In Jon Hickey’s much anticipated debut novel, “Big Chief,” Mitch Caddo, a member of the Passage Rouge Nation of the Lake Superior Anishinaabe, is counting on out-maneuvering the old saw that “You can’t go home again.”

Instead of making use of his Stanford law degree in D.C., he’s decided to return home to the tribe’s reservation in Wisconsin and get involved in local politics. This feels like a dangerous choice for Mitch, Passage Rouge is a mix of childhood nostalgia and much darker feelings, always leaving him to wonder if, as a “suburban Indian,” he really belongs there.

By throwing himself into his role as tribal operations officer and right-hand man to its President Mack Beck, he hopes to cure himself of what he refers to as his “existential shiver,” a kind of haunting physical response to all he’s suppressing by putting off deeper concerns about his life and identity in favor of short-term highs, such as the upcoming reelection campaign — a thing that is not going well.

Mitch soon finds, however, that the past cannot be put aside indefinitely, especially as his surrogate father and legal mentor, Joe Beck, is working to elect the opposition candidate. Joe was his mother’s friend, and when she died in an accident involving a drunk driver, it was Joe Beck who taught him how to be a legal member of the tribe and how to connect to the spiritual side of his legacy. It’s agonizing then that Mitch can’t help but see his mentor as a political opponent in an election that’s starting to turn nasty.

Advertise with us

What’s at stake in the novel is nothing less than the nuances of Native American identity in the Twenty-First Century. Or to use Hickey’s language from the novel: Who is a “real Indian?” In the election, this question is an issue for both candidates on the ballot.

Hoping to create actual change, specifically to clean up the Anishinaabe’s reputation both on the reservation and beyond its borders, Mack Beck’s administration, guided by Mitch, has been using “administrative exclusions” — disenrollment and banishment — to expel drug traffickers and violent criminals.

This is a practice left over from the previous administration, so while not unheard of, the scale on which it is being used is making many people nervous. Anyone expelled from the reservation for crimes might retain their freedom, but are no longer considered part of the tribe. As the election heats up, citizens gather in large numbers to protest this practice.

The opposition candidate, Gloria Hawkins, has her own problems with identity. She’s lived much of her life off the reservation and has on several occasions lost elections for governor of Wisconsin. She’s written a best-selling memoir and been “a go-to talking head pundit on Indian issues.” This celebrity, such as it is, does nothing to help the authenticity of her claims of being Anishinaabe. Instead, she’s thought of as pandering, the kind of Indian the “chimokomonaag, the whites,” would admire.

When Mack Beck wants to discredit Gloria Hawkins by viciously attacking her claims of citizenship on social media and employing administrative exclusions to banish her highest profile campaign supporters, Mitch has an important decision to make. Should he abandon all claims to even a “meager decency” by continuing his ruthless political maneuvers or should he listen to the voices in his head — his mother’s, Joe Beck’s — and rediscover the part of him that’s still a good man by switching sides and helping Gloria Hawkin’s campaign to victory?

Advertise with us

Torn between two ideas of how best to live — to embrace the norms of the culture outside the reservation or find a way to accept himself as Anishinaabe, is the toughest decision of Mitch’s life.

Fortunately, Jon Hickey (who is Anishinaabe) possesses a deft hand, and whether writing about tribal politics, family relationships, or the ever-important language of personal identity, “Big Chief” reveals Mitch as truly complex character, one who leans into ambivalence and asks of himself truly difficult moral questions.

In our current cultural landscape, what could be needed more?

Jeffrey Condran is the author of the story collection “Claire, Wading into the Danube By Night” and is the co-founder and publisher of the independent literary press Braddock Avenue Books.