
When I was younger, I dreamed of writing all kinds of works. I wanted to write short stories told from a thousand different perspectives, books that ranged from historical fiction to deeply researched nonfiction — and perhaps a few fantastic poems, as well. I see the same desire to write broadly in my creative writing students now; they bemoan that their works often focus on the same type of character, or share a common narrative stance, or, despite the best abilities, come back to the themes that have always suffused their work.
MEN BEHAVING BADLY
By Tim O’Leary
Rare Bird Books ($26)
I’m older now, and I’m usually happy to have just written anything at all, no matter if it feels like I’m banging the same drum over and over again, across the years. And I tell my students that most of us, try as we might, cannot get out from under our obsessions: on some level, most of us write the same thing, on repeat. You can run away from the writer you are, but you’ll either stop composing anything at all, or find out that you’re writing about the exact same topics you always do, only in space, or in the past, in space in the past.
I know this sounds like a grim prologue to my review of Tim O’Leary’s new story collection, “Men Behaving Badly.” But I often enjoyed this slim little book, even if the author’s obsession holds no sway over me. Mr. O’Leary has an abiding interest, and it’s right there in the title: each story does feature a man, sometimes a couple, behaving terribly. It was refreshing to read a book that dug into the author’s topic of choice rather than attempting to circle far away. But, in attempting to be cohesive, short story collections can feel like too many variations on the same melody, and the repetition can become wearying.
Mr. O’Leary’s main characters usually share a sense of being put out to pasture by society, as well as a rebelliousness against that feeling. Sometimes their acting out is pretty benign (and funny), as in the first story, “Made Man,” about a rancher who moves to an Arizona retirement home at the end of his career, only to find himself entangled with an apparent mafioso.
But in other stories, that simmering sense of anger at being overlooked boils over, as in “Raging,” in which a world that looks not too dissimilar from our modern America is in the grip of a pandemic of violence and anger, which gradually seeps into and overtakes the man in its center.
“Raging” is the second story in the collection, and I sensed that Mr. O’Leary and his editor were leading off with their strongest plays. After that, the stories slightly blurred together, despite disparate plots and settings. In most, there’s a sense of inevitability, a feeling that, sorry though he might be to say it, the author feels that men inevitably become angry, embittered, and alone. It’s hard to distinguish one of those dudes from the next.
In the tales that don’t end that way – when an old man becomes a vigilante in the rollicking “The 100-Year-Old Sheriff” or a normal guy ends up with a movie star in the gossamer-thin “The Pass List,” I got the sense that Mr. O’Leary felt they might have ducked their fate. At times, as in “Reunion,” the story didn’t even make narrative sense, so eager was Mr. O’Leary to make his point about the essential awfulness of men.
The hits get played a lot. The stories often (not always) include guns, fisticuffs, bellowing, and women characters who exist solely as the girlfriend or the wife. There are several snakes in the book. There’s fishing. Weapons and cars are occasionally described with Tom Clancy-like precision. Slurs and stereotypes are dispensed liberally (heh), especially about women and LGBTQIA people. It would be foolish to be surprised or offended, I suppose. It is a book about (and I suspect, mostly for) men, after all, and don’t men like those things?
And yet, I can think of few men that I know who would recognize themselves in these portraits of befuddlement and rage. My male buddies are often kinder, more observant, and less militant than the men in this book, even when they’re well past both 60 and their glory days. From my colleagues at Pitt to the high school friend I chat with at the mechanic’s, they seem much more engaged with life in all of its possibilities than the guys in this book.
In the end, Mr. O’Leary’s topic is both his blessing and his curse here: the stories are mostly page-turners, funny and irreverent, and occasionally offer real, if limited, insight into the male mind. And yet a little of his type of main character goes a long way, and in the end, I was ready to close his book and have a more nuanced, thoughtful chat with a male friend about books, or trees, or television. Anything, really, except snakes, guns, and the simmering rage of being over 40.
Shannon Reed is a teaching associate professor at the University of Pittsburgh, and author of the forthcoming book “Why We Read: On Bookworms, Libraries and Just One More Page Before Lights Out” (February 2024).




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.