In her new book, “Open Socrates,” Agnes Callard — one of the most influential public philosophers writing and lecturing today, and an Associate Professor of Philosophy at the University of Chicago — explores the life and thought of the Greek philosopher Socrates, so that she, as her subtitle says, can make “the case for a philosophical life.”
She begins by contrasting Socrates with Russian writer Leo Tolstoy, who at age fifty went through a crisis “caused by his inability to answer certain questions,” existential questions regarding why he cared about any of the things he cared about, or even why life was worth living.
Though Socrates engaged with similarly difficult questions, he used them as a lively starting point rather than a depression-inducing roadblock. Instead of lamenting that he “had no life,” Socrates embraced life and inquiry, presenting himself “as a person one can become.”
Socrates’ wrote nothing — in Plato’s dialogues he is an indefatigable instigator, one with an uncanny ability to productively engage with what Callard calls “untimely questions.” These are questions which “we need answers to” long “before we are prepared to ask them,” so we often postpone or even ignore them. We, like Tolstoy, allow inquisitiveness to get “ruled out in advance.”
But nothing stops Socrates; for him inquiry is endless. Her book asks what such a philosophical life requires, and where it leads us. Thinking should be a “communal feat,” and Socrates shows us how to succeed — with two people asking and answering those “untimely questions.”
In Chapter Five, Callard identifies the “Gadfly-Midwife paradox,” perhaps the most dramatic paradox associated with Socrates. It calls into question how he could be famously both a gadfly and a midwife, since “the negative project of avoiding falsehood” (the gadfly) seems in conflict with “the positive project of seeking the truth” (the midwife). Is he a split personality?
No, he is not, Callard concludes. Rather, our summary of Socrates has always been lazy: “It is easier to believe in the existence of two Socrateses than to believe that there was ever one person who denied that thinking is a private mental activity.”
There is a dual sense of poetic justice in Callard concluding “Open Socrates” by discussing death. First, as Socrates declares in the “Phaedo,” the dialogue that includes his death scene, doing philosophy “in the proper manner is to practice for dying and death.”
Second, Callard frames the discussion with a personal story — her friend Steve, a fellow philosopher, died prematurely a few years ago. Their relationship, based entirely on talking about their field of study, and her emotional reaction to his death, illustrate how being philosophical is not just a way of living, but “also a way of dying.”
She looks back on a conference organized to honor her friend, held before his memorial service, with an unusual realization: “the fact that we were dealing with our friend’s death made us philosophize better.”
A central myth of death involves us having to explain ourselves to a divine figure. Callard says this myth represents the point at which untimely questions “can be delayed no longer. Preparation for death is preparation for that time, and to do philosophy is to see that time as right now.”
Facing his death at seventy, Socrates continued doing what he’d always done — taking on “a project that is too big for a life.”
It’s not surprising that one engaged in such a project needs help. Socratic wisdom, often mocked as feigned ignorance and false servility, is true wisdom and humility. The key to unlocking it lies in recognizing that “in the presence of others, something becomes possible that isn’t possible when you are alone.”
To inquire is to engage, and vice-versa. In “Open Socrates,” Agnes Callard argues that the world would be a much better place if more of us lived the Socratic life.
Gary Ciocco is a traveling philosophy professor and poet who lives south of Pittsburgh.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.