With Americans spending 16-20 percent of their income on health care totaling $3 trillion a year, the Affordable Care Act doesn’t seem so affordable, says Steven Brill. His latest book, “America’s Bitter Pill,” explains the good, the bad and the ugly of how the ACA or Obamacare came to be and its implications for a health care system that should be in intensive care. The ICU was where Mr. Brill ended up when it was discovered that he needed surgery for an aortic aneurysm while he was writing this book.

The book is great but frustrating to read at certain points.

I know, I know. What I learned when I did the Time magazine piece is this is a subject everybody cares about, but everybody has not experienced it. The scene in the book where I ask the CEO of United Health Care to explain my explanation of benefits [letter sent to him after his heart surgery, which the CEO could not decipher]. Everyone dreams of doing that.

That fact that you did not get an answer was one of those frustrating moments.

Advertise with us

Hear more of this interview with Steven Brill.

I think it was an important moment because it is emblematic of how screwed up the system is. I mean, step back and think about this: Here is the single most important consumer product that all of us buy and here is the largest, most successful seller of that product [United Health Care], and the CEO of that company cannot explain the most basic, important, frequent communication he sends to the consumers of that product. God knows, the consumers don’t understand it. That tells you something about the health care system.

Since the middle class is bearing the brunt of the cost for Obamacare, it seems the Republicans, who oppose it, are now their champions.

Let’s see how much they champion the middle class, you know, if the Supreme Court rules that state-run insurance exchanges don’t allow for people to get subsidies. Let’s see how much the Republican governors who didn’t build their own state insurance exchanges champion the middle class when someone making $45,000 a year, who now is paying $250 for their insurance because they are getting a subsidy of $500, is told that because of the decision the governor is making they have to pay $750 or lose their insurance.

Those Republican governors better be careful what they wish for because it is one thing for them not to expand Medicaid, which affects poor people, but as you point out, the subsidies are all about the middle class. What you also identified is the subsidies themselves ultimately aren’t enough because — and the major point of the book is — the prices are all still too high. Insurance premiums are still going to be high. Even with subsidies, it is very difficult for people to be able to afford their insurance. That $250-a-month policy might have a $9,000 deductible. So they have to pay $250 a month plus $9,000 before they get their first dollar of health insurance.

Advertise with us

The self-employed middle-class families who have been told their cheaper plans do not exist anymore are really being hurt by the cost increase. In one case I know of, it’s going from $600 something a month to over $1,000 for a family of four.

But that $600 a month they were paying before is not insurance. In the book, there is a couple in Ohio who were paying $469 a month (self-employed). When he got cancer he found out that insurance policy he thought he had only covered him for $1,000 a day at the hospital. You can’t get weighed for $1,000.

So is it correct to say Obamacare stopped that kind of limit to care a policy provides?

Well, in a very clumsy way, and they sold it terribly and Obama over-promised. They basically eliminated that kind of faux insurance. It’s really clumsy politics, incompetent messaging on the part of the administration. The other thing they didn’t message was the fact that the subsidies exist. They were embarrassed that this is a massive income redistribution program. Which it is. Once upon a time, Democrats weren’t embarrassed by that.

Don’t you think it’s strange that a president who is known for being such a thoughtful, measured speaker didn’t get the message out clearly, and there was so little transparency in the process? It goes beyond over-promising.

Advertise with us

Well, I think you are right. Some of his policy people kept telling Valerie Jarrett [the president’s senior adviser] and other senior people, “He’s got to stop saying, ‘If you like your insurance you can keep your insurance.’” Because there are a whole bunch of footnotes and asterisks to that, such as if you like your insurance and it is a decent policy then you can keep it.

As you point out in the book, there are so many problems with the cost of health care that basically what the Affordable Care Act does is push more people into a broken system.

The problem with health care is the prices are too damn high. You can’t get around it. If someone sells you a box of gauze pads for $77 in a hospital, no amount of legislation is going to solve it until you do something about the $77 cost of gauze pads.

Isn’t that gouging? Aren’t there laws against that? Also, it is not the insurance companies who are making the money. It’s the hospitals, the drug manufacturers and the makers of medical equipment. Why aren’t doctors more upset since they are doing the work?

You know, that’s actually a really good question. When I talk to doctors they are sort of beaten down. First of all, they don’t know nearly as much about Obamacare as you do. Unless they are employees of UPMC, for example, this is just stuff that happens to them. It’s paper they have to fill out. They are victims of the system. In the 1950s and ’60s, the American Medical Association controlled the system. Now, GE and Siemens, which makes CAT scans and MRI equipment, have more power over the system than the doctors do.

Advertise with us

So we have identified the profit-makers, can’t we find a way to curtail the damage, reform the system?

The problem with cutting health care costs is you are taking income away from somebody. So if you are GE, or Pfizer or Merck and you try to cut into their income, they have lobbyists. The health care industry spends four times as much on lobbying in Washington as the military industrial complex. So you get the reform that they will allow. Obamacare is the kind of reform they will allow because it gives them tens of millions of new customers to buy their overpriced products.

Do you think hospitals should have their own insurance programs like UPMC?

I think they should, and what you need, and Pittsburgh would be the best example, is really tight regulation -- regulation of their profits and regulation of the salaries of the people who run the place. You need a really tough system so that if UPMC decides you don’t need that kind of care and you think they are skimping on your care, you can go to an independent regulator who can look at it.

I think the Jeffrey Romoff model, the way you eliminate the incentive for over-testing and over-treating and all that stuff is by having the provider be the insurance company, makes a lot of sense. [But] it only makes sense if you tightly regulate the monopoly that you are giving to them. As best as I can tell, in Western Pennsylvania no one has regulated that monopoly at all.

Advertise with us

In the book, you ask President Obama questions and he declined to reply to a few of them. Were you surprised by that?

I was stunned that he didn’t reply to the Valerie Jarrett thing. Stunned. It says she is the real chief of staff. Not only that, it sort of suggests he doesn’t want to insult her by saying she is not. I am just mystified by that. There are so many easy ways he could have answered that and not answered it. People told him from the beginning you have got to bring someone in to run this thing or it’s going to be a total debacle and he didn’t do it.

I thought, wow he knows this is going to be in print and yet he is not responding.

Explicitly, I told his press secretary I am going to print the entire Q & A, so if he doesn’t answer the question that is what I’m going to say. They said OK, we know that. OK.