Edited by the Thurber Award-winning writer and Pittsburgh native Damon Young, “That’s How They Get You” is an eclectic anthology of stories, memoirs, essays, email chains, and text message conversations, all engaging Black American humor.

It’s a wild mix of narratives, jumping from themes and styles, coming from some of the biggest names in Black writing right now, coalescing into an engaging read of quick and punchy entries.

When looking at any anthology or collection, there’s an impulse to form some kind of hierarchy, to pick out the stand-outs from the duds, but in this case, I think such a task is pointless. The truth is, there’s no work here that feels out of place, boring or of significantly lesser quality than the others.

That’s to be expected. These writers are all on top of their game, each having a stellar portfolio of writing in their own right. And even if that weren’t the case, every one of the works moves by so quickly that it would be difficult to linger.

Advertise with us

I will admit, going into this, I was a bit skeptical. Not of quality, but of tone. Humor is hard enough to impart on page, and when a book presents itself as “An Unruly Anthology of Black American Humor” it could feel like a setup for too-high expectations.

Despite that, I found myself laughing hard and laughing often at what I was reading. This is a funny book, as advertised, no matter what else there is to say about it. One entry, “Group Chat” from Deesha Philyaw, is a downright hilarious story about two sisters trying to calm their mother down after she convinced their father to take Viagra.

It’s told in an inventive way, utilizing the format of text messages along with more traditional prose, while still producing some of the most laugh-out-loud lines in the whole anthology. The dialogue between the sisters is so natural that one would be forgiven to think it was pulled straight from someone’s cellphone.

Philyaw captures that stunned awkwardness of acknowledging how your older parents still have sex with an obvious glee, and it ends with a heartfelt moment between the sisters that impart some more somber and emotional notes on their bond.

Honestly, all the entries here, fiction or non-fiction, narrative or essay, fit a similar blueprint. Even something as out-there as Kiese Laymon’s entry, whose title is so crass as to be unprintable, fits into that kind of structure. It’s a dialogue told through emails, a back and forth about trying to find a good restroom to use in West Virginia.

Advertise with us

Laymon is funny and unrelenting, leaning into the frank vulgarity regarding the situation, being as blunt and stark about the dilemma as can be. And the story certainly drops some knowledge in the end, the kernel of truth that lingers with the reader, despite the crazy scenario that brought them there.

Still, as I read and reread the chapters in this anthology, I couldn’t stop asking the same question: “Who is this for?”

The introduction from Damon Young sets the stage for the following collection of works, telling the true story of a joke from his childhood that stuck with him, dissecting it and meditating on it. He goes on to describe how humor can be a weapon, a salve, a reflection, a catharsis, and so on.

He writes, “The best humor is constructed around a surprise-wrapped truth-like substance,” which I think would be an apt way to describe the laughs throughout the anthology. The only potential issue is the notion that it’s “surprise-wrapped.”

The trap of all comedy, especially Black comedy, is that there will be people who laugh at the joke without really getting it, people who will take the empty calories while ignoring the nourishment. But at the same time, the people who do already “get it” don’t really need to be imparted these revelations, though they’ll still appreciate the chuckles.

Advertise with us

For a few of the entries, you might, like I did, think you immediately got the joke right from the title alone. When coming to “The Karen Rights Act” by Mateo Askaripour, the title had me questioning if Karen jokes were still relevant in 2025.

Despite my reservations, it ended up being the funniest story in the whole collection. Following a world where, somehow, discrimination against anyone named Karen becomes legal, it’s a complete farce of whole controversy over the use of the name as a pejorative. The way it escalates and follows the scenario from Karens being turned away from bars all the way to civil unrest and internment camps. It’s wildly hilarious. But there’s not much in the way of surprise or unexpectedness.

Consider “The Jackie Robinson Society,” from “Daily Show” alum Wyatt Cenac. It leads with the joke from the title; what if there was a secret meeting of all the different Black people who were the first in their field, akin to how Jackie Robinson was the first Black MLB player?

The story tears through a litany of examples of such people throughout history, and it does with a righteous frustration. And with that comes the humor, the absolute absurdity of the various trials and hurdles faced by these people being shown as the ridiculous and laughable racist double-standards they are.

And while it made me laugh, it surely wasn’t “surprise-wrapped.” I think the story even knows this, with its final lines kind of acknowledging that, pointing out that the titular society is a place “Where we can share a knowing nod and even laugh at the frustrating, maddening, and downright dumb things we’ve had to put up with while white people ‘figure out’ some [stuff] we already knew.”

Advertise with us

That quote feels like an encapsulation of the entire anthology. Reading it felt like being in on a joke, understanding and laughing along to something I know all too well about. And I suspect for most other Black readers, it’ll be a similar experience.

The subject matter is familiar, the commentary is, too, but that doesn’t make it any less valuable or engaging. I still just come back to the question of what people will get from this book. Damon Young, again in the intro, says that “this book is a reminder. To leave shame behind. To leave respectability behind.”

And it does that.

I won’t go so far to say the entries in this book are more akin to lectures than narratives, but the deeper truths of these stories aren’t necessarily a surprise. As for the readers that don’t already know these truths, I hope they’re able to find them within these stories. I’m positive they’ll be amused and entertained as they turn each page.

I just wonder, though, when they close the book, what will they remember? The humor? Or the truth-like substance?

Advertise with us

Hopefully, both.

Stefan Zhael is a writer and critic from the Midwest.