
Well into this year’s presidential election rematch, a substantial number of Pennsylvanians still harbor doubts about the outcome of the 2020 election — roughly four in 10. It’s an alarming statistic for a battleground state that could tip the Electoral College.
Donald Trump’s election disinformation campaign from that year (which has been exhaustively disproven), has made it increasingly difficult for the American public to objectively assess its voting systems.
Any discussion is partisan: One side rightly acknowledges that no evidence of widespread voter fraud exists but wrongly dismisses all updates to the election system; the other side deploys conspiracy theories to justify election claims that occasionally hit on a vein of truth.
DISPROVEN: MY UNBIASED SEARCH FOR VOTER FRAUD FOR THE TRUMP CAMPAIGN, THE DATA THAT SHOWS WHY HE LOST, AND HOW WE CAN IMPROVE OUR ELECTIONS
By Ken Block
Forefront Books ($28)
This unfortunate discourse is the ideal context for Ken Block’s “Disproven: My Unbiased Search for Voter Fraud for the Trump Campaign, the Data that Shows Why He Lost, and How We Can Improve Our Elections.”
As the man tapped by the Trump Administration to find voter fraud nationwide, Block came face to face with just how broken American voter data truly is. And he was often forced to watch his painstaking findings skewed or misconstrued by the very administration he served.
Block acknowledges there are cases of voter fraud that likely go undetected; however, without the partisan mud-slinging, these failures of the election system can be seen as something much more comforting: rare instances of failure caused not by a conspiracy, but by inconsistent data collection and poor record-keeping.
In other words, fixable issues that don’t represent a democracy on the brink.
This levelheaded outlook is refreshing and weirdly reassuring, a kind of “third track” that current debates seem unable to acknowledge because it’s, well, boring. But let’s not devalue the benefits of “boring.”
In 250 pages filled with dense analysis of voter data trends across states, Block easily identifies the crux of the issue, which is record-keeping and data-sharing. States and their little laboratories of democracy administer elections in very different ways, sometimes differing down to the counties and municipalities. With a system this fractured, something as simple as tracking whether a voter has moved between states is nearly impossible.
“Different states and counties implement the same laws and rules differently, yielding a chaotic result for our national elections. None of this means our elections are corrupt, or that an election loss can be blamed on these inconsistencies,” Block writes. Unfortunately, his findings were regularly distorted or taken out of context by the very people he was painstakingly explaining his results to.
After Block struggled valiantly to garner enough election data to assess duplicate mail-in voter fraud, only a measly 167 cases were found nationwide. Block was actually expecting more, as this was during a time when Trump was actively encouraging supporters to vote twice, by mail and in-person, ostensibly to “stress-test” the system.
So when it came time to turn these 167 double votes to law enforcement, the Trump administration, realizing that the president’s recent statements cast an unfortunate light on double voters, told Block they “did not want to bring attention to such a small amount of fraud.”
In another case, Block was able to locate two ironclad cases of voter fraud in Pennsylvania. He brought them to the attention of Bernard Kerik, a close friend of Rudy Giuliani who supported Trump’s election fraud propaganda. (He was also personally pardoned by Trump for committing massive tax fraud — but Block is a gentleman, and never mentions this).
When Kerik found out that the two fraud cases were actually committed by registered Republicans, he told Block that “it would be taken into consideration, I guess,” before going on to falsely claim that “thousands of fraudulent votes had been cast in the election.”
Block is not bitter enough to ruminate on these monumentally frustrating details. He explains exactly where his findings begin and end, and asks readers to dig deeper if they like. This type of steely decorum is clearly what recommended him for this thankless task in the first place.
This book isn’t for those looking to wallow in outrage or to bolster deeply-held beliefs. Instead, “Disproven” is for people in public policy, for leaders, for politicians and activists. It’s for people who need the stark, black-and-white facts presented to them so they can actually fix what’s wrong. Ken Block has done his job. Now it’s time for our election officials to do theirs.
Rebecca Spiess is a Pulitzer-prize finalist and the associate editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: rspiess@post-gazette.com or on X at @RebeccaSpiessL.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.