About halfway through “Upon the Corner of the Moon” the character of Macbeth — who should be considered a slightly different figure (and perhaps closer to the historical Macbeth) than the character in his eponymously-named, Shakespeare-authored play — encounters a monk in his travels, and in their conversation a question is asked: “Tell me, can one man serve as another’s conscience? Can someone be the conscience for a king?”
This, in many ways, feels more like the question that Shakespeare’s play asks its audiences, whereas Nieman’s novel seems more interested in what the cultural and social apparatus and pressures of the 11th century might have had to do with how that conscience developed and, further, how such a question could come to be asked at all.
Nieman’s novel takes on the difficult task of giving us, as readers, access to a historical context for the Macbeth we know from the oft-performed tragedy, while also engaging us in a clear consideration of the political vicissitudes of a Scotland facing an inevitable religious confrontation between the old ways the new.
The story wanders back and forth between the perspectives of Macbeth and Gruach, who will eventually become Lady Macbeth. It also happens in an entirely linear fashion, with the perspectives and speech patterns of both characters growing and changing as they do. This brings, for a reader, a fascinating blend of emotionally-charged and dramatic moments in a narrative heading toward a final scene that, ostensibly, every reader will anticipate (if they, indeed, remember their high school English classes).
This intense and honestly affecting scene-building Nieman does is the real power underscoring the book. We see a young Macbeth become half-brother to an older and somewhat smug Duncan. And, in the entirety of their relationship throughout the book, which involves each one helping, saving, and learning to love the other, we can’t help but be reminded of the violence and betrayal that will eventually conclude their story.
Gruach, too, has so much to do in her own attempts to survive a world in which she’s been sold off to the most expedient bidder. Nieman doesn’t shy away from the complications of Gruach’s sexuality and the repression of this patriarchal world caught between the two almost-tidal forces of ancient, native Scottish practices and the encroaching Christian context.
A warning to readers that the brutal treatment Gruach receives at the hands of her eventual-husband Gillecomgan is not for the faint of heart and brings this historical fiction directly into the sights of our contemporary fascination with the likes of “Game of Thrones,” and the sexual violence that viewers found there.
Beyond even the survival of these abominations, we see Gruach imprisoned in a larger cage — men’s expectations and distrust of women. In one scene, Duncan, listening to a conversion with the Latin tutor Oswald, advises Macbeth “No doubt it was women’s counsels that persuaded Aethelred to abandon his armies…beware such advice, my gentle brother, whether from a woman or a monk, or find yourself similarly disgraced.”
Such is the world that Gruach must continually battle throughout the novel, including her own salvation at the hands of Macbeth, and her business-like marriage to him.
In Act III of Shakespeare’s Macbeth, our tragic character admits to his wife “so full of scorpions is my mind.” For a playgoer, either early-modern or contemporary, those scorpions feel contained within the play itself: We understand what rends at Macbeth and the guilt at those choices.
Nieman’s novel does something very difficult to pull off — it shows us where those scorpions began, and how they were once the loss of a father or the abuse of husband, and how they burrowed deep within these characters and waited, patiently, for the moment they would come alive again and haunt them.
Nieman’s “Upon the Corner of the Moon” is a haunting and bloody tale of Scottish history. It’s also a finger tracing along a set of scars, ones we already know are too deep to ever really heal.
Matthew Minicucci is a poet and essayist. He is an assistant professor at the University of Alabama.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.