizing in a well choreographed, perfectly synchronized number.
I observed the audience in the lobby after the show concluded, and if everyone’s smiles were any indication, Westinghouse Arts’ performance was as fun as “Crazy For You” is over-the-top in all the right ways.
“Crazy for You” ran March 23-24.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.