Reading collected works of acclaimed poets should feel both revelatory and immersive, as if each turn of the page is a door opening into some life moment transformed through language and line break. It also allows consideration for the writerly obsessions that keep literary types coming back to the keyboard as age and experience can bring insight.
“Collected Poems of Stanley Plumly” furthers and succeeds in those goals — and features a terrific opening essay by co-editor (and stellar poet) David Baker that generously contextualizes Plumly’s aesthetic.
Plumly, an award-winner for both his verse and his critical work (focused mainly on John Keats), was an influential part of a generation of American poets that included the likes of C.K. Williams, Louise Glück and William Matthews.
Poems by these, and other standout poets of the time, share, as Baker puts it, “expansions of the lyric’s narrative and storytelling capabilities, a strong social conscience, and career-long engagements with poetic form, especially the line, rhythm, and the relation of idiom to technique.”
That Plumly, who helped start the MFA program at the University of Maryland, and these others would become “life-changing teachers” and expand an understanding of their craft through literary criticism is unsurprising.
What might be interesting to readers unfamiliar with Plumly’s oeuvre is how effectively he employs the “prose lyric” or “the complex manners by which he invests the lyric poem with ‘narrative’ values … location, character, action, the passing of time, the storytelling function image.”
In “The Ward,” Plumly leans into his battles with cancer through place and character: “The ones with wigs enter the sterile space/with their eyes cast down, the ones with/kerchiefs focus on the air straight ahead/of them — I still have my hair, though only in/a sort of slow-growth way, like frost on a stone.”
He measures the scene through simile and setting, getting the details right while finding “music of the spheres … to mitigate/the silence and kindness of the nurses./We are all alive, regardless, God save us./… All this, whatever else it is, is health.” Life and death remain the affirming currency of Plumly’s poetry.
The collected poems also highlight Plumly’s fascination with the Romantic poet John Keats, whom Plumly thoroughly researched in his acclaimed 2008 biography, “Posthumous Keats.” His engagement with Keats’ writing seems to come from the intersection of Keats’ letters to his brother George, his theory on “negative capability” that became “a pillar of Modernism,” as well as Keats awareness of his “posthumous existence” with his death from tuberculosis coming at the tender age of 27.
In fact, Plumly incorporates Samuel Taylor Coleridge’s grim account of briefly meeting Keats — “when I shook him by the hand there was death!” — into more than a few poems. Perhaps, this fascination comes from Plumly’s own heart-related issues as well as his father’s premature passing from cardiac disease which he memorializes in “For My Father, Dead at Fifty-Six, on My Fifty-Sixth Birthday.”
And while strangers, other poets and his parents play lead roles in Plumly’s work, it’s the observation and engagement with nature in the form of trees and birds that’s a noticeable thread running throughout poems like “Cedar Waxwing on Scarlet Firethorn,” “Cardinal,” “Magpie” and “Maples,” among several others.
In “Dutch Elm,” he refers to micro-fungi that’s wreaked havoc upon the elm and eulogizes the loss of their “towering cathedral branching/spread into a ceiling above the lonely sidewalks of Ohio…/I miss standing there, letting the welcome dark make me invisible.”
If anything, reading this collection cements Plumly’s worthy reputation, deserving the opposite of the central figure in “Woman on Twenty-Second Eating Berries,” where “No one will say your name, and when you come to/the door no one will know you, a parable/of the afterlife on earth.”
Fred Shaw is a visiting lecturer in creative writing at the University of Pittsburgh.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.