Native American speculative fiction has been undergoing a renaissance in the last few years. The popularity of Stephen Graham Jones’s horror novels and the publication of anthologies such as Grace Dillon’s “Walking the Clouds” and Shane Hawk and Theordore C. Van Last Jr.’s “Never Whistle at Night” have introduced dozens of Indigenous writers to the mainstream reading public.
The result is nothing short of a seismic shift in the genre, as the boundaries of what makes arresting science fiction and horror are expanded by Native history and storytelling traditions. Carson Faust’s debut novel “If the Dead Belong Here” is a haunting addition to this growing canon.
“If the Dead Belong Here” opens with the vanishing of six-year-old Laurel Taylor from her bed in a small Wisconsin town. As the women in her family search for the little girl, the world begins to unravel and the walls between living and dead blur. Faust, an enrolled member of the Edisto Natchez-Kusso tribe of South Carolina, repurposes the aesthetics of the Southern Gothic to illuminate the haunting intergenerational trauma of colonialism.
The Faulknerian narrative roams between characters, geographies and decades as it roots out the colonial rot that lies at the heart of one family’s tragedy. Laurel’s mother Aditya falls into the arms of addiction as the vanishing reignites the trauma of losing her brother and the years of violent abuse by her ex-husband. Laurel’s teenage sister Nadine struggles to keep the search alive even as she is haunted by more than one ghost.
In between, fragments of the past interrupt the story, haunting the pages with the brutal history of Native dispossession — the removal of Native people from their Southern homelands, segregation, and Christian indoctrination.
Faust is deeply invested in grounding his novel in the specific lives of Native women and two-spirit people — he weaves many of his grandmother’s own stories into these pages, and they work to recover the true nature of horror. What we should fear is not the ghosts of the dead, but the brutality of the living.
While the novel is possessed by Native dispossession, those fragmenting wounds never sink the story. It is held together not the throughline of trauma, but the irrepressibility of Indigenous lifeways. Laurel and Nadine come from a long line of female Native healers whose root and water magic, we learn, was shared with them by the ucv’ske, a community of dwarf-like people noted in the folk stories of many different Southeastern Native peoples.
Convinced that the ucv’ske have taken Laurel, Nadine and Rosebud travel back to the Edisto river in South Carolina in search of the in-between — a land of shadows between the living and the dead — to save her.
The section that follows is the most lyrical of the novel. Faust uses horror tropes and style to weave together masterful descriptions of ceremony as three generations of women plunge into worlds of beauty and death to bring Laurel back to the living.
History is now, he tells us, water is medicine, power is a flower that grows only with the help of a certain kind of blood.
And while the ending avoids the cliches of redemption and triumph readers may hope for, it satisfies with a kind of solid embodiment as Nadine breaks from the legacy of family suffering to embrace a future grounded in her people’s deep knowledge. The novel teaches us that the living often haunt the dead, and sometimes the dead save the living.
“If the Dead Belong Here,” which was recently long-listed for the Center for Fiction First Novel Prize, introduces readers to a voice whose literary style and commitment to the vibrancy of Indigenous storytelling promises a future body of original, genre-bending work in the years to come.
Jennifer A. Howard is a fiction writer and academic who lives in Durham, NC.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.