The Great Migration was an American watershed straight out of the Old Testament. The mass exodus of 6 million Black Americans from the Jim Crow South was an epochal event that inspired scores of memoirs, histories and sociological studies.
Mostly overlooked, however, is an even bigger migration that occurred at roughly the same time. From World War I until the 1960s, an estimated 8 million poor white Southerners poured into the upper Midwest, seeking job opportunities and better lives. They gravitated to industrialized centers like Detroit, Chicago, Cincinnati and Muncie, Indiana, where they reshaped economies, values and politics in ways that still reverberate today.
“HILLBILLY HIGHWAY”
By Max Fraser
Princeton University Press ($32)
Max Fraser, an assistant history professor at the University of Miami, examines their diaspora in his fascinating new book, “Hillbilly Highway: The Transappalachian Migration and the Making of a White Working Class.’’ A former journalist, Fraser draws on government reports, industry archives, oral histories and other sources to document the Southern migrants’ transformative impact.
“Transappalachian migrants were at the center of many of the defining events of the period – from the country’s explosive industrial development around the turn of the 20th Century to the rise of the modern industrial labor movement during the 1930s and 1940s; from the unfolding of the postwar urban crisis to the decisive political realignments that transpired over the course of the 1960s and 1970s,’’ Fraser writes.
The poor white newcomers faced hostility. Northerners pelted them with hateful epithets that echo the invective directed at present-day immigrants. “Hillbilly’’ was one of the nicer putdowns. At various times they were called “scabs,’’ “snake-eaters,’’ “foreigners,’’ “worse than Negroes’’ and “a problem population.’’ In a 1951 survey, Detroit residents named “poor Southern whites’’ as the most “undesirable’’ group in the city. Only “gangsters’’ and “criminals’’ rated lower.
Fraser’s discussion of the economic conditions that prompted so many Southerners to flee their homeland echoes the conclusions Steven Stoll reached in his excellent 2017 book, “Ramp Hollow: The Ordeal of Appalachia.’’ Long story short: Poor families that had survived for generations on subsistence farming had their livelihoods destroyed when out-of-state syndicates invaded Appalachia to plunder the land for coal and timber. Those industries created a temporary uptick in employment, but both were played out by the early 20th century, leaving the region with no jobs and spoiled land.
“And so, at a rate that would increase steadily over the years – from the tens of thousands per decade at the turn of the century, to the millions per decade by the midpoint – poor and working-class residents of the rural Upper South would begin making longer journeys in search of employment outside of the region,” Fraser writes.
The dispossessed Southerners used various interstates to make their escape. From Mississippi, they took Route 45 through western Tennessee and Kentucky and up to Chicago and Milwaukee. Kentuckians followed Route 23 to Cincinnati and Dayton; West Virginians took U.S. 35 to Columbus and U.S. 19 to Akron and Northeast Ohio.
Seeking safe harbor, many of them crowded into the same urban neighborhoods already occupied by other Southern transplants. These enclaves, such as Over-the-Rhine in Cincinnati, were notorious for high poverty and crime, nuisance bars and storefront evangelical churches. The rise of Ku Klux Klan in Indiana and other states was blamed on the influx of white Southerners.
Fed-up politicians and civic leaders tried to address the urban blight through anti-poverty programs and other measures. They largely failed. Black organizations, leveraging public sympathy for the Civil Rights Movement, reaped more of the benefits.
“There was more than a little irony to the fact that Southern Appalachian migrants, who had played such an important role in the prehistory of the War on Poverty, now found themselves increasingly overlooked by the federal programs they had helped inspire,’’ Fraser writes.
Increasingly disillusioned by 1960s liberalism, working-class whites expressed their discontent by moving away from the Democratic Party. Southern segregationist George Wallace’s stunning victory in the 1972 Democratic presidential primary in Michigan augured the rise of Reagan Democrats in the 1980s and, today, Trump Democrats.
Fraser concludes with an insightful look at how the Southern migration introduced “hillbilly’’ music to Northern audiences, expanding its appeal and turning it from a regional sound into a popular national format. Homogenized, urbanized and rebranded as “country’’ music, it now traffics in nostalgia for generally nonexistent times and places — an underpinning it shares with the right-wing populism that took root in the late 1960s, Fraser notes. Jason Aldean fans may or may not disagree.
Steve Halvonik is a former Post-Gazette reporter and editor.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.