On a snowy Tuesday night, five women gathered around a kitchen island in O’Hara to discuss the novel “My Friends” by Libyan author Hisham Matar.
Winter weather had depleted the book club to half its usual size, but still they came together.
While the scene might appear colloquial, they’ve been doing this for 40 years. The women met when they were in their late 20s and 30s. Four decades and almost 470 books later, they are still bonding over storytelling and friendship.
For these women, it has been a coming of age, a support group in their later years, a living anthology still being written.
“It’s very important as you get older to have that basis of friendship,” said Michelle Domeisen, 70, a retired commercial real estate broker.
It all started, somewhat improbably, with spaghetti on the ceiling.
Domeisen was visiting the apartment of her then-boyfriend when she met Nancy Geer, one of his roommates. She was standing in the kitchen, holding a mint julep, tossing strands of spaghetti at the ceiling to see if it was done. Geer’s hair was red then; now it is white.
The two became fast friends, and Domeisen connected Geer, a writer, to a job at KDKA-TV. They began talking about starting a reading group.
Domeisen and friend Karol Paltsios took a vacation to Japan to visit another friend living there. They were connected to Frances Wise, a woman 40 years their senior and a prolific reader.
After the Japan trip, the women held a planning meeting over lunch at a Downtown hotel in October 1986. They held the first book club meeting that November. The founding members were Domeisen, Geer, Paltsios, Pam Siewers, Barbara Clements and Wise, the matriarch of the group.
“It was the power ’80s,” Domeisen said, remembering the shoulder pads and suits.

Most of the members were working in male-dominated fields, single, forging their own paths, armed with confidence and unabashed intelligence. They became a support system for each other.
Today, the group’s 12 members each take a turn selecting a book, leading the discussion and preparing a themed meal.
On this particular Tuesday, Penny Williams, a retired physician, served tagine sfrani, a Moroccan lamb stew made with a Libyan paste. Club members also nibbled on cauliflower salad and homemade pita bread with ice cream and a cookie crumble for dessert.
“One of the best parts about the book club is that you are introduced to books that you never would have heard of before,” Geer said. “It’s fun if we like the book, and sometimes the discussion goes even better if you don’t like the book.”
Their tastes vary. Some members don’t enjoy biographies or nonfiction.
“I always like the book and the company is great,” said Geer, 71.
Most of the women were single and living in Shadyside when the group began. Over the decades, they have supported one another through marriages, divorces, illness and grief.
“We’ve seen each other through everything,” Geer said. “We’ve spent the past 40 years doing life together.”
That support has often extended beyond their monthly meetings.
When Geer was diagnosed with breast cancer 30 years ago and struggled to eat, club members showed up with meals for her family.
“My husband said we wouldn’t need that,” she remembered. “But he was the first one at the door letting them in. It was nice for my kids to see that you do that for your friends.”
More recently, when Domeisen delivered the eulogy at her mother's funeral, she looked out from the lectern at the packed church and saw her reading group.
“It matters to us,” she said.
The women have also gone through loss within their own circle, burying two members in recent years, including Wise.
“As we get to a period where we are experiencing deaths and some very sad things, we know we have each other,” Domeisen said.

The club’s meetings continued even during the COVID-19 pandemic. Their commitment is so steadfast that other things take a backseat, like travel.
“It’s sacrosanct,” said Arlene Carbone-Wiley, 76, a former research technician.
Her husband checks with her early when planning trips.
“If it interferes with the book club, nope we can’t go. I have a book club tonight,” she said. “ Australia will need to be postponed.”
The only time a member has left the club is when they’ve moved. One who moved to Florida had grown up in Medellín, Colombia. She once chose a book by Pablo Neruda and read it in Spanish.
“We have had so many wonderful different experiences,” Domeisen said.
Over the years, the group has read and discussed books on history, architecture and novels about World War II and the AIDS crisis. Choosing the right book comes down to a “gut feeling,” Domeisen said.
“Some books are good to read but not good to discuss,” she said.
The member hosting the monthly meeting is expected to share a deeper context about the author and themes that go beyond the text.
That intellectual curiosity has drawn the attention of established and emerging authors, including Ken Gormley, the president of Duquesne University and a childhood friend of Domeisen in Swissvale.
Club members have advised authors on manuscripts before they’re published and offered candid feedback and suggestions before final editions. Gormley thanked them in the foreword of his book, “The Heiress of Pittsburgh.”
“The idea of sharing it with people was scary,” he said.
However, as he got closer to turning in the manuscript, he felt he could trust the group to help make the novel better. Gormley received copious notes and was peppered with questions.
“It was fabulous,” he said. “This is not your ordinary book club.
“They were careful readers, and really perceptive. They were instrumental in bringing the book across the finish line.”
Meeting with authors “is a privilege that the group does not take lightly,” said Lu Donnelly, 74, an author and architectural historian.
Fellow club members showed up for her book launch party a few years ago.
They also give back through a philanthropy initiative. Around the holidays, they donate to organizations like the Women’s Center and Shelter of Greater Pittsburgh, food banks, schools and international aid groups. One year, the club helped a family who lost their home in a fire to purchase Christmas gifts.
Each member seems to have a lifelong affinity for reading. Domeisen remembers Nancy Drew books and the highly anticipated Scholastic book fairs at school.
Geer began reading after gaining a fascination for Harriet Tubman. She later majored in English and earned a master’s degree in literature from Carnegie Mellon University.
Other friends have occasionally expressed an interest in joining the club, but the maximum is 12 members, one for each month. Openings are rare. Before inviting a new member, the women look for a sense of humor, intellectual curiosity and most of all, a willingness to show up.
“One thing that is nice is that most of us are mothers,” Geer said. “And our children have all seen us go to book club and it has reinforced friendships and reading in their eyes.”
For the book club’s 25th anniversary, they traveled together to Seven Springs Mountain Resort. This time, they are considering something more low-key.
Members’ husbands play a special supporting role. They joke that Donnelly’s husband is the gold standard because he washes dishes and refills wine glasses. He was inspired to start his own book club and the group has been meeting for five years.
Soft cafe music hummed as the women discussed “My Friends,” a novel centered on exile, government oppression and lasting friendships.
Williams brought up the idea of the morality of lying and the need to do so to protect the people you love. She highlighted lines like, “Living in tyranny creates brave people.”
Their conversation centered on the book but sometimes cascaded to other areas of life.
For Domeisen, who has retired twice and has a love for philosophy and theology, the reading group offers the kind of intellectual engagement she treasures.
“It is a phenomenal place to stretch your mind,” she said.
A few days before the most recent reading, Paltsios and Domeisen were reminiscing about the book club through the years.
“This might be the most important era of the reading group, because we know we have each other,” Domeisen said.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.